This past week’s podcast guest—psychotherapist Connie Zweig—put together an anthology in the early ‘90s called Meeting the Shadow, a compilation of excerpts and essays from Marie-Louise von Franz, Audre Lorde, Ken Wilber, Joseph Campbell, and others—including, of course, C.J. Jung, about Jung’s theory of the unconscious. She also included a piece by psychiatrist M. Scott Peck, who wrote The Road Less Traveled, a book that spent a decade on The New York Times bestseller list and has sold more than seven million copies since it published in 1978.

I’d seen this book—I think my parents owned a copy—but always dismissed it because, I dunno, its title comes from a Robert Frost poem that’s oft-quoted, oft-misinterpreted, and ultimately, kind of a cliché. But his essay in the anthology intrigued me because it was not treacly at all: He wrote about evil and power. And so of course I needed to read his bestselling book.
I understand why The Road Less Traveled is a mega-bestseller: It’s at times bracingly honest and keenly observed, with some well-placed client sessions. And perhaps it’s because of my ongoing work with Courtney Smith (podcast episode here) on The Drama Triangle (more on this below), but a few sections lit me on fire, namely where Peck lays out the thesis of the book, which essentially revolves around whether your see yourself as capable of solving the problems in your life, or are more interested in sidestepping responsibility and placing blame on external factors. As he writes, “Most of us are like children or young adolescents; we believe that the freedom and power of adulthood is our due, but we have little taste for adult responsibility and self-discipline. Much as we feel oppressed by our parents—or by society or fate—we actually seem to need to have powers above us to blame for our condition. To rise to a position of such power that we have no one to blame except ourselves is a fearful state of affairs.” (304) He argues that this is why most people are not long for therapy: Too much responsibility.
I mean, he’s right. It’s much easier to see yourself as being at the mercy of the world, where events happen to you (below the line) rather than as its creator and director, where life happens through and by you (above the line).
Here’s Peck:
“We cannot solve life’s problems except by solving them. This statement may seem idiotically tautological or self-evident, yet it is seemingly beyond the comprehension of much of the human race. This is because we must accept responsibility for a problem before we can solve it. We cannot solve a problem by saying ‘It’s not my problem.’ We cannot solve a problem by hoping that someone else will solve it for us. I can solve a problem only when I say ‘This is my problem and it’s up to me to solve it.’ But many, so many, seek to avoid the pain of their problems by saying to themselves: ‘This problem was caused me by other people, or by social circumstances beyond my control, and therefore it is up to other people or society to solve this problem for me. It is not really my personal problem.’” (32)
And then, for all of us who love self-diagnosis (and diagnosing other people), he offered this simple breakdown: “The neurotic assumes too much responsibility; the person with a character disorder not enough. When neurotics are in conflict with the world they automatically assume that they are at fault. When those with character disorders are in conflict with the world they automatically assume that the world is at fault.”
Thinking about this in the context of being below the line on The Drama Triangle (Victim, Villain, Hero), the neurotic is most likely to enter the triangle as the Victim, the person with the character disorder as the Villain. Though as we’ll see, it’s not quite that simple.
Peck elaborates:
“Even the speech patterns of neurotics and those with character disorders are different. The speech of the neurotic is notable for such expressions as ‘I ought to,’ ‘I should,’ and ‘I shouldn’t,’ indicating the individual’s self-image as an inferior man or woman, always falling short of the mark, always making the wrong choices. The speech of a person with a character disorder, however, relies heavily on ‘I can’t,’ ‘I couldn’t,’ ‘I have to,’ and ‘I had to,’ demonstrating a self-image of a being who has no power of choice, whose behavior is completely directed by external forces totally beyond his or her control. As might be imagined, neurotics, compared with character-disordered people, are easy to work with in psychotherapy because they assume responsibility for their difficulties and therefore see themselves as having problems. Those with character disorders are much more difficult, if not impossible, to work with because they don’t see themselves as the source of their problems; they see the world rather than themselves as being in need of change and therefore fail to recognize the necessity for self-examination.”
Okay, back to The Drama Triangle, which I recently had the chance to workshop, gaining a whole new perspective on how this dynamic enfolds. I had assumed that when you are below the line (aggrieved, upset, world happening to you), that you used the triangle by understanding which role you are occupying (Villain, Victim, Hero), and then who, correspondingly, was playing the other two parts in your upset. So, in other words, if my husband and oldest son, Max, are arguing about homework and its getting intense, then I would identify my husband as the Villain, my son as the Victim (Rob would probably say it’s the opposite), and I would get to be the Hero, rushing in to soothe everyone’s impatience and help Max get his work done. But as I learned this week, when you’re below the line, when you’re the victim of life, you typically play all three roles, shifting around the triangle as you process your upset. So, while I love that Hero role, I’m likely being the Villain and Victim, too (blaming Rob, feeling helpless). In terms of the languaging Peck provides below, the neurotic and the person with the character disorder are both below the line and both Victims on the triangle. Here’s how the Conscious Leadership Group defines each of these roles from the victim-position, when you’re below the line. (And yes, it’s confusing because there’s a double victim, but stick with me.)
This is CLG’s definition of the Victim position: “Victims see themselves as ‘at the effect of’ people, circumstances and conditions. They often experience themselves as disempowered. You’ll know you’re in the Victim position if you feel powerless to effect change. The Victim plays out its role by a declaration of pain and suffering, as well as defeat. The Victim often complains and whines and/or argues for why it can’t have what it wants. Once in this role, the victim is able to feel unique, as it waits for someone else to fix the problem.”
Courtney, who coaches this process, elaborates that Victims will say things like: “I’m trying,” “I’m so tired and confused,” “I don’t know what else to do,” “This is so hard,” and “I have to…”
This is CLG’s definition of the Villain position: “The Villain focuses on blame. They blame themselves, an other or ‘them.’ You will know you are in the Villain position if you feel your position is the right one, and you only search for evidence that supports your claims. The Villain’s main goal is to find fault, and identify who caused the problem. The Villain plays out its role by declaring that it ‘knows’ and is ‘right’ thus stifling open discussion and keeping attention on the problem.
Courtney explains that Villains will say things like: “Here’s how we got into this mess,” “I screwed up,” “We have to do it this way,” “You just don’t get it.”
This is CLG’s definition of the Hero position: “The Hero seeks temporary relief. The hero looks for suffering inside or outside of itself. But rather than feeling helpless, like the Victim, the Hero assumes that it is able to control or change the situation. Thus the Hero reacts to pain by finding temporary ways to make it go away. Heroes act with an expectation of reward; specifically that you or others will ‘feel better’ because of your deeds. Heroes play out their role by applying a ‘solution’ to the ‘problem’ in order to avoid feelings or discomfort.”
Courtney suggests that Heroes will say things like: “I’ll help you figure this out,” “I can handle this,” “It’s easier if I just take care of this.”
Does it not feel like we’re watching The Drama Triangle unfold across social media on the daily? And is it not strikingly easy to determine—often from childhood patterning—where you’re most comfortable entry point is to this Drama Triangle?
You can order Drama Triangle cards from Conscious Leadership Group (author of The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership, which I’ve written about many times)—they delineate all the corresponding personas and what those personas say, along with what the persona requires. For example, on the Victim card, one persona is The Worry Wart, who says, “This could be a problem,” and needs “Irresponsible people, an uncertain future” in order to enter The Drama Triangle and do their thing. The cards are fantastic, because you can put them on the ground and role play your scenarios out, and move yourself around as you shift from blaming external factors or yourself (Villain position), to feeling helpless and sorry for yourself (Victim position), to offering fixes and distractions to make the situation resolve (Hero position).
Another important thing to remember: Transcending the below the line Drama Triangle isn’t the point either. Courtney and company think we spend 95% of our time below the line—the trick is to get conscious of the fact that you’re in The Drama Triangle and then to move to the center of the triangle by understanding what the underlying fear is…which is usually fear of loss of control, fear of loss of security, or fear of loss of approval. That’s how you break the cycle. That, and as Peck offers above, perhaps therapy, if you’re willing to stick with it.
Here he is to take us home: “It is not an easy transformation. As soon as they realize that they will ultimately be required by the process of psychotherapy to assume total responsibility for their condition and its cure, most patients, no matter how eager for therapy they initially appeared to be, will drop out. They choose rather to be sick and have the gods to blame than to be well with no one to blame ever again.” (295)
I hope this wasn’t too confusing—thanks, as always, for reading. (Here’s the original Drama Triangle interview with Courtney.)
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
1/4: Embracing the Shadow with Connie Zweig, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/26: What motivates change with Carrie Wilkens, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/21: The power of trauma narrative with Akiva GoldsmanApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/17: Reducing harm and saving lives with Maia SzalavitzApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/14: The malleability of the brain with David EaglemanApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/10: Breaking the addiction binary with Carl Erik Fisher, M.D.Apple | Spotify | Transcript
12/7: The Gordian Knot of mental illness with Rachel AvivApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/3: Reimaging recovery with Holly WhitakerApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/30: Grappling with Part X with Phil StutzApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/22: On cultivating creativity and abundance with Richard ChristiansenApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My New York Times bestselling book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.