I heard Courtney Smith might be one of my soulmates for years before we finally met—not only because we have the same taste in people (we have many dear mutual friends), but also because she’s an Enneagram genius, and the sort of person who is happy to talk about G.I. Gurdjieff and the Fourth Way at a cocktail party. Courtney has a robust coaching practice—individuals, executive teams, women’s groups—where she integrates the Enneagram (she studies with Russ Hudson), trainings from the Conscious Leadership Group, the Alexander Technique, and the Work of Byron Katie, with her own perception and raging intelligence. Courtney is brilliant, particularly at assessing systems on both the micro and macro level, and she’s also exceptionally warm, excavating all of our human foibles and patterns for the treasures of promised growth. My favorite part of Courtney though is that she plays against type: I love finding the mystical and metaphysical in a woman who has a degree in mathematical economics from Wake Forest, a masters in Public Health from New York University, and a J.D. from Yale Law School. (Courtney also worked as a consultant at McKinsey & Co.)

Courtney workshops the Enneagram in an entirely unique way—and will be joining me on the podcast soon for an exploration of how she understands this system (and how we can each mine it for expansion), but in the interim, I asked her to take us through the Drama Triangle, and what she means when she talks about living below-the-line versus above-the-line. I mentioned the Drama Triangle dynamic a few weeks ago, from my very limited perspective and many of you asked for more. Below, Courtney explains why it’s such a useful and essential tool. What’s particularly beautiful about her explanation is that she doesn’t demean or diminish the Drama Triangle—this is not about escaping ourselves to be an “above-the-line” version all the time—it’s simply about coming to understand what’s driving how we relate to each other and the world.
(As for the Enneagram, I covered many of the basics with Susan Olesek on Pulling the Thread, the founder of Enneagram Prison Project—if you’re curious about the system, that’s a good place to start. FWIW, I’m particularly passionate about the Enneagram, not only for its ability to psychologically profile, but also because it has mystical roots—one of the early fathers of the Enneagram is Evagrius Ponticus, the same desert monk who first wrote down the “Eight Demonic Thoughts,” which became the Seven Deadly Sins. Each sin is associated with an Enneagram type, plus Deceit and Fear to make nine. If you don’t know your Enneagram Type, I’d recommend the RHETI test, developed by Russ Hudson—it’s $12 and takes about 40 minutes.)
A Q&A with Courtney Smith
ELISE:
First, can you define above-the-line and below-the-line?
COURTNEY:
Above and below the line is a concept that I learned from Diana Chapman and her fellow colleagues at Conscious Leadership Group. It’s a really simple way of orienting yourself to how you’re experiencing the present moment. Most of the time, we spend a lot of time thinking about the content of what’s happening. Oh, my daughter’s graduating. Oh, you have this book that’s out. But the idea of above or below-the-line in the present moment is not just the content we’re talking about. It is also how you’re relating to that content. And above and below-the-line makes a very simple distinction, which is this: If you are below-the-line, in some aspect of your body there is the presence of fear or threat. It can be tiny or it can be really big.
ELISE:
And is fear or threat just part of our biology? Is that just how we’re wired?
COURTNEY:
Yes. When you think about it, this is a smart survival strategy for our species. Orienting to scan for fear and threat is a smart way to ensure you stay alive. But it does mean that we experience threats even in the most simple situations. And in fact, if we get really, really honest with ourselves about how we’re relating to reality, most of the time there is a little bit of threat there, a little bit of fear.
ELISE:
I don’t want to sidetrack us, but I always have this reaction, and this might be because I’m an Enneagram Type 1—and I won’t drag us into the Enneagram, we’ll save it for the podcast—but whenever someone unexpected calls me or texts me, my immediate reaction is that I’m in trouble. Is that Type 1, or is that just human?
COURTNEY:
[Laugh.] Yeah, I think that’s not universal. I think it’s common, but I don’t think it’s universal. [Laugh.] For purposes of simplifying, because then that helps us have a working model we can actually use and apply in our regular life, in this above or below-the-line construct, we really talk about only three very basic fears that are present and operating in our bodily system.
The most basic one is fear or threat to your security. And this is your physical and emotional well-being, or the physical and emotional well-being of those you care about. Then, there’s fear or threat to approval. What are people thinking about me? And as a social creature, at some level we register that it matters to our survival what people are thinking about us. And then the third one is a fear or threat of loss of control. And control is a way of making sure nothing bad happens. At the end of the day, they’re all related to a threat to loss of security. Typically, we find the following:
1. I’m afraid something bad is going to happen.
2. I’m afraid you’re going to have an opinion of me that I am not comfortable with.
3. Or, my plan for what I think should happen is under threat.
ELISE:
Can you define the Drama Triangle, and then its relationship to being below-the-line?
COURTNEY:
If, as a species, we’re predisposed to be below-the-line, 95%, 96%, 97% of the time, the question is: Why do we care? Why are we even talking about this? And the reason we care is because, when there is a signal of threat running through our body, it's really, really uncomfortable for us. And so almost immediately, unconsciously, we begin to filter reality, and we begin to respond to reality in a way that is trying to make that fear and threat feeling go away.
And so, the reason we care about identifying whether we're below or above-the-line, is at some level our system is getting hijacked around an agenda of creating a feeling of safety in the body. And that's a normal human need. But if that's how we're experiencing reality, and that's the thing we're trying to solve for as we go through reality, we are going to show up in a particular way that actually doesn't allow us to change, allow us to grow, allow us to find a novel solution, allow us to take into account broader needs, or broader wants and desires. Because everything now is oriented around threat.
And so, one of the tip-offs that we are seeing life from below-the-line versus above-the-line, is this: Are we in a recurring pattern? Because a recurring pattern is a sign that the way we've been acting has been trying to reduce feelings of fear, rather than to actually look at the situation with fresh eyes and make a move from there. And so the pattern keeps repeating, because the way we show up is just to make ourselves feel safe. We don't actually change the underlying conditions that have caused the situation to present itself in the first place.
And so the Drama Triangle, which is a concept that was created by Steven Karpman in the 1960s, and again, something I learned through Conscious Leadership Group, is that when we are seeing the world through a lens of threat and in these recurring patterns, there are three roles that we assign ourselves and others. These roles are all about experiencing life and reacting to the feeling of threat that reality seems to be foisting upon us.
Another shorthand for saying I'm experiencing life from a place of threat, is I'm at the effect of reality. Something's happening and I'm scared, and I need to respond and react to what's happening, because I'm at the effect of the fear it's creating in my body. The Drama Triangle then is all about the roles I adopt when I feel at the effect of life.
The first role in the Drama Triangle is Victim. There are real victims in the world, where things have happened to them. But what we're talking about here is a broader mindset of being at the effect of the world and relating to it as a Victim.
And so, the Victim feels a lack of agency and a powerlessness and lack of ability to assert and change reality. The other two roles within the Drama Triangle are flavors of experiencing life as a Victim. The second one is the Villain. And when the Villain feels threat in their system, they develop a very strong belief about who is to blame. And a very strong belief about what needs to change, what needs to happen, in order for this feeling of threat to go away.
ELISE:
Is the Victim identifying the Villain, or you can just show up and be a Villain looking to project blame?
COURTNEY:
Typically, each of us has a preference for where we enter the Drama Triangle, and that's your own psychological patterning. But we don't necessarily stay in one place. We can bounce around and inhabit both Villain and Victim, for example, at the same time.
So I might be in the Drama Triangle because I feel I am at the effect of what’s happening politically in our country. I feel powerless to change it, and so I'm inhabiting the role of Victim. And at the same time, I’m quite certain about what needs to change and who's at fault, and so I’m assigning the role of Villain to “those people” who don’t see the world through my eyes.
So there's Victim, and there’s Villain, who's going to blame and be very certain about what's right or wrong. And then the third role is the Hero. And the Hero basically is going to try to relieve the feeling of fear in the situation, for themselves and for others. And the Hero does this in two ways: they either come up with a distraction strategy for themselves or others, something to help soothe and ignore how uncomfortable this situation is. They might use drugs or alcohol, or they might distract themselves with overworking, or say things like: “This isn't that big of a deal, I can handle this, it's going to work out okay.” It’s an effort to minimize the situation. Or the Hero is going to swoop in with a solution that looks like it's going to fix the situation, but in reality is just fixing the feeling of discomfort, and so it's actually only a temporary fix.
ELISE:
Got it. Well, I know where I tend to come in on that Drama Triangle.
COURTNEY:
What's your preferred spot?
ELISE:
Hero. And so, if I come in as the Hero, am I always then inherently looking for the Victim and the Villain in the situation? Or you're saying I would shift myself into those spots?
COURTNEY:
You will shift yourself sometimes. And if you are playing the role of Hero, in order for you to play the role of Hero, you need a Victim. You're going to see the world, and treat other people in the situation either as Villain or Victim, so that you get to keep playing your Hero role.
ELISE:
That makes so much sense. And so, is this tendency an immutable trait? Is this just part of who I am as an Enneagram Type 1? Is this is how I'm structured, or is this a learned behavior?
COURTNEY:
I think it's some of both. We tend to gravitate towards what feels familiar to us, and that can be an orientation toward innate strategies that we came into the world with. That would be a function of our Enneagram type, and every Enneagram type has a flavor of Hero and Villain and Victim that feels comfortable to them. At the same time, inhabiting the Victim, Villain, or Hero is also a learned behavior that can arise out of the roles we played in our family unit.
ELISE:
Got it. And then within a family dynamic, or an entrenched work situation, or any number of patterns of people that you are intimate with or very familiar with, is it the sort of thing where you, let's say you have a mom who likes to be the Victim, or that's her role. Then do you switch typically between Hero and Villain? Is that what happens in family dynamics?
COURTNEY:
Yes. Yes, exactly. That’s part of why it's a learned behavior, because depending on what the roles were that your parents tended to inhabit, you were forced to play a different role in order to make the triangle work.
ELISE:
In intimate relationships, is it a problem if you and your partner both tend to prefer the same role? Or is there a polarity that's required in order... I know it's probably not good for the Drama Triangle to exist, but can we be too similar?
COURTNEY:
It will tend not to be that way where you’re vying for the same role. So here’s an example. If my son forgets to take his homework to school, and then calls me from school and says, "I forgot my homework," I can be the Hero, and leave my work meeting and drive the homework to the school. And I might collude with my husband, and see him as the Hero, where we both do that and we take turns. When my son forgets his homework on Monday, I'm the one that gets it, and on Tuesday my husband does it. We can collude and both be Heroes. Or I can also make my husband the Villain and say to myself, “I have to go and take my son his homework. This wouldn't have happened if my husband had done what he was supposed to last night and made our son put his homework in his backpack. I've told him a hundred times, put it in the backpack, and he didn't do it. And now I'm the one that's going to have to fix it.”
ELISE:
This sounds very familiar.
COURTNEY:
What I've done now, is my son has not learned the consequences of what happens when he forgets his homework. And so, I've created a situation where he's going to continue to forget his homework in all likelihood. But as the Hero, I'm going to get lots of validation potentially, when I stop by the school, and his teacher and the principal sees this mommy who is able to put everything down in the middle of a workday and bring her son his homework. And I may get praise for being so dedicated to the role. And so, there is a payoff I'm getting around being Hero, in terms of reducing any fear or threat of disapproval. People may like me and think I'm good at being a mom, but I'm setting up a situation that's going to recur.
ELISE:
And so how do you break the below-the-line Drama Triangle dynamics? I'm assuming that the healthy above-the-line is to recognize what's happening, and to resist the Drama Triangle? Is that the goal, to step out of it?
COURTNEY:
This was a big switch for me when I learned this. When I teach people about above and below-the-line, and about the Drama Triangle, they see themselves and they go, "Ugh, I don't want to be here." But the thing about the resistance to the Drama Triangle, is at some level that resistance keeps us from being honest about what we're really up to. As counterintuitive as it is, the first step is actually to allow, and admit your humanity, and even have fun with this crazy thing that we humans do over and over again. And to catch yourself in the Drama Triangle. And there are all kinds of fun strategies that I have learned and that I teach around making the Drama Triangle bigger, making it comical, in order to soften our resistance to it.
Because then, if we choose to shift out of it, it's not coming from a place of I'm a bad person. It's almost like you can be below-the-line about being in the Drama Triangle. When you use shame to move out of the Drama Triangle, that would be a shift that's more about alleviating the discomfort of judgment, as opposed to genuinely wanting to learn and relate to the world differently.
ELISE:
I know that we can't change people. Is there a way to bring people's awareness to this underlying pattern? Or is it one of those things where if you're really entrenched in a Drama Triangle, the only way to change it is to step out of it and collapse the Drama Triangle—and maybe in the process, lose the relationship?
COURTNEY:
The first thing is to get really comfortable with identifying fear. Because threat is what takes us below-the-line in the first place. Before we even talk about Hero, Villain, and Victim, really the fundamental seeing of reality is to see how scared we are. And so, to use this situation of my son and his homework, for me to see that I care what his teacher thinks, I care that my son might be seen as an irresponsible student, I care maybe that my husband sees that my first priority is our kids.
And so to get really clear: Oh, this is actually what's driving my behavior, that it’s: I'm scared of this. And then just even seeing the fear, and accepting that it’s a normal, human way to be in life. And now I can put that fear aside and say, Okay, do I want to solve this situation from fear, or do I want to solve this situation from a different place? And if I were to solve it from a different place, what is actually the right thing to do?
ELISE:
That's deeply resonant. Because that instinct around fear is so intense, right? I really didn’t realize that the Drama Triangle was mutable, and that we move around within it. I thought it was a pattern that you could stamp on a relationship and identify the people. Not that you came into every situation embodying one of those roles. So is there an above-the-line corollary?
COURTNEY:
Yes, and it’s called the Empowerment Triangle. So, let me start by saying that the Empowerment Triangle, where life below-the-line is, I'm at the effect of the world, I'm at the effect of reality, life above-the-line is reality is by me, reality is created by me and for me.
ELISE:
Ooh, I love that.
COURTNEY:
Yeah, there is a claiming of radical responsibility for your relationship to reality, your own well-being. And of course, there are things that we cannot control about what is happening, but how we make sense of reality and relate to it is always under our control. And so therefore, we take responsibility.
And so with the Empowerment Triangle, the Victim becomes the Creator, the one who is taking responsibility for their experience. And there are a bunch of tools around asserting what you want, being able to tolerate fear, and comfort in the unknown. The Villain becomes the Challenger, which is all about, instead of blaming people, getting people to face what's really happening and to face their role in the system.
ELISE:
That’s so interesting, just to think about the people I know who can flip between the below-the-line version of that, and then the above-the-line version. It’s slippery, right?
COURTNEY:
Yes, that’s part of the dance—once you are able to spend some time up there above-the-line, it is catching yourself when you drift below. Because it'll be instantaneous, the flipping back and forth. And so, you can feel both that Challenger and Villain flavor. And then the Hero evolves into the Coach. The Coach is all about empowering another to stand for what they want.
ELISE:
I love this, it's really beautiful.
COURTNEY:
It is beautiful.
ELISE:
I love the light vs. darkness of it too, and how our preference is to always be above-the-line. But how important it is to embrace that we are mostly below-the-line. I think there's this attachment to light in a way that's dishonest at times.
COURTNEY:
Yes, the allowing and the being okay with both. When I work with people to take radical responsibility, literally their posture changes, the tone of their voice changes, and it’s extremely powerful.
At the same time, it’s important to honor that there are actually many payoffs to life in the Drama Triangle. Sometimes there is a lot we have to risk if we take radical responsibility for the quality of our lives, and we may not yet be willing to do that. Part of the growth process is not rushing out of the discomfort that arises when we realize that we’re approaching life from the Drama Triangle because that’s where the learning and change and shifting of old behaviors occurs. When we make friends with our location—whether it’s above or below-the-line—we see that both tendencies, both mindsets are very human. We can’t aspire to stretch and shift to life above-the-line unless we respect, allow, and even value the very good reasons why that’s not where we tend to start, why that’s not our default experience of reality.