I wanted to dig back into the work of Ken Wilber in today’s newsletter, specifically the way he breaks down our culture into transcenders vs. descenders in a way that is deeply clarifying—in his camp, we must be both in order to actually embody nonduality. In my first post about A Brief History of Everything, I explored some of the key themes from his work a few weeks ago: holons (the idea that everything is both complete in of itself and part of something else); holarchies (holons are structured on an evolutionary chain that becomes more densely conscious as it evolves, i.e. a bat is more conscious than a banana); and all systems can be arranged in a quadrant where the top is singular (I/It), and the bottom is collective (We/Its), the left side is the personal (I/We), and the right side is empirical (It/Its). You can read more about this here.

In the coming weeks, I’m going to write more about Wilber’s work, including why what’s happening in psychedelics gives me some pause. I’m a fan in most therapeutic instances, but Wilber makes the point that you can ascend to a higher state of consciousness through drugs or some other expansive experience without actually…achieving a higher stage of consciousness. I have some concerns that people don’t get this, have a big experience, and then they believe that they are…divine, special, here to single-handedly save the world, ya know, GOD, without any context or any of the essential inner work to actually evolve. But I digress. (This also dovetails with all my posts about darkness and tapping into energies that we don’t understand: Here’s Understanding Spiritual Power, When Communities are in Shadow, and Understanding Collective Darkness.) I’m also going to write how Wilber’s theory of evolution—transcend and include—applies to our current political quandary, hopefully without getting over my skis.

In A Brief History of Everything, Wilber breaks down the past 2,000 or so years—the span of Judeo-Christian Patriarchy—into a battle between Ascenders and Descenders. There are the Ascenders, or those who believe in the fall, that there’s nothing but depravity here on this planet, and our sole goal is to get to heaven, somewhere else, up above; and then the Descenders, who believe that material reality is the only thing that exists, that any form of faith is a type of delusion.
Here’s Wilber:
ASCENDING:
“It’s at least a two-thousand-year-old war, often brutal and always rancorous. In the West, from the time roughly of Augustine to Copernicus, we have a purely Ascending ideal, otherworldly to the core. Final salvation and liberation could not be found in this body, on this Earth, in this lifetime. I mean, your present life could be okay, but things got really interesting once you died.”
DESCENDING:
“The idea that the sensory and empirical and material world is the only world there is. There are no higher or deeper potentials available to us—no higher transcendental stages of consciousness evolution, for example. There is merely what we can see with our senses or grasp with our hands. It is a world completely bereft of any sort of Ascending energy at all, hollow of any transcendence. And, in fact, as is usually the case with Descenders, any sort of Ascent or transcendence is looked upon as being misguided at best, evil at worst.”
THE PROBLEM WITH BOTH:
“We all know the downside of the merely Ascending path: it can be very puritanical and oppressive. It tends to deny and devalue and even repress the body, the senses, life, Earth, sexuality, and so forth.
“The Descending path, on the other hand, reminds us that Spirit can be joyously found in body, sex, Earth, life, vitality, and diversity. But the Descending path, in and by itself, has its own limitations. If there is no transcendence at all, then there is no way to rise above the merely sensory; no way to find a deeper, wider, higher connection between us and superficial facades, which separate us much more than join and unite us. Without some sort of transcendence or Ascent, we have only the Descended world, which can be shallow, alienated, and fragmented.”
Here’s the thing about our reality structure: We love binaries. We live for binaries. It’s very hard for us to embrace the nondual, that our world can contain all of these concepts and they don’t negate each other at all. Rather than searching for a paradigm that’s large enough to contain all paradigms, we choose instead to try to edge out the competition. We struggle to accept that science and spirituality are not mutually exclusive but might be explicating the same thing with different language (I would argue that we’re getting close to a unified way of describing both). Most markedly: We seem to believe we can escape this current reality instead of accepting that this is where we are. We’re here. We need to engage with it, exactly as it is, rather than wishing it were something else entirely.
Wilber goes into a lot more detail about the specifics of a descending vs. ascending point-of-view, arguing that one of the primary pitfalls of both schools of thought is the way we perceive ourselves as separate, either culture-of-humans-as-crime-against-nature (descenders) or as spirits-entrapped-by-nature (ascenders). Wilber’s point is that it’s one of our essential flaws to imagine ourselves as other. Are we nature or are we not? Is nature not part of the all?
Here is Wilber: “First, nature is supposed to be the one single reality of which all organisms, including the human, are part. In this sense, nature is absolutely all inclusive, nothing is outside of it. It is the ultimate and all-embracing reality, and everything that occurs is an activity of this ultimate reality. But two, culture is supposed to have deviated from this nature. Culture has to some degree split itself from nature. Culture, in fact, is ruining nature. So now we have two natures: a nature that you can’t deviate from, versus a nature that you can. And clearly they can’t be the same thing. They sneaked in two natures.” (p. 263)
Wilber seems to be asserting that we are all of these realities—ascending and descending in this great chain of being that passes energy up and down—not divorced from this reality structure and not supposed to be superceding it. Instead, we are living it. And all of our global and collective problems—particularly climate change, polarization, et al—is beckoning us toward transcendence, specifically to transcend and include…within this reality structure.
Gaia’s main problems are not industrialization, ozone depletion, overpopulation, or resource depletion. Gaia’s main problem is the lack of mutual understanding and mutual agreement in the noosphere about how to proceed with those problems. We cannot rein in industry if we cannot reach mutual understanding and mutual agreement based on a worldcentric moral perspective concerning the global commons. And we reach that worldcentric moral perspective through a difficult and laborious process of interior growth and transcendence. In short, global problems demand global consciousness, and global consciousness is the product of five or six major interior stages of development. Simply possessing a global map won’t do it. A systems map will not do it. An ecological map will not do it. Interior growth and transcendence, on the other hand, will do it. (p. 285)
And it’s not enough for a few of us to transcend through interior growth—many of us have to. If not most.
I finally picked up Wilber after Father Richard Rohr dropped a bunch of hints about how much Wilber’s philosophy means to him—and how coherent it feels as a construct or context for containing it all. Here’s Rohr in Falling Upward: A Spirituality for the Two Halves of Life:
“The gift of living in our time, however, is that we are more and more discovering that the sciences, particularly physics, astrophysics, anthropology, and biology, are confirming many of the deep intuitions of religion, and at a rather quick pace in recent years. The universe really is “inspirited matter,” we now know, and is not merely inert. Now we might call it instinct, evolution, nuclear fusion, DNA, hardwiring, the motherboard, healing, growth, or just springtime, but nature clearly continues to renew itself from within. God seems to have created things that continue to create and recreate themselves from the inside out. It is no longer God’s one-time creation or evolution; rather, God’s form of creation precisely is evolution. Finally God is allowed to be fully incarnate, which was supposed to be Christianity’s big trump card from the beginning!” (p. 93)
This idea of evolution from within is the transcend and include impulse in Wilber’s model, the idea that we continue to roll forward and get bigger, finding ways to bring all other holarchies with us. In the “We” sphere, or the collective, we have moved in time from archaic, to magic, to mythic (many organized religions are stuck here or at magic), to rational (we’re primarily here), to pluralistic (we’re moving here), to centuaric (we need to get here). And on the “Its” side of the collective, we’ve moved from tribes, to tribal/village, to early state/empire, to nation/state, to planetary, to global. We keep getting bigger and bigger with a more expansive view.
I want to close this out with Rohr again, who writes:
“Mature religions, and now some scientists, say that we are hardwired for the Big Picture, for transcendence, for ongoing growth, for union with ourselves and everything else. Either God is for everybody and the divine DNA is somehow in all of the creatures, or this God is not God by any common definition, or even much of a god at all. We are driven, kicking and screaming, toward ever higher levels of union and ability to include (to forgive others for being ‘other’), it seems to me. ‘Everything that rises must converge,’ as Teilhard de Chardin put it.” (p. 109)