I’m back on a horse in Montana this week—going fast and not breaking things—which means I’m getting to spend four hours a day talking to people who are not part of my immediate circle. Podcast listeners have probably heard me talk about these rides, but I treasure them, as they’re a too-rare opportunity to engage with people who sometimes see the world in the same way that I do, and sometimes don’t. I don’t know if our nervous systems are being recalibrated by being in nature on horseback, but despite political differences, we usually find a pretty substantial Venn diagram of shared values and friendliness—and not by avoiding the issues. Maybe it helps that I have yet to hear any of the conservatives in my midst this week even attempt to offer a defense of this administration—everyone seems to be concerned about cruelty, autocratic tendencies, and over-reach—but these weeks always remind me that there are broad swaths of overlapping agreement for almost all of us if we can only talk to each other IRL.

A couple of weeks ago, I made a video on Instagram about the need to build wide and vast alliances—to form a coalition of resistance. This is something that we’ve struggled to do on the left in recent years, choosing to alienate and exclude people who are not in perfect lock step with us on every issue. In times like these, purity politics won’t cut it—we don’t have to agree on everything to agree on most things, or even enough things. Collectively, we need to grow ourselves up to both see and embrace this. Not only is it possible to work with people who don’t hold the same views as us, but we must.
In the video, I talked about Rutger Bregman’s book Moral Ambition—Rutger’s episode of the podcast is coming out in a few weeks—and how idealism is typically a losing strategy. It’s not effective unless you’re willing to compromise, collaborate, and do what you need to get the ball down the field. As he explains, “The only kind of person we can’t use in this fight is the fool who thinks good intentions are enough. Someone whose clear-eyed convictions put them squarely on the right side of history, but who achieve little in the here and now.” It might be hard to hear, but I get it. I do think that many of us engage in a type of social narcissism—that our own rightness and moral perfection is a more important measure of our lives than pragmatically and flexibly pushing and acting to leave the world in a better place than we found it, even if it falls a little short of our ideals. You know, progress over perfection.
Bregman makes this point with a story I had never heard, about the British abolitionist Thomas Clarkson who managed to persuade the British empire to end its involvement in the slave trade. He wasn’t able to accomplish this by convincing the powers-that-be that enslaving people is monstrous and immoral; he tried that for a long time without success. Clarkson ultimately succeeded by moral reframing. He shifted his approach to focus on and publicize what was happening to the sailors on the slave ships. Yep. He managed to win people over to his cause by talking about the victimization of the perpetrators.
As Bregman writes, “Sailors died in greater proportion than the enslaved. British seamen were especially vulnerable to tropical illnesses and subject to a brutal economic logic. ‘Because they were laborers rather than a capital investment,’ wrote one historian, ‘slave ship sailors were more disposable than the captives.’ If a great deal of his crew were dead on arrival, many a captain was not bothered. After all, you didn’t have to pay a dead sailor.” Once the British public learned this, their outrage created the necessary momentum to achieve the goals of the abolitionists—it just came via very different means.
There’s something for us to learn here: We need to find commonalities where we all perceive harm. (For more on this, there’s my conversation with moral psychologist and professor Kurt Gray, author of Outraged.) We would also greatly benefit from holding a baseline vision for our future—and then work hard to invite as many potential bedfellows to our side as possible, accepting that “good enough” is good enough for right now. We can’t die on single-issue mountains anymore. We need a mountain range, one that’s sturdy and flexible enough to hold all of us in coalition without insisting that we stand in the exact same place.
Because here’s the thing: The far-right is masterful at this. We are seeing their long-term planning and strategy play out in real time. We need to take notes.
I keep thinking about Phyllis Schlafley, for example, the subject of the Cate Blanchett vehicle Mrs. America. For those who don’t know about Schlafley, she was a brilliant, far-right nut job who had a real passion for nuclear weapons and defense policy. But she’s most famous for stopping the ratification of the ERA (Equal Rights Amendment) in the ‘70s, a bi-partisan action that passed congress in 1972 and simply needed to be ratified by 38 states over the following decade. (She also participated in getting Nixon to torpedo the Universal Childcare act in 1971, another bi-partisan effort that would have changed the lives of working parents.)
Passing the ERA really shouldn’t have been a problem: It had wide support and was not seen as particularly political. Women deserve equal protection under the law, amirite? But Schlafly saw a cracked door and an opportunity to make a name for herself and build vast amounts of political influence by generating a movement to stop it. She wanted to demonstrate that she could build, lead, and flex a coalition of conservative women in order to build political power for a seat at the table that she actually wanted to sit at—and she collaborated with a lot of unsavory groups to make this happen. Her ultimate goal: Build enough power to get appointed as the ambassador to the UN. Taking on “the women’s issue” was a means to an end.
And wow was she effective. And not in the way you might think. If her own behavior is a barometer of what she found appropriate for women, she definitely didn’t believe that a woman should be confined to the home (she was a mother of six, worked incessantly, traveled constantly, wrote The Phyllis Schlafly Report, as well as six books).
As Barbara Ehrenreich writes in The Hearts of Men, “At the victory party for the defeat of the ERA, Schlafly attributed her side’s victory to their greater self-confidence as women. The feminists, she said, ‘are victims of their own ideology; they believe that women can’t do anything, that women are oppressed. But we of course know we…can go right out and do anything we want.’”
Schlafly developed the movement not as a moral one, but almost exclusively as a financial one anchored to ideas of guaranteed safety and security (the initial groundswell of anti-ERA women were concerned that their daughters could be drafted). She wasn’t opposed to abortion, for example, because of her concern about the rights of the fetus. It wasn’t a moral issue for Schlafly: She opposed abortion because she thought it let men shirk financial responsibility for their offspring as a “get out of jail free” card. She rallied the anxiety of women by talking up the divorce rate and suggesting that all men would bail on their children and families given any opportunity. She argued that women absolutely could not relax external constraints on men—and that equal rights would create a loose leash. (Their rallying cry, STOP, was short for: Stop Taking Our Privileges.)
Here’s Ehrenreich again:
“If she read the antifeminist literature available to her, the average woman who lobbied against the ERA with offerings of home-baked bread or future votes was remarkably well-informed about at least one sociological datum, the divorce rate. If, in addition, she did some thinking about her own chances of making a living as a self-supporting wage earner (and she would have to do this thinking on her own because the antifeminist literature is studiously silent about women’s collective disadvantage as wage earners), she would have formed a terrifying sense of her own vulnerability. The slightest outward ripple from the sexual revolution or the human potential movement could be enough to dislodge a husband from his marriage and catapult his ex-wife into sudden, midlife downward mobility. Faced with such a possibility, a woman could, quite sensibly, decide that the feminist promise of eventual economic equality was so much pie in the sky. Better, perhaps, to check the forces that allow men to think they have no natural obligation to support women, and one of these, clearly, was feminism itself.
…
“To antifeminists who focus on the issue of abortion, it is the possibility of sex without babies that has undermined male responsibility. After all, if pregnancy is ‘a woman’s choice,’ as feminists insist, what’s to prevent men from thinking that it’s also a woman’s responsibility? In a 1980 speech offered ‘in defense of the Christian family,’ anti-abortion leader Mrs. Randy Engel presented the view that, ‘men desire sex without responsibility. They become unmanly and frightened by the thought of having to assume economic responsibility for a family: They instinctively try to escape.’”
Pretty fascinating stuff. And totally backwards. Isn’t it interesting that men and feminists ended up at odds, rather than as allies? Not only was Schlafly’s platform so demeaning and diminishing of men, but men were not the ones driving the movement to end the ERA—or, for that matter, to insist on enduring inequity. Yet somehow, we continue to find ourselves in a gender war. For a moment there was even a men’s movement that understood that their welfare—really our collective welfare—relied on financial equity for women…after all the idea of a middle-income single-income family went poof in the ‘70s.
In The Movement, journalist Clara Bingham pulls together a history of second-wave feminism, weaving together the words of those who were central to its narrative, often pulling from the public record. (You can hear her on Pulling the Thread: “The Women Who Raised Consciousness.”) Bingham included the below from Schlafly:
The Phyllis Schlafly Report, February 1972, “What’s Wrong with ‘Equal Rights’ for Women?”
“Women’s lib is a total assault on the role of the American woman as wife and mother and on the family as the basic unit of society. Women’s libbers are trying to make wives and mothers unhappy with their career, make them feel that they are ‘second-class citizens’ and ‘abject slaves’ … They are promoting abortions instead of families.
Why should we trade in our special privileges and honored status for the alleged advantage of working in an office or assembly line? Most women would rather cuddle a baby than a typewriter or factory machine…
Women’s libbers do not speak for the majority of American women. American women do not want to be liberated from husbands and children. We do not want to trade our birthright of the special privileges of American women—for the mess of portage called the Equal Rights Amendment…
And why should the men acquiesce in a system which gives preferential rights and lighter duties to women? In return, the men get the pearl of great price: a happy home, a faithful wife, and children they adore…Let’s not let these women’s libbers deprive wives and mothers of the rights we now possess.
Tell your senators NOW that you want them to vote NO on the Equal Rights Amendment. Tell your television and radio stations that you want equal time to present the case FOR marriage and motherhood.
This is so wily. “Why should the men acquiesce in a system which gives preferential rights and lighter duties to women?” Egads. We have to learn how to play a smarter game. The idea grates against our idealism, I know, but look at where we are.
Like so many of you, I’ve been thinking hard about where we all go from here. I don’t really have any answers aside from the belief that we have to move past awareness into action and get organized in increasingly flexible ways. We need to grow our tolerance for collaborating with people who see the world from different perspectives. We have to looking for unifying commonalities rather than “disqualifying” differences. We have to stop morally excluding people and start including everyone with whom we can find even a plank of agreement. It’s a start.
In Moral Ambition, Bregman offers six myths about how change works: 1. The illusion of awareness. (Most of us just stop here.) 2. The illusion of good intentions. (Not everyone sees the world in the same way.) 3. The illusion of right reasons. (The example of Clarkson above.) 4. The illusion of purity. (You’re never going to build a coalition with complete cohesion.) 5. The illusion of synergy. (This is our belief that if someone is for X, then clearly they must also support Y.) 6. The illusion of inevitability. (The belief that change invariably happens and for the better.)
As an antidote, he offers the four ingredients for Moral Ambition—and has used the books proceeds to set up The School for Moral Ambition to help seed this type of thinking.
They are:
1. The idealism of an activist
2. The ambition of a start-up founder
3. The analytical mind of a scientist
4. The humility of a monk
So here we go. If you have these qualities, it’s time to get to work.