“Listen, are you breathing just a little, and calling it a life?” — Mary Oliver

I open On Our Best Behavior with a description of my breathlessness: My battle with chronic hyperventilation began in my 20s, sending me once to the ER and often to bed. Despite all sorts of interventions, it’s been a specter in my life, waiting for the right stew of sleep deprivation, over-caffeination, and amorphous stress to land in my body so it, too, can descend and haunt. For the uninitiated, chronic hyperventilation does not present as manic breathing: I’m not huffing and puffing into a paper bag. I am over-breathing, but in an imperceptible way. Meanwhile, my body is convinced I’m not getting enough oxygen specifically because my over-saturated lungs won’t allow me to take a deep breath. Instead, I hit a wall on the inhale, a wall I can only climb by yawning. And that only works some of the time. It’s very disorienting—and if you don’t know what’s happening, scary. While you feel like you’re dying, you appear merely sleepy. I can do this for weeks, sometimes months at a time. And I have no way to stop it in its tracks aside from trying to get enough sleep and hoping it will pass. I’ve been coached to attend to “stress,” which for me is evasive and elusive. The thing is, I have endured many “stressful” events without struggling to breathe: Meanwhile, I can start hyperventilating on vacation. I’ve never found a direct cause-and-effect; the randomness only makes it more haunting.

i love you text on pink and white polka dot background

In many ways, On Our Best Behavior is an exploration of this specter, just at the edge of my peripheral vision, this feeling that if I don’t move fast enough, if I don’t do enough, I will surely die. I wrote the book, in part, to understand what’s been chasing me all these years, making me feel unsafe, not secure, and like I’ll never be good enough.

I read a book called No Time to Panic last week by ABC News chief national correspondent Matt Gutman (out September 12) and then interviewed him for Pulling the Thread (our conversation will be out with the book). Matt has a different variety of anxiety than I do—he has a panic disorder—which sometimes takes him out at the knees. Typically, this happens in high-stakes situations: He’s had many panic attacks while on air, delivering the news. What’s most notable is that these terrifying episodes are generally imperceptible to the audience: He’s experiencing inner turmoil and loss of control, even while his body switches into mechanized cruise control and gets him through the talking points. I’ve experienced the same cognitive dissonance: “I can’t function right now, so why am I functioning? Why can’t anyone tell that I feel like I’m dying?”

Matt’s slim tome is an examination of fear, including consultation with many experts, like Stanford neurology and biology professor Robert Sapolsky (author of Behave). Matt explores its sacred, protective benefits, and buckets fear into two loose groups: Fear of bodily injury, death, et al. And then fear of social exclusion: In our long history, banishment spelled death. Matt believes his fear coincides with the latter.

As we chatted, we mused about how we both lack much fear in the first bucket: As an award-winning reporter, Matt has beamed into our living rooms from tough spots. He got his start in Gaza. He’s constantly putting himself into dangerous situations, causing many of his friends to wonder if he has a death wish. While I would never willingly venture into a war zone, I’m not a particularly scared person either: I still like to go fast on horses.

While Matt and I both know how to contend with physical threats, the amorphous ones, not so much. We’re both good at making our bodies perform, and yet we both suffer from bodies that go off the rails, specifically during moments where we need to be mentally and emotionally present. This is curious to me, and I have to wonder if anxiety isn’t both on a spectrum and spiky: Perhaps we’re all given an equal dose of it to mete out. Perhaps all of us have a little bit of (manageable) fear in all areas, which we mete out in a reasonable way over time, while some of us unleash all of our fear in one zone and at once.

Who knows: When you have anxiety and fear that feels maladaptive, you want to understand exactly that. Who or what can tell us why? As Matt’s book explores, this becomes an animating impulse and question in his life. No longer content to try to psychopharmacologize over the symptoms of panic, he recognizes that his panic might have deeper, more existential roots. Perhaps it carries a message. Much of the book is an exploration of exactly that, namely the dark well of grief inside of him around which he’s attempted to armor himself against—meanwhile, it’s exactly this dark well of grief that threatens to unleash itself from the inside out.

Matt suffered a “trail of tragedy” in his early life: The death of a sibling before he was born, the death of his father in a plane crash when Matt was 12, and his mother’s near-fatal encounter with cancer when he was a child. He seems to ricochet between tempting death and clinging to life, unsure how to bridge all this deep feeling with what it means to be a strong and accountable man in the world. In a strange way, his book dovetails quite perfectly with the final chapter of On Our Best Behavior: The chapter on Sadness, which explores what happens to boys and men when our patriarchal structure severs them from their feelings. In a world that programs boys for power and girls for goodness, the assignation of weakness for boys, and badness for girls, is a mortal threat. It’s interesting to me that Matt’s disorder takes him out at the knees, while mine has me by the throat. His snatches at his power, mastery, and control; mine snatches at my voice.

You can pre-order No Time to Panic now. Here’s an earlier post about defeating, or neutralizing, fear.

(I use affiliate links for other author’s books—if you purchase through that link, I earn a small commission. HOWEVER, the best way to support authors is to buy/order books from your favorite local indie bookseller!)

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:

6/29: Reconciling with What You Didn’t Receive with Minka KellyApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/22: Standing at the Edge with Roshi Joan HalifaxApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/15: Getting in touch with our desire with Emily MorseApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/8: Examining the myth of the linear career with Bruce FeilerApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/1: Gender as transcendent with Geena RoceroApple | Spotify | Transcript

5/25: Remodeling the World with Austin Channing BrownApple | Spotify | Transcript

5/18: The making of On Our Best Behavior with my editor, Whit FrickApple | Spotify | Transcript

THE LATEST POSTS:

Full archive HERE