It feels incredibly dark right now: We are watching the abrupt escalation of authoritarian actions here in the United States at the hands of masked vigilantes who are terrorizing Americans and immigrants alike, while Iranians are being executed en masse for protesting their 47th year of living under the authoritarian and theocratic Islamic Republic. It’s like watching the beginning and end of the same movie. (For more on Iran, I recommend following Yasher Ali.)

I want to be careful not to minimize what’s happening in Iran right now by comparing it to Minneapolis, as scary and precipitous as it feels here in the U.S. We are very, very far from the nightmare that the people of Iran have been experiencing for almost five decades. And we are geographically much larger and therefore, more difficult to control. We are secular. And fortunately, we have some strong and non-compliant state governments. But, Iran is an example of a gorgeous culture—responsible for creating so much beauty in the world, including algebra, ancient water management systems, the first charter for human rights (the Cyrus Cylinder from 539 B.C.), and so much more—that was ultimately subsumed by a regressive and suppressive force and taken hostage.

I’ve been re-immersing myself in the psychological development model Spiral Dynamics and it is calming me down to think about what’s happening in that context—it also might provide some clues about how we could most effectively respond.

For those who don’t know Spiral Dynamics, you can read my primer here (I’ve unlocked it from the paywall), or you can listen to my podcast with therapist Nicole Churchill (“The Basics of Spiral Dynamics”), my conversation with Ken Wilber (“To Transcend and Include”), or my solo episode on Spiral Dynamics ("Is This Our Push Up the Spiral?”). If you have the time, I highly recommend Don Beck’s audiobook with Sounds True from 2006, Spiral Dynamics Integral (also available on Audible).

Here is a way too brief reminder of the MEMEs or levels. We graduate up the Spiral as we mature and age, though we have a center of gravity in a specific level (or between two). The previous MEMEs are in us and part of our growth—we “transcend and include” them, to quote Ken Wilber. (More on the concept here.) No MEME is bad, wholesale, they all have shadow and light and should be respected as an important stage in the psychological development of both ourselves, and our cultures. Spiral Dynamics is fascinating because it works on both levels.

BEIGE (beginning of humanity): Focused on basic survival, i.e. newborns, those with dementia, people in disaster and war zones.

PURPLE (started 50,000 years ago): Tribal, with cause-and-effect magical beliefs, which would include modern superstitions like lucky underwear, Tarot, etc.

RED (started 10,000 years ago): Conquering, pillaging, risk-taking behavior with zero guilt—this is the terrible twos, and prevalent in teenagers. It’s King of the Jungle, take no prisoners vibes. Teaches personal power and boundary protection, but is destructive when not tempered by BLUE.

BLUE (started 5,000 years ago): Wilber refers to this as the “Conformist Age”—it emerged when we began to search for meaning and purpose and higher order. Orthodox religious beliefs are represented by this level as well as essential infrastructure for being responsible citizens, like law and order, government, rules, responsibilities, discipline. Communities and cultures can’t effectively function without strong blue.

ORANGE (started 300 years ago): This MEME/level arrived with the Enlightenment and ushered in freedom (we finally realized we shouldn’t enslave each other), along with science, rationality, medicine, capitalism, meritocracy, and the belief that everyone should be able to make the most of their life. Its shadow is runaway consumption, materialism and sometimes scientism. It’s not really interested in the sacred, nor is it particularly concerned about the price of all this growth.

GREEN (started 150 years ago): Eco-centric, egalitarian, pluralistic, inclusive, non-hierarchical—GREEN is the MEME/level of human rights, social justice, and equity. (It hates ORANGE, but GREEN is paid for by the fruits of ORANGE’s achievements.) GREEN envisions a utopia, it just doesn’t have the means to pay for it. GREEN’s shadow is that it is overwhelmed by guilt and sees everything—including history—through the lens of oppressors and oppressed. GREEN also falls apart when it begins to exclude people who don’t share its values (despite its value of inclusivity) and when it promotes diversity (but not diversity of thought). Wilber calls this behavior the MEAN GREEN MEME, or regressive Green.

[These are the First-Tier levels. I’m not going to talk about the promise of the Second-Tier today, though if you are capable of working with all the levels and honoring their gifts, you’re doing some Second-Tier leading and thinking.]

Before we get to what’s happening in the U.S., here’s a brief primer on Iran through the lens of Spiral Dynamics (if I get anything blatantly wrong, please correct me in the comments). In Iran in the ‘70s, under Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, Tehran was moving ORANGE: There was a decided push toward science, industry, and materialism and even some early GREEN (human rights movement, women’s suffrage, a drive for equality, etc.)—and this clashed with the country’s deep BLUE (fundamentalist divine order via Shia Islam). This fueled the Red-Green Alliance (these colors are unrelated to Spiral Dynamics, but they fit the circumstances)—a holy un-communion between the Islamists and Marxists against Westernization, led by Ayatollah Khomeini. This RED revolutionary movement—now referred to as “The Great Lie”— overthrew the Shah and Khomeini ascended to power and immediately put the country in an oppressive head lock, ruling via RED/BLUE: The BLUE asserts that there is one single, absolute truth and right way for the glory of Islam; the RED enforces with terror and violence through the IRGC (Revolutionary Guard) by hanging protestors from cranes for all to see. (Here’s a great explainer video from Elica Le Bon.) As she points out without using Spiral Dynamics, Iranians are desperate to overthrow the regime and see the return of Pahlavi—Reza is the Shah’s son—to stabilize the country (BLUE) in a transitional government before it moves forward into the future (ORANGE/GREEN and eventually to YELLOW/TURQUOISE, i.e. Second Tier).

Elica’s point—and she’s right—is that these same dynamics are afoot over here. And we have a lot to learn.

We all recognize that Trump has regressed. I don’t know if it’s cognitive decline, or a further revelation of his real personality and motivations, or a revenge addiction that’s even more out-of-control (see my episode with James Kimmel Jr. about this phenomenon: “How to Let Go of the Desire to See People Punished”), but Trump 2 is very different from Trump 1. Trump is RED now: He is exhibiting all the traits of a conquering, feudalistic, warlord, gang leader. There’s no evidence of guilt. There’s no contrition or concern. He is pushing against the bulwark of BLUE to see if the fence is, in fact, electrified, and whether he can take it down. As he feels power slipping (hello midterms!) expect this to get even worse. Whererever possible, he is trying to co-opt BLUE entirely, or bully it to get in line.

Trump won in 2016 by being ORANGE (he was supposed to be a businessman, after all) and playing to BLUE (Evangelical Christians, specifically) and RED (those who vibrate with the idea of a strongman, etc.). He’s very good at connecting with and mirroring the values of whatever crowds he meets. His campaign was essentially anti-GREEN and it was incredibly effective: He relied on a strategy of mocking and criticizing the country’s more progressive streaks (anti-woke, etc.), and very effectively communicated why GREEN’s vision was an assault on each level’s value system. He underlined that GREEN found RED barbaric (“basket full of deplorables”), BLUE privileged and oppressive, and ORANGE greedy and responsible for ruining the world. (Wilber wrote a helpful and short book on this: A Post-Truth World.) It was easy to stoke defensive feelings of anger and resentment.

In his two terms, he’s stacked the Supreme Court (DEEP BLUE) with justices who will be loyal, delivering for his Evangelical Christian constituents in the process (he effectively hobbled and co-opted an institution that should be an essential check on Presidential power); kept ORANGE satisfied by being pro-industry in every way (for Trump 2, he even brought in the ultimate ORANGE boi, Elon Musk); and as Charlottesville and January 6th illustrated, he not only allowed violence and terror from the country’s still-RED contingent, but honored it, giving them a seat at the table and offering them protection and immunity. In fact, Congressional Republicans (BLUE/ORANGE) are terrified of becoming RED targets—this is how Trump now demands their allegiance, submission, and obsequience.

Make no mistake that ICE—masked vigilantes to a one—are a RED Trump army, whose sole intent is to terrorize the American public and incite violence. If anyone had doubts about their legitimacy, let this past week—and the point-blank murder of Renee Good, and the subsequent federal protection of her murderer (and an attempt by the DOJ to investigate Good’s widow instead)—illustrate the goal here. Trump is working hard to get BLUE fully on its knees in order to come under his feudal dominion and service his agenda—and he’s dismantling huge amounts of our government in the process. He is doing his best to bring the entire thing under his control. What’s also terrifying for many of us is that he intends to use the technology of ORANGE (via Palantir, Grok, et al) to service his agenda.

So what do we do? We shore up BLUE. This is the only agenda that matters. Practically, this means that we stand behind our legitimate and honorable police forces (cue Philadelphia Sheriff Rochelle Bilal calling ICE “fake, wannabe law enforcement”); we support our military (including military heroes like Senator Mark Kelly and Senator Elissa Slotkin when they reminded our troops that it’s their duty to not follow unlawful orders); we get behind our elected officials and justices, particularly when they stand for the Constitution. We buttress everything in America that fortifies our rights as Americans.

We need to channel our own BLUE, to think BLUE. BLUE represents a call to belong to something larger than any one of us—while the emergence of BLUE frequently had a religious component in history, it is also a secular concern (Confucianism in China was BLUE). I know many of us are post-modernists and we like to take things apart, but now is not the time for that. We need to fortify BLUE.

And we need to speak BLUE. Again, this MEME is alive in all of us; we know how to do this. BLUE is the language of honor and obligation, of service to a larger project than our own lives or ambition. It is the birthplace in our psyches of charity, concern, and care. Through our words and actions we can remind those of us who are regressing into RED behavior, or confused, of their better BLUE natures—not through attack, but of sparking enough cognitive dissonance that they realize that they are out of step with their own values.

I was thinking the other day about my first conversation with Loretta Ross on Pulling the Thread (“Calling In the Call-Out Culture”), where she referenced what she calls her “Uncle Frank” strategy, which she uses with her own family.

Here she is:

❝

“It’s the Uncle Frank that blows up the Thanksgiving dinner table by saying something racist because the niece is saying, ‘We shouldn’t be celebrating Thanksgiving’ and Columbus day, and you know, all this other stuff.

“And my Uncle Frank strategy is to first remind the person who says these hateful, racist things of who they are. And so with my Uncle Frank, I used a tactic of saying, ‘Uncle Frank, I know you would run into a burning building to save somebody if you could. I know you wouldn’t care about what race they were, whether they were gay, whether they were an immigrant, because I know that’s who you are, Uncle Frank. You’re a good man. So, Uncle Frank, help me understand how I can reconcile the good man that I know you are with the words that just came out of your mouth. Which uncle do I actually have? The good Uncle Frank? Or the Uncle Frank that says those bad things about other people?’ You’re not calling them in and you’re not calling them out. You’re ‘calling on’ Uncle Frank to determine how he wants to walk through the world in his niece’s eyes.

“You’re lessening the feeling that he’s going to feel attacked or be put on the defensive, because you’re asking him to self-interrogate. Is this how I want to be seen by people? Or do I want to be seen in a way that’s aligned with my good opinion of myself that I have on the inside? Those are the tactics that are teachable, that are learnable, through calling in practices that we can use in every conversation. Again, you go underneath the words and you see the humanity of the person who’s expressing those words. And that, I think, neither the Right, nor the Left does very well because we tend to pounce on what we believe a person is represented by what they said on any given time, or even in the past.”

Loretta creates cognitive dissonance: Here’s who I think you are (honorable, brave, caring)—and it is not aligning with your behavior. I think you’re the former, no? This is what we all need to be doing, everywhere. (Loretta also has a fantastic book called Calling In: How to Make Change with Those You’d Rather Cancel—she came back on the podcast to talk about it (“How to Talk to People You’d Rather Hate”)).

Cognitive dissonance is the result of our self-perception butting against reality, and how we will do anything we can to make it go away and restore consonance with who we feel ourselves to be. (It’s the subject of one of my favorite conversations from last year with psychologist and professor Carol Tavris, co-author with Elliot Aronson of Mistakes Were Made (But Not by Me)—the episode is called “The Self-Justification Trap.”)

I think it’s our best weapon here: Hey Senator ______, I’ve known you to be the sort of person who puts country before party, and stands for the rights of Americans. I’m confused by _________. Is my perception of you wrong? Can you clarify? Can I expect to see something different from you going forward? I want to believe in who I’ve previously known you to be.

Or: Hey dad, for my whole life, I’ve thought of you as my hero—someone who sticks up for the little guy and makes sure that life is fair. When I hear you saying ____ or doing this____, it makes me feel like you’ve changed. I want to believe in the dad I grew up with. Can you explain how you’ve come to held some of these beliefs?

I recently read Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In, which is a classic business text (first published in 1981) written by William Ury and Robert Fisher, who created the Harvard Negotiation Project. Fisher passed in 2012, but Ury has been involved in Middle East Peace Talks for decades. Code: He knows how to work closely with RED factions. One of the things that they reiterate again and again in the book is to separate the people and the problem: “Be hard on the problem, soft on the people.”

They expound:

❝

“If they feel personally threatened by an attack on the problem, they may grow defensive and may cease to listen. This is why it is important to separate the people from the problem. Attack the problem without blaming the people. Go even further and be personally supportive: Listen to them with respect, show them courtesy, express your appreciation for their time and effort, emphasize your concern with meeting their basic needs, and so on. Show them that you are attacking the problem, not them.

“One useful rule of thumb is to give positive support to the human beings on the other side equal in strength to the vigor with which you emphasize the problem. This combination of support and attack may seem inconsistent. Psychologically, it is; the inconsistency helps make it work. A well-known theory of psychology, the theory of cognitive dissonance, holds that people dislike inconsistency and will act to eliminate it. By attacking a problem, such as speeding trucks on a neighborhood street, and at the time giving the company representative, Mr. Jenkins, positive support, you create cognitive dissonance for him. To overcome this dissonance, he will be tempted to dissociate himself from the problem in order to join you in doing something about it.”

I hope this helps. Experts in Spiral Dynamics, please jump in below—I’ll be back with more on this on the podcast as I really think it’s incredibly helpful. I wish Clare W. Graves and Don Beck were still alive in order to help us troubleshoot these times.

Stay safe out there friends.

I am holding my breath for the incredibly brave people of Iran in this heartbreaking—and hopeful—moment. May the end of their nightmare be near.