I’m halfway through the first draft of my next book. Now this sounds like good progress, but I’m stuck: I’ve been halfway through the first draft for many months. I haven’t been able to get through Chapter 5, which is arguably the most difficult chapter I’ve ever tried to write. There are a lot of reasons for this: It’s emotionally tricky material that I find personally triggering, for one; and there’s also a lot of complexity, with many threads to braid. It’s one thing to write it all down: It’s another thing to write it in a way that readers can follow my thinking, understand my points, and get where I’m wanting them to go without too much effort or head-scratching. I’m happiest as a reader when the writer does all of this processing for me rather than giving me a junk drawer of loosely connected, disorganized thoughts. You know how junk drawers are: Full of dislocated treasures (useful! necessary!) that don’t have a proper place to live.

I was kvetching to my therapist last week about feeling stalled out. “I wish I could feed everything in my head, and all my notes, into some AI bot and just skip this chapter,” I complained. “This is so painful.”

He looked at me, with a bemused smile. “Is that what you would really want?”

“I dunno. I know pulling disparate material together is sort of my sweet spot, but isn’t AI supposed to be way better at synthesizing anyway?”

“I don’t think that’s true,” he offered. “But if you could snap your fingers and have a complete draft in your hand, is that what you would want?”

I thought for two seconds, maybe three. “No, never. It’s perverse and it’s painful to admit it, but this is my favorite part. I know once I wrestle these pages down I’ll feel exhilarated—cracking chapters gives me a high—and there’s some insight or understanding here for me that I need to discover. But it really hurts right now. And this messy part also scares the shit out of me because right now, I’m at a loss for how to pull this all together. I’ve never felt this blocked. I’ve been sitting in the ‘sad room’ for days, staring at my computer, waiting for enough time to pass before I can justify going on a walk to get a coffee or a snack. I just can’t figure this out.”

I’ve written about this before, but drafting On Our Best Behavior was easy: It fell out of me, as I think I’d been working on the book in the back of my mind for most of my adult life. I was truly…writing what I know.1 Revising it on the other hand was hard. I had to restructure chapters, add sections, and do…17 drafts of my introduction. I had to go through the belly of the beast, to quote Stephen Pressfield in Do the Work, and it sucked. There were days when I pulled the blankets over my head and had a good cry.

Even so, I think about that time fondly: On Our Best Behavior would have been fine if I’d published the first or second draft. But pushing through my internal resistance until I cracked each chapter’s formula made the book great.

Reading back through the newsletter I wrote about that period from 2022 (The Power of Resistance), I have to laugh: I shared Episcopalian minister Cynthia Bourgeault’s words on breaking through binaries with third way thinking (this is resistance in action—it pushes you up to a higher perspective). As she explains in The Holy Trinity:

❝

“Most of the world’s ancient metaphysical paradigms are binary systems. That is to say, they function on the principle of paired opposites. Yin/yang is an obvious example. In binary systems the universe is experienced as created and sustained through the symmetrical interplay of the great polarities. … A ternary system envisions a distinctly different mix. In place of paired opposites, the interplay of the two polarities calls forth a third, which is the “mediating” or “reconciling” principle between them. In contrast to a binary system, which finds stability in the balance of opposites, the ternary system stipulates a third force that emerges as the necessary mediation of these opposites and that in turn (and this is the really crucial point) generates a synthesis at a whole new level.”

I don’t know how well I grokked this concept back then—only that I felt I was living through my resistance by way of the editorial process—but these concepts are at the root of my next book. So it feels very fitting that I’m getting a real-life experience of how difficult it is to summon this ternary force in action: I am resisting the resistance.

You’ve likely heard some of the stories of Nasrudin, the Sufi mystic before. In one particularly famous one, a neighbor is walking home when he happens across Nasrudin, who is searching for his lost key under a street lamp. The two begin to search and then after a long time, the neighbor asks him if he’s sure that he lost his key under the lamp.

“Oh no, I didn’t drop it here,” Nasrudin said. “I dropped it over there by my house.”

“Then why are we looking over here?”

“Because this is where the light is.”

I love this simple story because it’s so profound.

In Why the World Doesn’t End, Michael Meade offers that Nasrudin represents our own instincts when we know something is missing, and it’s nearby, but we’re afraid to voyage into the dark to find it. He writes, “He wants to search for the key that can unlock the mystery of life, but he also wishes to avoid the darker places and the deeper issues. Nasrudin as the holy fool illustrates the persistent human tendency to go where the light is and avoid the troubling places of darkness. Of course, the key we are really searching can only be found by entering where the world looks darkest to us. That is the way of this world, which is divided into opposing things, like darkness and light, day and night, order and chaos.”

The essential key is always in a tough spot, the darkest and scariest story: It feels uncontained, like chaos, uncertain. I’m searching for my key right now—and no, AI doesn’t have the unlock for me. Or I don’t want the shortcut. I don’t have a lot of opinions about AI except that it seems dangerous to outsource the processing and connecting that makes us human—I use it to help me find sources, but that’s about it. Because the truth is that if you’re working on something that you hope will change the culture, you have to let it change you first: There is no faster or more expedient path, unless you want to forsake the path for the destination. The point of this journey isn’t the book at the end—that’s nice and all—the point of the journey is the journey itself.

Here’s to finding our keys in the dark.