Last week, I felt incredibly sad—like I had been skating over a frozen lake of grief and it was slowly starting to thaw. Since I was a teen, tears have become increasingly evasive for me—I usually need to watch a movie in order to get myself going. And then sometimes I can’t stop crying for hours. In college, I was on Spring Break with my boyfriend and his family and there was a Hallmark movie about a kid who loses his horse. I was distraught, bawling, a mess, giving him and his tween siblings a lot of concern. It was an extreme over-reaction—nobody had even died—and this being Hallmark, obviously the boy and his horse find each other again. But that was the last time I remember really letting myself go.

Before the Seven Deadly Sins were Deadly, they were “Eight Thoughts”—they emerged out of the Egyptian desert by the hand of a desert monk at the same time that the New Testament was canonized. (Nope, they weren’t in the Bible.) I write about this wild history in On Our Best Behavior, including how they were eventually assigned to a woman just as they mainstreamed in religion. And I also wrote about this “eighth thought,” the one that didn’t make the cut: That thought was “Sadness,” and while I argue that the sins are lodged in the minds and bodies of women, I think sadness is primarily caught in the throats of men—it’s inaccessible to most. And when we cut people off from their feelings, toxic masculinity is the primary symptom.
Sadness is indelibly tied to loss and to our lack of control. Sadness requires letting go. And when we try to dam it in our bodies, which our patriarchal society insists we attempt, it will destroy us. In the case of these wounded boys and wounded men, typically the ones to wreak havoc on themselves and society, it will destroy us all.
My sadness started on Sunday, just a slow descension until that realization—“Wow, I feel really sad.” Monday, I flew to New York for a quick trip and an all-day board meeting. As I wandered around the city on coffee breaks, I tried to process what was happening in me. Why so sad? My brother, a book editor, and my friend Jen Walsh, a retired agent, offered clues.
Jen: “Oh honey, I hear in your voice that you’re in that creative post-partum period. Your book is out of your hands and almost in the world. It’s a liminal space, it’s often the hardest for writers.”
Ben: “Oh yeah, this is the time period when many writers become intolerable.” Ha. I love my brother and his unvarnished honesty.
I’m sure we do become intolerable. It’s a scary and grief-filled time, to imagine this object, this baby, this being that has been entirely your own is arriving soon to critics and readers. I want to ping my editor for constant reassurance, but I know she can’t really provide it. It will be what it will be. The book no longer belongs solely to me.
On Monday, when I arrived at my hotel, there were two finished copies waiting for me, signaling that On Our Best Behavior will be in the warehouse shortly, ready to be delivered to all of you. Holding it was a surreal experience, because even the galley copies—the advanced ones that go out to media in the months before launch—are not quite yet final. The ones I held in my hands that night were complete.
I write about this extensively in the chapter on “Pride,” but the desire to be seen, to be appraised for our talents and gifts, is strong in all of us. But for women, it’s a double-edged sword. There’s a playbook for visible women, and it doesn’t have a great ending. This is alive in me right now, these countervailing forces. More than anything, I want for people to read and resonate with my book. And at the same time, I’d like to move back to Montana, deep in the woods, and get a quiet and anonymous job, where I can be entirely to myself.
My guess, my hope, is that anyone can relate—putting any of our work out there, whether it’s in the office, in a gallery, or with our children, makes us hold our breath, and hope, with all our might, that we will be understood.
Thanks, as always, for reading.
(If you missed it, I loved my conversation with artist and dear friend Alexandra Grant about the creative process. She does a great job of explaining the “museums in our minds,” and trying to get our vision down on the page.)