We went to Sequoia National Park over the long weekend: We drove through the Giant Forest, shuttled in to see General Sherman (the largest living organism in the world, I was shocked to learn), and hugged a bunch of trees. I’d never been to Sequoia—it’s a wild experience to pass through a rugged landscape as you climb up, up, and up, and then round a bend into a grove of massive trees that are otherwise concealed from view, that exist only in the Sierras. Growing up in Montana, we made many trips to Glacier when I was a kid—the feeling this weekend was similar to Glacier’s Going to the Sun Highway (of The Shining intro fame), where you feel the awe-inducing magnitude of nature, which is very right-sizing. We are merely specks, showing up for a few years to pass time alongside trees that are thousands of years old and still growing, communing with each other beneath the topsoil. (If you missed my conversation with pioneering scientist Suzanne Simard, author of Finding the Mother Tree, you can find it here.)

How desperately we need this wildness. As Terry Tempest Williams writes in one of my favorite books, Erosion:

❝

“Remove our national parks and wildlands from the United States and what remains? An intolerable and lonely self-constructed world without the wisdom and beauty of a landscape much wiser than we are. We need human endeavor and intelligence, but we also need the intelligences of the wild—the millennial authority of redwood trees, the forbearance of bison, and the lyrical sermon of a wood thrush at dawn.”

Being back in primal nature and feeling my nervous system recalibrate and sync with some sort of ancient code, I thought about a recent podcast episode I hosted, where my guest was talking about current events. He remarked, “Step one is dehumanizing your enemy and calling them animals. That is the most obvious step that you're about to commit an atrocity.” I didn’t want to get into a debate and so I side-stepped the conversation, and replied that, well, we are animals.

Someone on social media took grave offense to this and told me that saying we are animals was tone-deaf (among other things). And this I find perplexing, because we are animals. I think our disavowal of this fact is responsible for so many of our current woes, starting with our definition of the word nature: “the phenomena of the physical world collectively, including plants, animals, the landscape, and other features and products of the earth, as opposed to humans or human creations.” That’s right. We’ve taken ourselves out of the definition of nature itself.

This idea that humans are so supreme, so exalted, so above all of the animating instincts that are—per the word animating, ANIMAL—is problematic, particularly in a culture where we are constantly being provoked into a fear response. Fight, flight, freeze, or faint, yes—but also, fear of loss of approval, fear of loss of security and safety, fear of loss of control as well. Primal fear drives so much of our behavior, without our conscious awareness or consent. It is a big part of who we are and how we conduct ourselves in the world—to pretend that we’re in control of all of our reactions to the world is insane.

While we arguably have more consciousness than a banana or a cat (though every year, we seem to learn more about the exceptional consciousness of other animate objects), we are still animals, of and part of the natural world.

So back to the word dehumanizing, which is a buzzy word right now—it’s a term that stepped out of academia (where it’s a big part of an important field of social science that explores stereotypes and bias and hate) and has gone mainstream—and we’ve all seen it now weaponized across social media, along with other big and ugly words with very specific legal and academic definitions. We cheapen these words and their meaning when we lob them around wantonly and use them against each other without really understanding what we’re trying to say.

While I get the intent and the instinct to find a word to describe a terrible concept—cue Hitler calling Jews parasites, and the Holocaust that eventually ensued—I do not like the word dehumanize. Its etymology is to de (off, from) + humanize (make or render human), so to strip someone of humanity. In the way we use it culturally and colloquially, this puts a prize on humanness as the ultimate thing or achievement above all things. In this context, equating someone with an animal (and again, we’re animals too) is degrading, based on a worldview where humans are on top, rulers of all.

Here’s the thing: Humans cannot claim this type of supremacy, for one. Can we not all agree that humans are capable of being truly terrible, the bottom of the barrel? Plus, when did we all agree that animals are lowly and bad? I would argue that you can tell a lot about people based on how they treat animals. After all, an early sign of psychopathy, particularly in young males, is an interesting in abusing, torturing, and killing animals. There is an absence of empathy. I think people who are depraved to dogs are just that…depraved. I don’t think they’re depraved to dogs because dogs are not human—I think it’s an indication of how they feel about life in general, and how they treat everyone. I wish, rather than using bucketing language, that we talked about psychological cues and behaviors, like Dark Triad traits (Machiavellianism, psychopathy, narcissism) and how to mark their emergence.

For lay people and those who are not pathological, I would like us to leave the concept of dehumanizing to the academics as it is an entrenched term and find more nuanced language to use with each other, language that comes back to the essential reality of who we are, and our place amongst nature. The etymology of the word anima is “breath”—a word that Carl Jung used to describe the soul. I think we get into trouble when we start de-souling, or de-animating each other and the world: Or more simply, when we start objectifying. When we talk about people as “troops” or “targets,” when we talk about women as body parts, et al.

The other reason dehumanization is sloppy? While the definition includes a negative connotation—“deprive of positive human qualities”—many of our similes, both positive and negative, rely on animal comparison: workhorse, busy as a bee, sex kitten, clotheshorse, mousy, swims like a fish, quiet as a mouse, etc. We’re inclined to compare ourselves to our animal brethren, which is one of our primary descriptors for our own behavior. I don’t think this is a bad thing—and in this current, heavily-language-policing landscape, where would someone draw the line? Are you dehumanizing your child when you say they’re as strong as an ox, or as busy as a beaver? Just saying.

To close us out, may I turn to Robin Wall Kimmerer’s stunning book, Braiding Sweetgrass, where she points to the shortcomings of our language in describing our world and its creatures:

❝

“English doesn’t give us many tools for incorporating respect for animacy. In English, you are either a human or a thing. Our grammar boxes us in by the choice of reducing a nonhuman being to an it, or it must be gendered, inappropriately, as a he or a she. Where are our words for the simple existence of another living being? Where is our yawe? My friend Michael Nelson, an ethicist who thinks a great deal about moral inclusion, told me about a woman he knows, a field biologist whose work is among other-than-humans. Most of her companions are not two-legged, and so her language has shifted to accommodate her relationships. She kneels along the trail to inspect a set of moose tracks, saying, ‘Someone’s already been this way this morning.’ ‘Someone is in my hat,’ she says, shaking out a deerfly. Someone, not something.

“When I am in the woods with my students, teaching them the gift of plants and how to call them by name, I try to be mindful of my language, to be bilingual between the lexicon of science and the grammar of animacy. Although they still have to learn scientific roles and Latin names, I hope I am also teaching them to know the world as a neighborhood of nonhuman residents, to know that, as ecotheologist Thomas Berry has written, ‘we must say of the universe that it is a communion of subjects, not a collection of objects.’”

After all, we live in a world shaped by a mechanistic worldview, one that saw humans as separate and absolute—apart from nature and not a part of it. Here’s Thomas Berry again, from an essay in Sufi mystic Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee’s beautiful collection, Spiritual Ecology:

❝

“René Descartes taught us that there was no living principle in the singing of the wood thrush or the loping gait of the wolf or the mother bear cuddling her young. There was no living principle in the peregrine falcon as it soared through the vast spaces of the heavens. There was nothing to be communed with, nothing to be revered. The honeybee was only a mechanism that gathered nectar in the flower and transformed it into honey for the sustenance of the hive, and the maple tree only a means for delivering sap. In the words of a renowned scientist: ‘For all our imagination, fecundity, and power, we are no more than communities of bacteria, modular manifestations of the nucleated cell.’”

I think it’s time for us to remake and redescribe our world. May we remember we belong to each other and find our reverence for all that’s animated in our world.

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:

1/11: On being with each other’s pain with Rabbi Sharon BrousApple | Spotify | Transcript

1/4: Embracing the Shadow with Connie Zweig, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript

12/26: What motivates change with Carrie Wilkens, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript

12/21: The power of trauma narrative with Akiva GoldsmanApple | Spotify | Transcript

12/17: Reducing harm and saving lives with Maia SzalavitzApple | Spotify | Transcript

12/14: The malleability of the brain with David EaglemanApple | Spotify | Transcript

12/10: Breaking the addiction binary with Carl Erik Fisher, M.D.Apple | Spotify | Transcript

12/7: The Gordian Knot of mental illness with Rachel AvivApple | Spotify | Transcript

12/3: Reimaging recovery with Holly WhitakerApple | Spotify | Transcript

11/30: Grappling with Part X with Phil StutzApple | Spotify | Transcript

11/22: On cultivating creativity and abundance with Richard ChristiansenApple | Spotify | Transcript

THE LATEST POSTS:

Full archive HERE