So first, I want to say that I don’t totally love the word appreciate in the context in which we use it today: Its etymology comes from (Latin) to (ad) + price (pretium). Perhaps this is why I’ve always had an uneasy relationship with the concept—I think it maybe feels cheap? Transactional? I don’t know. But I certainly felt seen by Diana Chapman, Jim Dethmer, and Kaley Klemp’s chapter on appreciation in The 15 Committments of Conscious Leadership. Seen, as in I routinely fail at spontaneous appreciation—both receiving and delivering—though I’m very, very good at expressing gratitude. Based on their guidelines, these are not the same thing.

As I read this chapter I thought about my exploration on PRIDE in On Our Best Behavior—and while Chapman and Co.’s book is not about gender, I had to wonder if this particular chapter is. Maybe not. But I know so many women who cannot hold appreciation, who quickly deflect, minimize, or reflect it back. To me, it’s always felt embarrassing and a little bit dangerous to receive appreciation because it suggests that I’m being seen. And for too many women, being seen and celebrated for our gifts is dangerous, an invitation to cut us down to size or put us back into our place. (There’s a much larger conversation of the cultural playbook of PRIDE in On Our Best Behavior.)

If you missed last week’s newsletter on candor, there’s more context on The 15 Committments of Conscious Leadership there. (Click here.)

First, the trio identify the five barriers or blocks to both receiving and dispensing appreciation—these all ring pretty true to me and I’ve certainly participated in all of these behaviors. To be honest, thinking about appreciation makes me squirm.

❝

The Inner Critic Interception. Regardless of outward signs to the contrary, the recipient internally dismisses the appreciation. The inner critic says, “What he’s saying isn’t really true. He wouldn’t be saying that if he really knew me. There are plenty of counter examples.”

The Hand-Off. The recipient passes credit to someone else—“it wasn’t really me. It was Paul over there”—or redirects the appreciation to someone else: “Oh, you think that’s a gift of mine, but you should really be paying attention to Suzy; she has that much more than I do.”

The Downgrade. The person responds by comparing herself unfavorably to an ideal that she didn’t meet. “Well, this was okay, but it wasn’t perfect. Next time, I’ll do better.”

The Dismissal. The recipient diminishes the quality or action as unnoteworthy. “That was nothing. I hardly did a thing,” or “That’s not anything special. Everyone is like that.”

The Reciprocation Race. The person reciprocates in kind: “Oh, you’re the nicest person for saying that. And I appreciate you even more than you appreciate me.”

Later, they explain that at the core of these strategies, you’ll always find an essential fear that’s attached to experiencing appreciation. These hit as well.

❝

· If I receive appreciation I am going to have to give appreciation and I am not sure I have either the capacity or the desire to appreciate.

· They don’t really mean it. They are just flattering me in order to get something from me.

· If I take in appreciation it requires me to be vulnerable and I don’t want to expose any weakness.

· Receiving appreciation ups the bar of expectation and I am not sure I can live up to that every time.

· If I receive the appreciation I will get lazy and not improve myself.

· If I accept this appreciation it means I am not humble.

Receiving appreciation is ongoing work for me: I continue to sit with the feelings of discomfort that are present for me when someone expresses appreciation for me or my work—my main ask of myself with On Our Best Behavior, for example, has to not immediately deflect to my amazing editor (hi Whit!) or minimize (The Hand-Off or The Downgrade, in their words). This is hard, it makes me so uncomfortable, for all the reasons I enumerated above. When will I be put back in my place? When will I be cut down as the tall poppy in the poppy field?

Dishing appreciation though is a muscle I could certainly develop as a preemptive measure, rather than relying solely on gratitude. I don’t know why this also feels…embarassing to me, but I’m guessing it’s because I’m so uncomfortable being on the receiving end that it makes me feel like I’m doing something to someone else that feels shameful? There’s a lot to unpack. Meanwhile, Chapman and co. offer a great and simple prompt/tool for upping the appreciation: You place three dimes, heads up, on your table or desk. You have to express appreciation—sincere, short, unarguable, specific—to three people every day, flipping a dime every time the deed is done. While I recognize that this action is directly attached to money, underlining appreciation’s etymology, I can get past it.

In a different section of the book, the trio expound on the presence of various not-oft-identified emotions, writing the following about JOY—interesting to think about your own work culture. Perhaps a dearth of appreciation means a dearth of joy?

“Joy tells a leader that something needs to be celebrated, appreciated, or laughed at, or someone needs to be patted on the back. Countless leaders fail to create a culture of celebration and appreciation because they’re cut off from their joy.”

I love the connection they draw between appreciation and joy—creating or channeling joy, rather than pricing people’s efforts, feels easier to get behind.

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:

8/3: Accepting the Invitation with Frank OstaseskiApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/27: Contending with Fear with Jakki LeonardiniApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/20: Our Collective Psychological Development with John Churchill, Psy.DApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/13: Understanding the WiFi of the Body with Lauren RoxburghApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/6: When women tell the truth about their lives with Dre BendewaldApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/29: Reconciling with the childhood you didn’t receive with Minka KellyApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/22: Standing at the edge with Roshi Joan HalifaxApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/15: Getting in touch with our desire with Emily MorseApple | Spotify | Transcript

6/8: Examining the myth of the linear career with Bruce FeilerApple | Spotify | Transcript

THE LATEST POSTS:

Full archive HERE