We live in a strange time, one that’s arguably “post-truth”—where some argue that all truth is contextual, or relative, or relegated to cultural interpretation. “What’s true for you might not be true for me.” It can feel…chaotic. It has been chaotic.

I’m going to offer a workaround, not to sidestep this essential point, but A. I’m not sure I’m equipped to argue about the qualities of truth or how to regain those qualities for our society, and B. It’s almost Thanksgiving and aren’t we all tired? I’m tired. I’m ready to be catatonic for a few hours in a tryptophan-induced haze.
Instead, let’s talk about how to contend with competing narratives at holiday dinners with family, where there might be multiple variations of “the truth” making their way around the table.
I think one of the most useful frameworks is facts versus stories. This is how Diana Chapman, Jim Dethmer, and Kaley Klemp write about the distinction in The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership:
“Stories are interpretations of the facts. Stories include all judgments, opinions and beliefs that we derive from the facts. The way the mind works is that it takes in facts/data and then it makes up stories about the facts. All stories are made up. They are not TRUE. They are simply the way we see the world. Conscious leaders make a clear and constant distinction between facts and stories they make up about the facts. They make sure that all facts are out on the table and then they encourage the expression of stories. They create a culture where stories (opinions, judgments, beliefs) are all welcome. They also create a culture where it is understood that stories are made up by the story maker and that they are not true.”
This is really big. (Brené Brown offers a spin on this when she talks and writes about how in the absence of facts, we make things up—we all abhor a vacuum, and typically rush to worst-case scenarios when there’s missing or inadequate information.)
My friend Courtney Smith—if you missed her podcast episode on the Enneagram, this is a good one to listen to while you cook—teaches from the Conscious Leadership Group playbook, and turned me onto The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership. And she recently coached me and some other women through distinguishing between facts and stories in a way that was revelatory. Because as the trio point out above, most of our daily interactions revolve around stories we tell… based on not very many facts. This makes sense: We are meaning-making animals looking to create cohesive narratives about ourselves and the world. We make a lot of stuff up in order to fit our perceptions into our worldview. Story is also how we construct our identities (“I’m a devoted mother, I’m a responsible CEO, I’m a loyal employee, I’m a devout Catholic.” Or, “I’m the child of divorced parents, therefore I struggle with intimacy and trust.” Or, “I’m a loner and a loser, because I’ve always been the last person picked.”) This doesn’t even include our collective stories, which are the stories we agree on that make up every part of our culture.
It’s easy to recognize the way we get stuck in story—unwilling or unable to change because…who are we without the story we tell about ourselves? What parts of our identity would we need to give up if we accepted a modified version?
This is where working with facts versus stories can be revelatory.
Now first, a fact is something that’s undeniably true: It’s an actual event, something that could be recorded on a video camera and played back for the world to verify. (The etymology of fact comes from facere (Latin), which is “do.”)
Everything else is story. Everything.
And from a single fact, our minds can go wild creating narratives.
Here’s a simple, made-up example: Let’s say you had breakfast with someone on a Friday to discuss a potential job. The following Monday, you sent this person a follow-up, to express your interest in the position. So two facts: You had breakfast with someone. You sent an email. It’s now Friday, and you haven’t received a response. Here are 10 stories I would probably tell myself over the course of a single day based on those facts: 1. The person is turned-off by your eagerness. 2. The person is laughing at you for thinking you qualify for the role. 3. The person has reference-checked you and heard terrible things. 4. The person’s mother passed away. 5. The company is going out of business. 6. The person is talking to HR about salary bands so they can make you an offer. 7. The person is in the midst of hiring someone else. 8. The person decided to promote someone else internally. 9. The person got fired. 10. The person does not yet have anything to report. I could go on and on. We’ve all been here. The point is: These are all stories—some more viable than others—but we just don’t know the facts outside of the facts that we know.
We do the same thing in our intimate lives: Let’s say that you had a dad that factually, only made it home for dinner one to two nights a week when you were growing up. Or, let’s say that your mother left your family, and you saw her once a year from then on out. Or let’s say that one of your siblings passed away when you were young. Or let’s say that you have a partner who falls asleep on the couch every night. You can imagine the stories that are present about all of these factual events—these things that a camera might have captured. While many of the stories are likely painful, it’s hard to judge how many are “true.”
Stories are essential, but the deeper we get into story-craft, the farther we get from reality. Per Courtney, “to see what is, we must be able to distinguish facts from stories.” She continued to explain that curiosity, creativity, witnessing, and visioning are all lost to us when we’re stuck in a story, convinced that our version is the correct and only one. Because stories are often so indeliby wrapped up in identity, we then make the mistake of defending stories for truth. As she points out—and every couples therapist can likely attest—most conflict is story versus story. (And sometimes both stories are true.) There’s rarely movement in this type of détente: Neither party is typically willing or ready to shift.
To practice, Courtney had us sit in pairs and have one person ask two questions for several minutes repeatedly while the other answered: “1. Tell me a fact about yourself? 2. Tell me the story you make up about that fact?” The person asking questions can’t respond. If you want to speed-date your way to increasing intimacy, this is a great way.
Getting the hang of this is slippery at first: As we practiced, we realized that more often than not, we were presenting stories as facts. (One hint: The word “because” signifies a story is present… “I struggle with intimacy because my dad was absent,” or “I’m a workaholic because I’ve never felt safe,” and on and on and on.)
Taking this out into the real world, Courtney urged us toward what she calls “inarguable speaking,” where you focus on emotional facts with your partner or friend: “In my body I’m feeling…,” or “The story I’m making up is….,” or “The thought I’m having is…” Again, the goal here is to speak as factually as possible by grounding your interpretations in your body and taking ownership of them as perceptions: It creates a lot more spaciousness in conversations. And might give you insight into how your mind unravels when you’re left to your story-making devices.
As an example: “The story I’m making up about you coming home and not saying hi or giving me a hug is that you don’t love me anymore.” That leaves a lot more room for your partner to tell you what might be going on than walking into: “You don’t love me anymore.”
Good luck out there friends—I’m grateful for all of you. And for our new family member, a three-legged kitten named August who we adopted on Sunday. The new family rule is that Rob is not allowed to go to Petco for litter anymore—because whenever he texts me a photo of a cat who needs a home, it’s done. I have the good folks at Alley Cat Rescue on speed dial (we adopted two of these kittens last year). And those are the facts. Meanwhile, this boy is amazing—he’s faster than the girls.

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
11/22: On cultivating creativity and abundance with Richard ChristiansenApple | Spotify
11/16: On all of our versions of self with Raquel WillisApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/13: The theory of Human Design with Chetan & CarolaApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/9: Loving with conditions with Jedidiah JenkinsApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/6: Where Tarot and Kabbalah come together with Mark HornApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/2: Understanding whose pain counts with Susan BurtonApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/30: The secrets of Asterian astrology with Jade LunaApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/26: On claiming intellectual superiority with Chloé Cooper JonesApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/23: The magic of the Enneagram with Courtney Smith Apple | Spotify | Transcript
10/19: From conflict to connection with Esther PerelApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My New York Times bestselling book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.