“I just don’t know if I can care anymore.” I heard this from a friend this week—a distraught friend, a friend who is twisted by, and intimately connected to, what’s happening in Israel and Palestine, though she lives far away from the war, here in Los Angeles with me.

I read her text on multiple levels: That she feels like she can’t care any more, that she’s at a 10 in feeling emotionally involved and heartbroken; and also that she’s done, that she needs some relief, that she’s tipping into empathic distress.
I understand. The roots of the word “care” shine a light on why. Care, such an essential word, a word that’s hard to synonymize, comes from chara (Old German): To grieve, lament. It is connected to pain, to suffering, to the very core of attachment. To care is our most difficult and vital work. But to care, we need breaks, we need reprieve, in part because there’s always more caring, more grieving to be done.
It’s hard to overstate, too, that care is often considered to be women’s work: Caregiving, caretaking is our dominion, which makes the implications of the etymology even more staggering. As many of you know, I included a chapter on Sadness in On Our Best Behavior, because before they were 7 Deadly Sins, they were Eight Thoughts—and Sadness made this original list. In my book, I focused the final chapter, the chapter on Sadness on the interior lives of men: What happens to boys who are cut off from their feelings, and what happens when these wounded boys become wounding men? The chapter is about men’s buried and latent grief, and their inability to access these deep reservoirs of feeling: I argue that the primary symptom of this suppression is toxic masculinity. When grief is not accessible, it manifests in part as domination, violence, rage.
The etymology of care also reminds me of the work of pioneering psychologist Carol Gilligan, author of In a Different Voice and Why Does Patriarchy Persist?, which she co-wrote with Naomi Snider. Gilligan’s work focuses on the development of morality in children, how boys come to see their role as being in the world, while girls come to see themselves as being in service to the world. For girls, this requires a dislocation from their voice, their authority, an assertion of their own needs and desires. In Why Does Patriarchy Persist? the duo write about the insertion of the word “don’t” in the vocabulary of both boys and girls. For girls, it becomes: “I don’t know.” For boys, it’s “I don’t care.” By etymological extension: I don’t care, therefore I don’t grieve, I don’t lament.
I wish I had made that connection before On Our Best Behavior went to press.
I know plenty of men who are upset—though the primary expression of their grief is oftem anger—rage seems far more accessible to men, easier, more “masculine.” Meanwhile, it feels like women are, once again, trying to cleanse the world with our tears. Our culture is swamped in grief.
It is, quite simply, too much.
In Standing at the Edge, Roshi Joan Halifax outlines the “Edge States” of altruism, empathy, integrity, respect, and engagement—the points where we tip from our highest and most treasured values to the other side, where we sometimes participate in the very behavior we profess to abhor, when we cause harm despite intending the opposite.
Here’s Roshi Halifax outlining the premise:
Altriusm can turn into pathological altruism. Selfless actions in service to others are essential to the well-being of society and the natural world. But sometimes, our seemingly altruistic acts harm us, harm those whom we are trying to serve, or harm the institutions we serve in.
Empathy can slide into empathic distress. When we are able to sense into the suffering of another person, empathy brings us closer to one another, can inspire us to serve, and expands our understanding of the world. But if we take on too much of the suffering of another, and identify too intensely with it, we may become damaged and unable to act.
Integrity points to having strong moral principles. But when we engage in or witness acts that violate our sense of integrity, justice, or beneficience, moral suffering can be the outcome.
Respect is a way we hold beings and things in high regard. Respect can disappear into the swamp of toxic disrespect, when we go against the grain of values and principles of civility, and disparage others or ourselves.
Engagement in our work can give a sense of purpose and meaning to our lives, particularly if our work serves others. But overwork, a poisonous workplace, and the experience of the lack of efficacy can lead to burnout, which can cause physical and psychological collapse.
Roshi Halifax was on Pulling the Thread recently (you can listen to our conversation here), where we spoke about the well-intentioned but sometimes problematic energy of “helping,” which so many of us carry, and how this, to quote her, “can feed our latent tendencies toward power, self-importance, narcissism, and even deception of ourselves and others.” I watch this carefully in myself, particularly in our hyper-performative, social media-driven world where we want to testify and time-mark our “goodness,” our moral superiority, our certitude. In our conversation, Roshi Halifax and I discussed the words of Dr. Rachel Naomi Remen who wrote, “Helping, fixing, and serving represent three different ways of seeing life. When you help, you see life as weak. When you fix, you see life as broken. When you serve, you see life as whole. When we help we may inadvertently take away from people more than we could ever give them; we may diminish their self-esteem, their sense of worth, integrity and wholeness. When I help I am very aware of my own strength. But we don’t serve with our strength, we serve with ourselves. We draw from all of our experiences. Our limitations serve, our wounds serve, even our darkness can serve. The wholeness in us serves the wholeness in others and the wholeness of life.”
In this incredibly dark and difficult moment, I keep coming back to this idea: What actually serves?
Does the world need to hear my moral outrage? (Probably not, particularly as the social media din reaches an all-time high.) Do I have any expertise or insight to offer here? (Not really, though more to come from me on early Christianity, plus everything more I’ve learned about Spiral Dynamics, which I’m finding increasingly stunning and reassuring.)
Where I keep returning is that we each can and must serve through the energy we’re powering in the world. Are you powering fear? Are you powering rage, or hate, or intolerance? Try powering love instead. Try powering grace or compassion. Try powering peace. I actually mean this quite literally. We run these energies through our body before we express them in the world: You feel your rage, your hate, your fear before it comes out in your voice, or on the keyboard. Focus on cultivating and feeling a sense of peace in your heart instead. Move it through your whole body before sending it across the globe: Together, we can start to bring the temperature down.
Meanwhile, take care of yourselves and each other. We often leave ourselves out of the circle, but processing collective grief should never be done alone.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
11/6: Where Tarot and Kabbalah come together with Mark HornApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/2: Understanding whose pain counts with Susan BurtonApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/30: The secrets of Asterian astrology with Jade LunaApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/26: On claiming intellectual superiority with Chloé Cooper JonesApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/23: The magic of the Enneagram with Courtney Smith Apple | Spotify | Transcript
10/19: From conflict to connection with Esther PerelApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/12: Simplifying Wellness with Liz MoodyApple | Spotify | Transcript
10/5: Tackling money fears with Farnoosh TorabiApple | Spotify | Transcript
9/28: Cultivating our Presence with Thomas HüblApple | Spotify | Transcript
9/21: Thinking our way to health with Ellen LangerApple | Spotify | Transcript
9/14: Contending with panic with Matt GutmanApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My New York Times bestselling book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.