I sat with a large group of women this week and we did a radical practice, something I’ve written about at length before. We wrote down three things:

  1. What we want.

  2. What we want.

  3. What we really, really want.

But no, we weren’t re-writing the lyrics to “Wannabe” by the Spice Girls—we didn’t want “zigazig ah.” (In hindsight, these lyrics make no sense?)

We were actually writing about what we want to be and what we want to do with our lives.

Next, we shared these wants—which were supposed to be so big, so humiliating, so prideful, we’d never fully admitted them to ourselves, much less shared them with anyone else—with this group of relative strangers. Not with a single neighbor in the circle, but out loud, to the entire group.

Without breaking anyone’s confidence, here’s what I observed. Initially, the idea seemed to be excruciating. Women were squirming, a few people cried as they shared because they were so embarrassed by the audacity of the dream they had for themselves.

But here’s what was wild: Nothing was audacious. Everything stated seemed perfectly reasonable. And more stunning still: This is a group of women who routinely gather because they share a life philosophy and overlapping interests, and yet nobody wanted the same thing. Very few wants were even in the same lane.

Yet, before we started sharing, you could almost smell the scarcity in the room. After all, there’s a pervasive and insidious idea for woman that there’s just not enough to go around. That if you get what you want in your life, it means another woman will not. We are ruled and dominated by scarcity: There’s only one. Sometimes two. Meanwhile, men are not so constrained—they are fully engaged in helping each other get bigger, understanding that in their particular ocean, more water means that all boats rise. (Much more on this in newsletters to come.) They are also much more comfortable with overt transactional relationships. (More on transactional relationships and shadow vows here.)

As women kept sharing and reflecting, you could feel the room expand—as though by saying our wants out loud, these dreams could finally take up space, become structured, more real. Action plans were constructed, desire transformed into eventuality.

I highly suggest doing this with a group of friends.

Later that night, after the circle dispersed, I gathered for dinner with a group of women had been in the room—almost entirely authors, or soon-to-be-authors, and one friend who never, ever wants to write a book. We returned to a conversation I had had with many of these same women right before my book came out.

I had initially included this story in this newsletter about wanting, which came out in the days before my book release, but pulled the story out to ensure I had permission to share. (I did, but permission came after I had hit send.)

So I’m offering it to you now. We had participated in a similar event—a three-way book party and discussion—and then had dinner after, where we went around the table and said we wanted. Several women were present at both events:

❝

One woman, who has written many books that have sold steadily and nicely over time (but did not make a bestseller’s list), asked the rest of us what we want for our books.

“I would love to make the New York Times bestsellers list,” I told the group. “I think I have a chance of hitting it for a week. That would be nice validation—but what I really want is an infectious growth curve, where the book sells well over time because people are passing it on, book-clubbing it, talking about it. I want the book to work so that I can write more books and keep hosting my podcast.” (People talking is the driver of all book sales, FWIW—press helps put books in the consideration set, but word-of-mouth is what moves books into peoples’ homes.)

Another friend thought for a minute and offered that she wants her book to sell well and would like to make the list, but not because she wants to write another one. What she really wants is to build a library of video content and courses that aggregate the encyclopedia worth of material she’s already made so she can stop reinventing the wheel and make some passive income.

And then another friend, whose second book came out awhile ago and is selling like hotcakes, offered that despite her success, she didn’t make the list and feels that it was a crushing defeat.

“I was classified as ‘Advice, How To’ and not Non-Fiction, which is ridiculous,” she explained. (Advice/How-To has 10 spots, not 15, and is dominated by heavy selling manuals—it’s a very competitive list.) “And I felt so much pressure to make it because my publisher put pressure on me. I’m going to need therapy about it because not making the list ruined my launch, and I’m really sad about that.”

I asked her what type of pressure, because most publishers recognize a lot of this is outside of authors’ control, and she replied: “Well, they said, we know you want this and we want this for you too, so let’s do our best to make this happen.”

I marked the language she used, but I didn’t push her. We reassured her and moved on.

About 20 minutes later, she piped up: “Hi, guys, I feel really embarrassed—that was really prideful that I said that I wanted that, and was upset I didn’t get it. I’m really embarrassed.”

“No,” I replied. “You should have wanted that. You were right to want that. And I’m sorry you didn’t get it. You’ve already written two very successful books, and you will write another, and each launch has been bigger than the last. You will have this. I’m proud of you for owning that you wanted it.”

Another friend interjected, “And you were under pressure from the publisher—that’s really hard.”

And then I felt really proud of my friend: “No, they didn’t pressure me. I wanted it. They were supporting the fact that I wanted it. I’m the one who wanted it.”

BINGO.

This was a powerful moment. I could feel her shift, the acknowledgment that owning her wanting and not getting what she wanted was more survivable, and faster and easier to process, than triangulating her bad feelings onto someone else, and blaming them for what was hers. What she’d been carrying around for half a year seemed to lift. She didn’t get everything that she wanted, and yet, she was okay.

It’s embarrassing to own our wanting. It’s difficult to publicly proclaim whatever it is, and work for it, and recognize that our effort and desire might not be enough to earn or win it. But that’s so much cleaner and clearer than shifting that wanting onto a third-party, of making it someone else’s responsibility or fault, or of repressing it entirely.

It’s funny to read this now, because for the record, I got exactly what I wanted. And I’m still getting it—the book-clubbing, the circles, the word of mouth. And I’m convinced that it came to pass in large part because—through the process of writing On Our Best Behavior—I was able to identify and own my wanting. Going into publication, I felt very aligned with myself.

As we revisited this night in May earlier this week, the friend who had kicked off the question told me how excruciating it had been for her to hear me say what I wanted that night. She was very concerned for me, worried that I would be crushed with disappointment, as at that moment, two weeks before my book came out, the New York Times list seemed like a pipe dream. (To be fair, I didn’t have enough press lined up to give anyone much confidence.)

“That’s funny,” I offered, “because I did not feel anxious. Not because it seemed like a certainty, but because by naming what I wanted, I had already let it go. I had pulled all my available levers, I had planted all my seeds, done what I could. It was out of my hands. But because I had been clear with myself, I wasn’t holding any of that wishing energy back—my part was done.” Honestly, I was at peace.

What was also interesting about this recent revisit is that my friend who didn’t make the list was there again. In these intervening months, her wants have gotten bigger, clearer, and more fully articulated and owned. Rather than triangulating, she is aligned and directed. And I have every confidence that in this go around, she’ll get everything she wants.

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:

9/7: Understanding psychological safety with Amy EdmonsonApple | Spotify | Transcript

8/31: On What We Can Become with Kate BowlerApple | Spotify | Transcript

8/24: Why Do We Expect Life to Be Any Other Way with Nora McInernyApple | Spotify | Transcript

8/17: The Science of Heartbreak with Florence WilliamsApple | Spotify | Transcript

8/10: What We’ve Chosen to Forget with Baratunde ThurstonApple | Spotify | Transcript

8/3: Accepting the Invitation with Frank OstaseskiApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/27: Contending with Fear with Jakki LeonardiniApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/20: Our Collective Psychological Development with John Churchill, Psy.DApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/13: Understanding the WiFi of the Body with Lauren RoxburghApple | Spotify | Transcript

7/6: When women tell the truth about their lives with Dre BendewaldApple | Spotify | Transcript

THE LATEST POSTS:

Full archive HERE