A few weeks ago, my husband and I almost stopped speaking. Despite using him as a regular example in my newsletter (which he LOVES!), we enjoy a pretty peaceful relationship punctuated by only occasional moments of wanting to throttle each other. But this week was not good.

Every spring, our nanny/third parent Vicky goes to Guatemala for two weeks to see her mother and her husband’s family. And every spring—even though our two kids are in school for most of the day—I’m reminded that we are a failing tripod without her. What’s most striking about Vicky’s yearly absence is how acutely ashamed my reliance (strike that, our reliance) on her makes me feel, particularly as a signifier of my privilege. My kids are six and nine, and I recognize that absent an office that I have to report to every day, employing Vicky full-time seems like a luxury. But to me, her presence is as essential and sacred and necessary as a roof over our head or my marriage. I couldn’t do any substantive work without her. Yet, the fact that it makes me feel bad says…a lot. It says a lot about being a woman and a mother in America. (Rob does not feel bad at all; I would guess he hasn’t even thought about whether he feels bad.)
Everything was on the rails at the beginning of the second week—and then my youngest was sent home from school with a fever, and it all fell apart. For me, at least. As the parent who works from home, and as the parent who works for myself, and as the…mother, I’m the one who typically bends. (To be fair, Rob also had to bend so I could go to a paid work event.) Regardless, it was pretty fascinating to see how quickly we were in disarray—how do you pick up one kid after school, when the other one is sick in bed? How do you listen intently to someone you’re interviewing for a podcast while you’re simultaneously listening for a puking child on the other side of the wall? We don’t have any family nearby; thank God for generous school mom friends.
It was stressful—and I have a willing co-parent. And it was short-term. This is how most families function all the time, one domino away from everything falling apart. (LAUSD teachers are on-strike right now, and I just read ’s newsletter this morning about frantically trying to get her kids into summer camps as soon as registrations opened—and failing.) Keep in mind that according to the Pew Research Center, almost a quarter of U.S. kids under the age of 18 live with only one parent—and 80% of the 11 million single-parent families in the U.S. are headed by mothers. Parenting without a lot of support is not tenable. It was never supposed to be this way. We were not supposed to do this alone—we were supposed to have alloparenting. We don’t have paid parental leave. We don’t have affordable, high-quality daycare. We don’t have any stopgaps outside of family if you’re lucky and the goodwill of relative strangers.
I write about this at length in SLOTH in On Our Best Behavior, and I write about my relationship with Vicky, too—including the shame that I have it so good. The other week—during this shame attack—I realized how perverse this really is. It’s perverse to feel this way about a relationship that’s one of the most meaningful in my life. Shouldn’t I be celebrating it instead? But I feel ashamed—I feel ashamed because other mothers don’t have a Vicky, that we’re so divided between haves, have-nots, and I-would-nevers. Or that’s the perception. And by not talking about it openly, these lines are maintained.
I interviewed Angela Garbes when her book Essential Labor came out last year, where I wrote in the introduction:
A first-generation Filipino-American, Angela makes the argument that the United States must re-orient the way we think about everything—the economy, in particular—to venerate the vital act of care, of tending to each other’s needs, and of prioritizing the collective…otherwise we are lost.
In our conversation, we touch on what this means for all of our lives, including the ways that women like me must come out of our shame pockets to talk about all the people who care for us—labor that has become largely invisible behind the veneer of our projections of what it looks like to be a functioning family in America. As I explain to Angela, our family would cease to work without Vicky, who is effectively our third parent. I believe Angela is right, that we need to be having these collective conversations first, in order to push culture to re-prioritize against a new axiom of what really matters in our lives.
Angela and I talked about Vicky at length in our conversation, including what Rob and I pay her, her PTO (about six weeks), benefits (we pay for her and her husband’s health insurance), etc.—Angela asked, and I wanted to answer bravely, in part to help normalize these conversations. Vicky is a grandmother who lives with us during the week and with her husband during the weekends (they live about 60 miles away, which is not a viable LA commute). One thing you often hear is that women like me are paying women to take care of their children, and then women employed as caretakers are then forced to abandon their own kids—that when women across the board don’t exclusively care for their own children, they perpetuate a vicious cycle of neglect. There’s a lot wrong with this argument—that fathers are not included in this equation, for one, and also that a vast majority of women in America need to work. Comfortable single-income homes are an extreme rarity—the tenability of that fantasy went poof in the ‘70s (and was never really a reality for more than a handful of years).
The biggest part of my conversation with Angela was about the worthiness of care work, how important it is, how it should be venerated. And how we must start talking about how much support we all need. And we need to make this support—and our need for this support—visible.
I’m guessing a lot of other women besides me feel shame about transactional support—and so it’s typically hidden away. Not discussed, not revealed, not highlighted on Instagram. We need to bring it out of the shadows, because guess what: WE ALL NEED IT. ALL OF US. And we need collective action to make access to support happen, for everyone—this includes paid family leave, it includes access to affordable, high-quality daycare. As Angela Davis, author of the essential Women, Race, & Class, explains, “childcare should be socialized, meal preparation should be socialized, housework should be industrialized—and all these services should be readily accessible to working-class people.”
Here’s Angela Garbes from our podcast conversation: “I love that you just said venerate. This is honorable work, you know? It's all necessary. And I think that this idea of some work being unskilled is to me another myth that's used to say that we should pay some people less than we pay others. You know, work is work. And since we all have to work in this country, it shouldn't be a threat. It’s not like it takes away from your skills. It's just understanding that every job has different things that are required of it, you know, and to be good at a job, and to be able to do things requires some mastery and understanding. And all of it is good and all of it is worthy and all of it is important.”
If Angela liked that I said it should be venerated, I like that she said it requires mastery. Because this is also how I feel about Vicky, and another source of my shame: Vicky is incredible with children. She is masterful. In comparison, I am sometimes impatient, irritable, and distracted—I love my kids, but I’m not particularly good with kids. Vicky is excellent with kids. My kids might love her most of all. And for that, I’m eternally grateful. And there’s no shame in that.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
3/16: The origins of inequality and patriarchy with Angela SainiApple | Spotify | Transcript
3/9: The indomitable, lovely, and enchanting Katherine MayApple | Spotify | Transcript
3/2: Learning how to self-heal in the dark with Tara SchusterApple | Spotify | Transcript
2/23: Navigating family dysfunction with America’s therapist Nedra TawaabApple | Spotify | Transcript
2/16: A beautiful conversation about friendship with the wonderful Will SchwalbeApple | Spotify | Transcript
2/9: I chatted with one of my favorite college professors, Priscilla Gilman, about being a child of divorce and the essential role of criticismApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is coming 5/23, and available for pre-order now.