I’ve learned a lot this year—I’m guessing we all have, particularly as the world gets stranger, darker, scarier. Instead of bending toward pessimism, fear, and despair, I’m choosing to see the unfurling of events through a metaphysical lens: It’s helpful to me, at least, to believe that we all chose to be here. And now, the call is to understand why.

At the beginning of the year, I wrote a piece for Oprah about wholeness. It was about the step-change required to move from wellness and its personal, physical pursuits to wholeness and its emotional and spiritual aims. Ultimately, it was about shifting our focus from “longevity” and length of life to depth. What does it look like to do less and be more? What would it be like to embrace ourselves fully rather than to try—earnestly, endlessly—to be someone else, someone likely fitter, thinner, younger, smarter, richer?
This concept of wholeness felt vaguely connected to my book at the time, which was in production but not yet out, though it’s only now that I really understand how. Part of the revelation came from this Carl Jung quote: “I’d rather be whole than good,” which drew my attention to the fact that in Jung’s world, a distaste or fear of badness is antithetical to feeling integrated. This “badness” makes up the shadow.
And then, after On Our Best Behavior published, my friend, psychologist/astrologer Jen Freed (our podcast episode here) told me after she’d read it that I’d written a book about the collective shadow of women. It’s funny, because it’s so obvious, yet I’d never made the connection. In a nutshell, OOBB is about everything women are conditioned to disown—our appetites, desires, wants, and needs—in the service of being good women. Good women need no rest (sloth), have no need for affirmation, praise, or attention (pride), want nothing for ourselves (envy), have no discernible hunger (gluttony) or ambition (greed), want to be sexy but not sexual (lust), and are never upset about anything (anger). Where does all that bad feeling go? It goes into the shadow, both personal and collective. We bury it in our bodies—and project it onto each other, policing each other for those qualities that we’ve come to hate in ourselves.
I could have written On Our Best Behavior as a stunt-y book—embracing my lust, gluttony, and sloth for a year and recounting my adventures. But that wasn’t the point: The book is not a call to be extra-prideful or extra-greedy, it’s for women to simply accept our full humanity. To come into balance. To recognize our impulses, passions, and desires as an essential part of ourselves and this experience. To reclaim our wholeness by embracing everything we’ve cast into our shadow.
This is hard work. It’s not a mental exercise, it’s a full body one. It’s a process of constantly interrupting an interior dialogue that’s full of judgment and disdain. Reclaiming this shadow requires coming face to face with intense cultural programming that is embedded in our minds and bodies.
I’m not really one for New Year’s Resolutions, or fix-its. In years past, a vast majority of mine have been about diet and exercise and I’m still in the process of letting that go as a testament to “letting myself go,” i.e. not keeping myself on a leash and chain about food (see: Gluttony chapter). (I have a very powerful conversation with the one-and-only Kate Manne coming up on the podcast—I highly recommend pre-ordering her book Unshrinking: How to Face Fat Phobia, which is out on January 9.)
So in lieu of resolutions about “being good” about my body, I will offer that for me, 2024 is the year of grappling with shadow, hopefully with something significant to offer at the end of it. I’ve been writing about this a bit already (What’s the Work for Us?, Understanding the Energy of Shadow, When Communities are in Shadow, etc.), but there’s certainly more to come.
This feels like essential next steps in an adventure I didn’t know I was starting when I became fixated on wholeness—but again, that’s the power of the unconscious to shape our lives, and take us where we need to go. To that end, tomorrow’s podcast is a wrap-up of the big lessons I’ve learned this year, and the first episode of the new year features Jungian therapist Connie Zweig, PhD, author of Meeting the Shadow, Meeting the Shadow on the Spiritual Path, Romancing the Shadow, and The Inner Work of Age. (It’s one of my favorite podcast episodes to date).
Are you all into resolutions? Where do you feel drawn and what’s pulling your attention for the year ahead?
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
12/26: What motivates change with Carrie Wilkens, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/21: The power of trauma narrative with Akiva GoldsmanApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/17: Reducing harm and saving lives with Maia SzalavitzApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/14: The malleability of the brain with David EaglemanApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/10: Breaking the addiction binary with Carl Erik Fisher, M.D.Apple | Spotify | Transcript
12/7: The Gordian Knot of mental illness with Rachel AvivApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/3: Reimaging recovery with Holly WhitakerApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/30: Grappling with Part X with Phil StutzApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/22: On cultivating creativity and abundance with Richard ChristiansenApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/16: On all of our versions of self with Raquel WillisApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/13: The theory of Human Design with Chetan & CarolaApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/9: Loving with conditions with Jedidiah JenkinsApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/6: Where Tarot and Kabbalah come together with Mark HornApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/2: Understanding whose pain counts with Susan BurtonApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My New York Times bestselling book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.