I interviewed Kate Kennedy for an upcoming episode of the podcast this past week—she’s the author of the brand-new book One in a Millenial and the host of Be There in Five, where she dissects popular culture in a hilarious and revelatory way. While our upcoming conversation and episode is slightly different and lighter than typical Pulling the Thread fare, it was really fun, and her book made me think, particularly in the way that popular culture informed our consciousnesses as children. Which brings me to Kevin Costner and Field of Dreams, a movie from the ‘80s where Costner constructs a baseball field in his corn fields for a group of baseball ghosts to come out and play. (Wild conceit in retrospect!) Costner is prompted to build this field by a phantom voice in his head that says, “If you build it, he will come.”

As a 10-year-old, I internalized this message intensively: I loved this movie and I loved that phantom voice. And I’m not alone: This line has been (mis)quoted for decades as the ultimate If/Then statement, extolling us all to action with the promise of miracles in response to our efforts—it’s manifestation, the arrival fallacy and how we “just-if-y” to ourselves to keep our foot on the accelerator. If I do this, then I will get that. If I just…get the promotion, then I can buy the house. If I just parent perfectly, then my kids will get into the right college and face no uncertainty. And so on and so forth. It’s a formula that seems to guarantee certainty.
For me, growing up in media, “If you build it, they will come” translated readily to the idea that if you launched a blog, or built a website, or wrote a book, readers/viewers/shoppers would materialize, just like “Shoeless” Joe Jackson out of the corn fields. And the thing is, in the age of early algorithms, back in the 2000s and early 2010s, they kind of did: There were so many early players who benefited from search engine optimization (SEO) and killed on basic search terms, or figured out how to ride Facebook’s early product feed to massive traffic waves. The problem, of course, is that they couldn’t maintain this mostly fabricated growth: Their core offering was a colander, not a container. People came because they were driven there—not because they drove themselves—and they just as easily drifted away. You’d hear things like, “I read something somewhere, I have no idea where,” because content sites were so undifferentiated. After all, desperate to maintain the traffic flows and (quasi-artificially) inflated audiences, sites engaged in a rapid race to the bottom, optimizing headlines according to what people happened to be searching for, engineering clickbait, valuing quantity over quality, over and over again. The prized metric was Unique Visitors, not retention, return rates, or time on site. Rather than healthy production budgets and reasonable rates per word, writers and editors were given performance-based KPI’s like they were day traders: They hit traffic goals by farming an absurd number of pieces per day, hoping something would hit. This is not the field of dreams where Pulitzer Prizes are won.
I always saw the potential upside of that moment in time as an opportunity for niche sites to build small, but reliable businesses, buttressed by equivalently small, but loyal and devoted audiences. After all, there have been massive upsides to the democratization of the internet: You don’t need to be a cultural gatekeeper, nor do you need a cultural gatekeeper’s permission to publish directly to the internet and to share your work and thoughts with the world. Massive homegrown communities and cottage industries have been born. As much as this is a double-edged sword (misinformation, virality, a culture of “influence,” etc.), there’s a lot of beauty in this.
Back in the day, though, it seemed obvious to me that you were never, ever going to be able to compete with big tech for audience—that chasing scale was not viable when Google could and would rejigger their search algorithm and turn on and off traffic spigots according to their whims. But very few people seemed to agree, determining that going big was the move, that the real audience was the algorithm.
Meanwhile, the result was entirely predictable: The cratering of an industry, the demolition of brands that took decades to build and just a few years to burn down. The sites that survived are those that never prioritized growth for growth’s sake, and kept their existing readers front-of-mind and thus, ensured the support of those readers through subscriptions. When it comes to the scale of the internet, they are small. Even the mighty New York Times only has 10 million subscribers. (To that end, I’m very concerned for journalists and journalism right now—please support your local paper!)
Where am I going with this? In two directions.
First, I was at dinner last week with a friend who is a venerated and decorated movie producer. She asked me for a hot take on her industry, which is in a scarily weird, post-strike, streamer-dominant space. I don’t know anything about Hollywood, but I offered two theories: One, that we have a broken Cosmic Egg that’s fracturing all of us (newsletter about this coming soon); the other, pattern recognition based on what’s happened across media, where magazines were the tip of the spear. (I worked at Condé Nast in The Devil Wears Prada era, oh how things have changed.) Before the internet, magazines operated on zero data: Covers with their newsstand sales were put up on the wall. You could look at an image of a celebrity and wonder why it out-performed an image of someone else, but you were left with your best guesses, and there was no expectation that you’d crack the code. It wasn’t math, it was magazine-making. You followed your intuition, made stories you would want to read, with the hopes that other people would want to read them as well. It was a one-sided conversation and honestly, when it comes to protecting creativity, it was healthy: Feedback isn’t always helpful, just as making something “popular” isn’t the right metric for judging something’s value. After all, as soon as data and the algorithms get involved, there’s a formula: people who control budgets stop prioritizing stories that should be told and start trying to engineer success, tweaking the inputs. We’re back to If/Then statements: If this worked, then this will work. If people like this, then they’ll like this. It’s the same race to the bottom, dictated by commerce rather than art. It’s a disaster. Maybe it’s too late for Hollywood, but maybe the streamers will course correct before they crater engagement by burning us out on data-driven decisions. (There’s obviously lots of other stuff going on here, too, including choice paralysis.)
I’ve also been thinking about this a lot because it’s January, and people are earnestly re-engaging with their to-do lists and plotting their futures, and I always see an uptick in requests for advice from people who want to get in the content business, whether it’s launching a newsletter, a podcast, a book, or a brand that involves storytelling. People are looking for assurance, certainty, direction, convinced that there’s an audience development formula out there to engineer rapid and sustainable growth. They’ve been told that if they build it, people will come.
Oh, if only it were that simple. In some ways this is true, or it can be true, but it requires patience and a leap of faith. You can’t see this a game that you’re supposed to play and win, a code you’re supposed to crack, otherwise you’ll get addicted to growth curves and become enslaved to the machine. That’s probably not the impetus for making something in the first place.
My best advice is to focus on delivering for readers, and on the niche that you’re best prepared to fill—that, and to corral your expectations. Not that your expectations might not be far surpassed, but because expectations aren’t a good reason to do something. The etymology of expect come from Latin ex (“out”) + spectare (“to look”)—it’s the practice of waiting, specifically waiting for something that you’ve already defined. Expectations are training yourself for the If/Then, rather than staying in the present moment, rather than doing the thing itself, whatever it is that wants to come through you. Yes, there are short-cuts—“hacks” in today’s parlance—but if we’ve learned anything in these past two decades, it’s unclear where those shortcuts actually lead, and what you’ll be left with in the end. And whether that particular trip will be worth it.
Perhaps, instead of If you build it, they will come, we should go with: If you build it, something will happen. I firmly believe that you have to put yourself in motion for the universe to get behind you, but it’s not always healthy to know the destination. Nor is it good to know who “they” might be: They might not be hordes, they might be a small and mighty community, a baseball team. And they might come over time—slowly, organically, steadily, of their own volition. They might choose to spend time with you, rather than being forced into an algorithmic speed date where it’s on you to convince them to stay. Go for quality over quantity: It may not be grand, but it’s certainly more durable, more reliable, more nourishing.
I’ve been on Substack for a year today, and am so grateful for all of you, who have slowly, steadily, organically joined this community. I deeply appreciate your support.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
1/18: On growing ourselves up with Aliza Pressman, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript
1/11: On being with each other’s pain with Rabbi Sharon BrousApple | Spotify | Transcript
1/4: Embracing the Shadow with Connie Zweig, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/26: What motivates change with Carrie Wilkens, PhDApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/21: The power of trauma narrative with Akiva GoldsmanApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/17: Reducing harm and saving lives with Maia SzalavitzApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/14: The malleability of the brain with David EaglemanApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/10: Breaking the addiction binary with Carl Erik Fisher, M.D.Apple | Spotify | Transcript
12/7: The Gordian Knot of mental illness with Rachel AvivApple | Spotify | Transcript
12/3: Reimaging recovery with Holly WhitakerApple | Spotify | Transcript
11/30: Grappling with Part X with Phil StutzApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My New York Times bestselling book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.