I met Rabbi Steve Leder in 2022, when I interviewed him on Pulling the Thread. Rabbi Leder is the author of several bestselling books, including For You When I am Gone: Twelve Essential Questions to Tell a Life Story and The Beauty of What Remains. Both are about his work as the senior rabbi of Wilshire Boulevard Temple in Los Angeles, where he has helped thousands of people process the worst moments of their life. He does this on his “couch of tears,” which I’ve been lucky enough to visit. Despite not being part of his congregation, Rabbi Leder has generously sat with me as well, and answered my questions about Judaism, life, and faith. (He also furnished me with an excellent reading list, which I’ve shared at the bottom of the post.)

I saw Rabbi Leder at a Shabbat dinner in the immediate weeks after October 7th and I couldn’t help but think how tough it would be to lead a massive congregation right now—a congregation of people who are directly impacted. Not only must he manage so many peoples’ anguish, fear, grief, and rage, but he’s also looked to for answers about morality and policy—how does one understand and reconcile suffering on such a horrific level? The devastation unfolding throughout the region is an impossible and heartbreaking hell with no easy solutions, as much as we all desperately want it to end with a durable peace, and the assurance of safety, health, and freedom for all.

Rabbi Leder and I spoke for awhile at that Shabbat dinner—I was touched by his ability to stay calm and measured, and to hold the space for all that’s present. I asked him to hop on a Zoom, the contents of which are described below. We did not get into the Israeli government or foreign policy—I am not equipped to adjudicate those conversations, though I’ve been leaning on Ezra Klein’s podcast conversations for ongoing context and clarity, if you’re not already a listener and a fan. (His conversation with Nimrod Novik was excellent, as was the conversation with Tareq Boconi about how Hamas thinks. And needless to say, I loved his conversation with Rabbi Sharon Brous about “believing some aspects of Israel have become indefensible and also believing that Israel itself must be defended.” Rabbi Brous is joining me on Pulling the Thread in January to discuss her gorgeous upcoming book The Amen Effect. Please pre-order if you can.)

More about Rabbi Leder: After receiving his degree in writing and graduating cum laude from Northwestern University, and spending time studying at Trinity College, Oxford University, he received a master’s degree in Hebrew letters in 1986 and rabbinical ordination in 1987 from Hebrew Union College. Newsweek Magazine twice named him one of the ten most influential rabbis in America.

ELISE:

Rabbi Leder, you’ve seen a lot in your time. How do you explain how we seem to have collectively fractured at this moment and can’t seem to agree on basic facts?

RABBI LEDER:

Well, people in groups lose their minds. That’s a big part of it. They just lose their minds and fact and truth become completely beside the point. And I'll also tell you one of my favorite Yiddish sayings, which is that a half-truth is a whole lie. The conflation that we're seeing is the framing or the telling of a half-truth.

I have been preaching the value and necessity of disambiguating what's happening—and making it clear that Hamas and October 7th have nothing to do with the legitimate, nuanced, complicated rights of Palestinians and Israelis in the Middle East. It has nothing to do with the betterment of Palestinians. Nothing. That's not Hamas' mission. It never has been. And if we can disambiguate that, for me, that's my greatest hope for some level—among sane people—of agreement. Can we all at least agree that Hamas breaking the ceasefire on October 7th, and the barbaric way in which they chose to do so, was wrong? My congregation has everything, a very wide spectrum of political beliefs. I would say 30% of my congregation voted for Trump, and 20% probably voted for Bernie Sanders. We've got it all.

When George Floyd was murdered, and there was looting and burning, I heard from the right in my congregation: “This works against their own cause,” “two wrongs don’t make a right,” and on and on. And I said, “Okay, fine, but can we agree that a Black man was murdered by a racist cop in public and no one did anything? Can we at least acknowledge that as a recorded fact?” Most people were willing to do that. It created some sense of consensus and moral clarity. Conflation is the enemy.

ELISE:

When you think about this horrible quagmire that we're in, how are you leading your congregation through this and and how do we think about this morally, both from the perspective of the Torah, and just as people who care about people?

RABBI LEDER:

I can send you the speech I gave a couple of days after October 7th to the congregation at a memorial service that we had for what we then knew was more than a thousand people. I can send it to you because I think it lays out my leadership approach pretty clearly, which again, is disambiguating and not contextualizing this. But I’ll tell you some of the main points.

As I told you earlier, part of the reason I'm doing okay is that I am less surprised than most people that this happened. And I am less surprised than most people about the reality of our college campuses and the spineless leadership in most of academia. So it's both disambiguating in terms of the legitimate issues facing Palestinians and Israelis, but also it’s just the newest chapter in the oldest of stories. One example I can give you is, and I put this in the talk, if you read The New York Times account of the 1903 Kishinev pogrom, and you removed the name of the place and the date of the article, you could easily believe it was a New York Times article on October 8th, 2023. And if you read the Russian ambassador's interview with The New York Times in 1903 and remove his name, which was Cassini, and the date and the place, you would swear we were interviewing someone from Hamas on October 8th. He said: “The situation in Russia, so far as the Jews are concerned is just this: It is the peasant against the money lender, and not the Russians against the Jews. There is no feeling against the Jew in Russia because of religion. It is as I have said—the Jew ruins the peasants…”

Perhaps surprisingly to some, this gives me a sense of faith, and I'm trying to give that to my congregation.

We actually have been here before, not only in the Holocaust. We can defeat Hamas. Yes, something else will return in its place, but hopefully something less deadly, more productive, and better for the Palestinian people. The saddest part of this, beyond the savagery and brutalism and loss of life, is something Abba Eban said many years ago, when he was the Israeli ambassador to the United States. He quipped, “The Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.” And I quote him because what is an additional heartache for me is that Gaza could have been the Singapore of the Middle East. They're roughly the same size and have roughly the same size population.

There could have been seaside resorts, solar farms, green fields, desalinization, world-class hospitals, universities, museums, etcetera. But when Israel handed Gaza entirely over to the Palestinians in 2005, within 18 months, Hamas took over. There hasn't been an election since. And they chose the path of violence and Jew hatred instead of the path of uplifting the Palestinian people in their own independent nation, with their own freedom and agency. There hasn't been a Jew living in Gaza other than hostages since 2005. So this business about colonization and occupation when it comes to Gaza—not the admittedly more complex issues on the West Bank—but when it comes to Gaza, this business about occupation is complete and total bullshit, as is this rhetoric about it being the world's largest outdoor prison. And more specifically, that being Israel's fault.

People conveniently forget that Egypt also has a border with Gaza that they closed. Now, if Israel closes the border and Egypt, their Arab brethren closed the border, maybe the problem is not with Israel and Egypt. Maybe the problem is in Gaza. If Gaza is a massive outdoor prison, then Hamas is the warden and the prison gang in charge. And I know I'm on a bit of a rant here, Elise, but even if we accept, which I do not, but even if we accept that it is a prison, when prisoners escape from prison, there is nothing admirable and there is no entitlement to rape and torture and murder and beheading and burning and kidnapping. And I also want to make the deeper point here, which is to say that when you hear: “What can you expect? What do you expect from Hamas after all this oppression, etcetera”—when you say this, you are insulting Hamas, because it is calling them subhuman. It is removing agency. They are human, they do have agency. They did make choices. And those are the facts.

ELISE:

I want to go in two directions. First, I want to explore the moral implications for Israel. Israel is in an impossible place, and it’s very easy from over here to denounce Israel and pass judgment when there’s no clear path forward. So, what do we do? And then I’d love to hear you talk about your faith, and this repeating story across time—how do we close this book?

RABBI LEDER:

Let’s start with Israel's choices. And this, I know after almost 40 years of being a rabbi and listening to people sit on what I call “my couch of tears.” Most of us were raised by well-meaning parents and teachers and a society that taught us that when you have a decision to make, if you make the right decision, there will be a good outcome. And if you make the wrong decision, there will be a bad outcome. But I have learned that much more often than people realize, life does not present us with a good choice and a bad choice. It presents us with a bad choice and a worse choice. And that's the position Israel is in. This is not a new story, but Golda Meir put it pretty well when she said, “If we have to choose between being dead and pitied or alive with a bad reputation, we'll take the bad reputation.”

And that's where Israel is, and that's where Israel has always been. And much of the world, including much of the Arab world, privately although very rarely if ever publicly, wants to get rid of Hamas. And Israel is the only country willing to do it. So Israel is in a way, from every corner, put in this very difficult position. And it's hard to understand unless you live in that neighborhood. But when I say to people who live in Los Angeles, for example, imagine 40,000 rockets on Mulholland pointed at you in Studio City. You live in Studio City and the rockets are on Mulholland. That’s how far Gaza is from these kibbutzim. So, what would you want your government to do?

I hope that analogy is piercing enough for people to understand the proximity of the danger. And I hope that no rational person requires further illustration or understanding of the ruthlessness of the enemy. I've seen the raw footage, and Elise, you cannot unsee these things once you've seen them. You cannot unsee them. It was like when I was 12-years-old, I saw Night and Fog in Sunday school. Those black and white images of emaciated bodies bulldozed into pits with a kind of somber French narrator. You can't unsee these things. So this is the situation Israel's in. They have a bad choice and a worse choice. Now, what's the path forward? Here's why I'm hopeful.

Why did Hamas do this now? They did it now because Israel and Saudi Arabia were very close to a peace agreement, maybe a cold peace, probably a cold peace, but a peace nevertheless, which would fundamentally change the dynamic of the Middle East. Saudi Arabia is Sunni, and 85% of the Muslims in the world are Sunni. Saudi Arabia also has the two holiest places in all of Islam within its borders. A peace treaty with Israel would likely and hopefully immediately create detente with 85% of the Muslim world and further marginalize the government of Iran, who I think we can all agree are the bastards of the planet along with a few of their friends. So Hamas did this to sabotage that agreement. My hope is that once this war is over, whatever that means, because we don't really know yet what that means, there will be a massive Marshall Plan reconstruction of Gaza.

It will be handed over by Israel to a more responsible Palestinian leadership, and then the deal with Saudi Arabia will proceed. Because here is the good news: We know that Israel is capable of making peace with its Arab neighbors, and we know its Arab neighbors are capable of making peace with Israel. The peace with Egypt has held, the peace with Jordan has held, the peace with the UAE has held, the peace with Bahrain has held, the peace with Morocco has held, even the peace with Sudan has held. Peace agreements work. You can make a deal with Israel if peace is your objective. If the death of all Jews is your objective, there can be no peace. But I'm hopeful. Look, I have no inside information, but I'm hopeful that this will result in peace being made with Saudi Arabia, and that is a huge step in the right direction.

ELISE:

So let's talk about this repeating history. I'm working on a newsletter about early Christianity and reading the New Testament as “wartime literature,” to quote professor Elaine Pagels, and the way that the Jews were retroactively blamed for Rome's crimes, namely for killing Jesus as a salve for Roman guilt. I mean, who were the people crucifying 500 people a day? It wasn’t the Jews who were occupied by the Romans. So, what is this about?

RABBI LEDER:

Look, any knowledgeable Jew who understands history in general and more specifically Jewish history knows that, first of all, we have to decide: when does history begin, which is a huge question. This “what aboutism” is really about whose history began when, which is nothing but a race to the bottom. But this much we do know. We do know that Judaism was created and born out of a different way of understanding deity and the human experience. Monotheism is one of the two most profound ideas that Judaism has brought to the world. This idea that, unlike Paganism, which views the world as being sustained through this clashing and dichotomous tension of the gods, that the world is sustained by chaos and tension, like a celestial, dysfunctional family, Judaism comes along and says: No, all is one. The world is not sustained through conflict and tension, it's sustained through oneness and wholeness. Peace means wholeness. And this immediately made Jews outsiders. And we know from the Psalms that the Babylonians, when they exiled Jews and destroyed the temple in 586 BCE, threw Jewish babies off of cliffs. We know that. We know about, you know, you're writing about it, what the Romans did to the Jewish outsider, including the threat that Jesus was to the establishment—Jesus, who was a rabbi teaching Judaism, let's start with that.

ELISE:

Teaching Judaism to his 12 Jewish apostles!

RABBI LEDER:

Yes, one of whom, after Jesus' death created a new religion, which was fine! By the way, just as an aside, Elise, this may blow your mind because you're a scholar. The real issue with Paul was that Paul was willing to do away with circumcision as a requisite commandment for a gentile to convert to Judaism or be “saved.” He did away with it, and the rabbis could not abide by it. That was a bridge too far for them. Years ago, I asked Josh Galloway, who's one of the leading authorities on the intertestamental period, “Josh, if the rabbis had agreed to forego circumcision for gentiles to be saved, would there be a billion Christians or a billion Jews in the world today?” And he said, “There'd be a billion Jews.” That’s an amazing aside, and an amazing thing to think about, a sort of sliding doors look at the past and present.

So we know what the Babylonians did. We know what the Romans did. And we know that when Christianity was chosen as the official religion of the Roman Empire, and the name Judea was changed to Palestine, we know that from that day forward, Jews were marginalized, and victimized, and scapegoated. And very often for taking the only avenues made available to them because of the prohibitions placed upon them, because of their Judaism. And the prohibitions placed upon Christians like dealing with money, for example. And then we move on to the Crusades. When I saw some of the raw footage from October 7th, it reminded me of the martyrology in the Yom Kippur service about the 10 Rabbis. Of course there were more, but 10 rabbis who represent all of the Jews who were tortured by the Romans because they refused the edict to stop teaching Torah, are remembered every Yom Kippur. Rabbi Akiva was flailed alive with an iron rake. They raked his skin off until he died.

Rabbi Hanineh ben Teradion was wrapped in a Torah scroll, and then they put wet wool over his vital organs and set the scroll on fire. The wet wool was so that he would die a slower, more painful death. We know this happened. Then we moved to the pogroms, then we move, of course, to the Holocaust. I can give you a thousand other examples of what it means to be an outsider. Now the irony of all of this, is that so much of the Jew hatred that we're seeing now is framing Jews as the majoritarian white privileged culture. Nevermind that more than half the Jews in Israel are people of color.

Let's go back to what happened in Iran when the Shah was deposed. What happened to all of those Jews who left with nothing but a suitcase? A friend of ours, Mandana Dayani, was four years old when she had a gun put to her head in Iran.

This is an old story, and a new story, and it's the same story. And now I'm going to offer you a theory, which you may or may not agree with, but I believe it. I think the unique American dynamic here, and European dynamic, is that if you want to hate white successful people…I don't like using the word privileged here, because everyone is privileged in some way or another, and everyone has a deficit of some kind. I can turn a phrase, but I can't make a three pointer. I can't do math, I failed algebra in ninth grade. But if you want to hate successful white people, as long as it's Jews, you mostly get a free pass because most people don’t really care about Jew hatred all that much. Jew hatred is an acceptable form of hatred directed toward white people. And I'm not talking about white supremacists where that's obviously not true. It's not about skin color. But for these idiot graduates of TikTok University marching on campuses for Hamas and calling October 7th a “counter-offensive,” I think what they're really doing is playing the victim and lashing out at white privilege.

Ironically, some of these activists are marching for Hamas. These are feminists marching for rape. These are LGBTQ+ people marching for homophobia and torture and murder. The way the Romans tied homosexuals to a bundle of wood and set it on fire, which is where fag or faggot comes from.

ELISE:

Oh, really? I didn't know that.

RABBI LEDER:

Yes, that's where it started. A fag is a term for a bundle of wood before it came to be the term for a cigarette. And so they would tie homosexuals to a bundle of wood and set it on fire. And that's how they became known as faggots or fags. And here they are marching for Hamas. It makes no sense other than their Jew hatred subordinates every other value they say they believe in. There's no other explanation.

ELISE:

I think everyone is so full of unease, anxiety, and guilt, that they need to put this bad feeling somewhere. We’re not equipped to process our own anxiety in this culture. I’m not suggesting that it’s okay to project it onto the enemy “out there” but I think that’s what’s happening: We want to claim moral righteousness and project all of our bad feeling onto an easy target. (I wrote about this in these newsletter (“The Scapegoat” and “Self-Help Needs a Rebrand.”)

RABBI LEDER:

Yes, it’s displaced anxiety. It's displaced anger. I often, on my “couch of tears” remind people that when someone slams a door, they're not angry at the door. Unfortunately, Jews are the door, again and again and again. And when you're the door, it's hard not to take it personally.

ELISE:

I know. And there’s so much history, on all sides, that people just don’t know. And yet they feel so certain in passing judgment. Like I don’t think people realize why Jews ended up in Europe. That they were enslaved and displaced—that enslaved Jews built the Roman Colosseum, for one—and that they’ve been refugees for millennia.

RABBI LEDER:

There were a million Jews in the Arab world who are no longer in the Arab world because they were booted out. Now again, whose history begins when, and so on and so forth…it’s an endless question. I often say to people, Elise, I've given up all hope of a better past. We can't have a better past. It's a blunt instrument when I say that. But it's also very instructive and effective. We have to now talk about moving forward. And listen, I'm going to leave you with a great thing I just learned last week. You ready?

ELISE:

Yes!

RABBI LEDER:

I was in New York last week, and Betsy, and I, and our son Aaron took a bagel making class from this guy named Sam Silverman, who is the bagel ambassador of Manhattan. He teaches these classes and organizes a big bagel festival every year. So we took a bagel baking class, and I asked him about the history of the bagel. He said the bagel was created by 17th-century Polish Jews. Why? Because they were forbidden to bake bread. They were forbidden to bake bread in Poland because the Christian bakers didn't want the competition. And because metaphorically, bread was associated with the body of Christ, and they didn't want Jews anywhere near that.

So the Jews came up with this idea, a loophole, a workaround of boiling rather than baking. That's why there's a hole in the bagel so that it boils and cooks evenly. And that loophole enabled them to eat grain products and to have their own form of bread. It was an adaptation, born of restriction and oppression. Amazing. And most of those Jews, when they were forced out by pogroms, went to New York and Montreal, which are the epicenters of bagel culture. Even though it's become more universal—and I don't mean it to be as silly as it sounds—it's an example of how, when the status quo or the equilibrium is disrupted or punctuated for Jews, it results in an adaptation and an upward evolution of what it means to be a Jew.

ELISE:

We make something new. I love that.

RABBI LEDER:

Isn’t that great? That's where I'm hopeful.

ELISE:

This is awful, awful for everyone—but from here, I can only hope and pray that we'll end up in a better place.

RABBI LEDER:

I guess the way I put it, is if you have to go through hell, don't come out empty handed. And that's the real goal here. None of it is worth it, but we can't allow it to be worthless.

RABBI STEVE LEDER’S SPEECH AFTER 10/7

A Letter to My Children

Dear Aaron and Hannah,

Auntie Marilyn texted me on Wednesday asking me to call Grandma. You know that Grandma is turning 90 and has dementia—you know that she is easily and often confused. “Steven honey,” she said to me in tears, “they are killing babies.” Evil pierced the fog and numbness of her failing brain. Evil has also pierced your hopeful and tender hearts and those of your friends. Like all parents and all their children, it has always been painful for mommy and me to see your innocence and your hearts shattered by lost love, by failure, by life, and by death. I am so sorry for you, for your friends, and for everyone who now knows what they did not before October 7th.

I and many others already know this is merely the newest chapter in a very old story. We know the Babylonians threw Jewish babies off the cliffs of ancient Israel, 2,700 years ago. We know that ancient Romans flayed the skin off of Rabbi Akiva with an iron rake because he refused to stop teaching Torah. We know they wrapped Rabbi Haninah ben Teradion in a Torah scroll and set it ablaze on a bed of grass. We know they placed wet wool on his chest to slow the burn and prolong his suffering. We know his disciples begged him to open his mouth and inhale the smoke so that he would die more quickly. We know that he refused… We know 500 years ago the Spaniards burned Jews at the stake if they did not convert to Christianity.

We know the New York Times reported a pogrom in Kishinev this way on April 28, 1903. “The mob was led by priests, and the general cry, ‘Kill the Jew,’ was taken-up all over the city. The Jews were taken wholly unaware and were slaughtered like sheep. The scenes of horror attending this massacre are beyond description. Babes were literally torn to pieces by the frenzied and bloodthirsty mob. At sunset the streets were piled with corpses and wounded.”

We know The Russian ambassador to the United States, Count Arthur Cassini, flipped the script and framed the victims as the victimizers in an interview on May 18, 1903. “The situation in Russia, so far as the Jews are concerned is just this: It is the peasant against the money lender, and not the Russians against the Jews. There is no feeling against the Jew in Russia because of religion. It is as I have said—the Jew ruins the peasants…”

And of course, you and already knew about the world remaining mostly silent as Nazis murdered 6 million Jews—beaten, raped, executed, and gassed; one million children, gassed, incinerated and turned into smoke…smoke. And it is wrong to say or think that six million Jews died in the Holocaust. In truth, one Jew died, six million times. Each was a unique miracle born out of love. Each had a family, and gifts for the world, and dreams ending in fear and pain…so much fear and pain.

I know you feel abandoned by so many of your friends…we all feel abandoned right now. “Where are you?” we wonder. “We marched with you. We supported you. We reached out to you. We allied with you in your fight for dignity and justice. Where are you?” It pains me to tell you this. But most people are better at virtue signaling than acting with virtue. Many who claim to be woke are asleep when it comes to us…to you. They do not care that it if we sat in one second of silence for each Jew murdered by Hamas we would be sitting in silence for more than 25 minutes. They do not care that the number of dead Jews by percentage is equal to 44,000 dead Americans on 9/11. They do not care that before those 44,000 Americans were murdered, they would have been dragged through the streets of Manhattan, hands tied, gang-raped, bleeding, tortured, stripped bare, paraded, and beheaded. I am sorry for the heartbreaking truth you and your friends now see so clearly. Every generation of Jews has its wake-up call. October 7, 2023 is yours.

You know that when I am trying to help someone through trauma I often say that we cannot have a better past. So, now what? Now, be morally clear. Know who your friends are and who they are not.

The dynamic between the Arab nations, Palestinians and Israel is complex. Feel for the innocent Palestinians who have been the political football of the middle east for a century. They deserve better from their Arab brethren, they deserve better from Israel and the west. But do not allow the script to be flipped. Be morally clear and do not allow the legitimate rights of anyone, anywhere, to be conflated with what happened on October 7th. Hamas’ mission is not about bettering the lives of Palestinians. But its mission is very clear and it alone is the root cause of Gazan’s misery and ours. “The Day of Judgment will not come about until Muslims fight Jews and kill them. Then, the Jews will hide behind rocks and trees, and the rocks and trees will cry out: ‘O Muslim, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come and kill him.”

On Rosh Hashanah, three weeks before this massacre, I said to our congregation, “We often think of life as a series of good and bad choices followed by good and bad outcomes. But for the Jewish people life sometimes offers us not good or bad choices, but bad and worse choices. Golda Meir put it this way, ‘If we have to have a choice between being dead and pitied, and being alive with a bad image, we’d rather be alive and have the bad image.’” Sure, her point and mine lack nuance. Israel’s choices are not always so binary, but right now, they are.

This is the truth I am the sorriest you now know. There is a difference between murder and killing. Hamas murders Jews and murder forces Israelis to kill, even when innocent people die in the process. It is the most tragic of truths, but Hamas offers us no other choice.

Why did Hamas do this now? Not only because their mission is to murder Jews, but also because Israel was on the verge of making peace with an enemy; perhaps a cold peace, but peace nevertheless. Eighty-five percent of Muslims in the world are Sunni. Peace with Saudi Arabia means peace with 85% of Muslims. It means an end to the religious component of middle east conflict with Israel. It means a rejection of the rejectionist ideology of Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, Islamic Brotherhood, Qatar and Iran; an ideology that does not want peace…only dead Jews, only blood.

Your Papa was tough. I saw him cry only twice in my life. Once was at 16 years old, when we said goodbye as I boarded a plane for my first trip to Israel. I miss him so much, but I am glad he is not alive to see what you have now seen. I know your hearts are broken, and you are angry, and confused, and feel so alone, so misunderstood. I am sorry for your broken hearts; for our broken hearts. But there are some things that can only enter our hearts when they are broken.

Things like how much we need each other, our truest friends, our real allies, and the stranger sitting next to us in shul who is no longer a stranger at all; who is our brother, our sister, our comfort and our hope. The good people in our lives who are not Jews that have reached out, who do care, who are morally clear. They too give us comfort and hope. America and our President, give us hope.

So amid the confusion and the fog, be clear and remember, that to be a Jew is never to lose hope for a beautiful end to the oldest of stories. What did the poet mean when he wrote that verse in the 23rd Psalm, “Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies?” I think he meant to give us hope in the battle against fatalism; to tell us we can make peace with our enemies and with each other. Who could have imagined a Jewish nation rising from the ashes three years after Hitler’s death? Who could have imagined a lasting peace with Egypt, Jordan, the UAE, Sudan, Bahrain and Morocco? Who could have imagined potential peace with Saudi Arabia?

“Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil,” says another verse in that powerful and poignant Psalm; reminding us that we will somehow walk through this valley of shadows together; we will not remain in it forever. For what is a shadow really, but proof of light? A shadow, no matter how dark, or how long, cannot exists unless a powerful light still shines. It is obstructed, but it shines. Hate, is love obstructed, murdered even, but it is not love extinguished. Hate is not the end of hope, but the beginning of a battle summoning us to a deeper faith, to clarity and courage; it is a solemn oath to a more beautiful tomorrow…

Aaron and Hannah, you were born out of the deepest, most magical love. You, Mommy and I, our people, our Torah, and God are the stuff of dreams for better, for love, for peace. No matter what must be done, never allow such dreams to be murdered; never allow hope to die. No matter how deep the valley and long shadows, we surely will emerge again into warmth and light. Until then, be strong, be brave, be clear.

Love,Dad

THE READING LIST RABBI LEDER GAVE TO ME:

A Treasury of Yiddish Stories, by Irving Howe and Eliezer Greenberg

Found Treasures: Stories by Yiddish Women Writers by Frieda Forman, Ethel Ralcus, and Silberstein Swartz