“I can’t decide if this book I’m finishing is so obvious it doesn’t need to be stated, or it will confuse everyone. I guess what I’m trying to say is that it’s either the best thing I’ve ever written or it’s trash.”
Ummm, okay? As I said this to my friend—also an author—she laughed. Did I realize I was stringing together diametrically opposed statements? (It reminds me of another one of my favorites: “I’m the biggest piece of shit that the whole world revolves around.”) She texted over a link to one of my newsletters from last summer (“The String of Pearls”).

“Read your own book,” she offered, “and use Stutz’s tool.” (I co-authored True & False Magic with the wonderful psychiatrist Phil Stutz, co-author of The Tools and the subject of the Netflix documentary, Stutz.) “My editor records my feelings week over week to remind me when I’m spiraling that three weeks ago I was like, ‘This is my best work yet,’” she continued. “This is our version of the String of Pearls.” Smart. (It’s like a mash-up between String of Pearls and The Science of Reality, which is still the hands-down best tool for dealing with uncertainty. Essentially, you write down your predictions about the future to illustrate that when it comes down to what actually happens…“you don’t know shit,” to quote Stutz.)
I’m guessing that all of you who create things—whether it’s paintings, board decks, novels, or meals-from-scratch—know this particular roller coaster well and have been its passenger many, many times. Riding the waves of ego inflation and deflation is par for the course, and it’s also painful. You vacillate wildly—yes, even in the same sentence, often in the same day—between thinking you should win a Pulitzer and believing your editor will cancel your contract. It’s very disorienting.
As a reminder, here’s Stutz’s tool, as described in True & False Magic.
The Tool: String of Pearls
“We need a functional definition of success in our culture, particularly because it’s so wrapped up with identity. You can’t structure your life around an identity where you win and you’re a big shot, or you lose and you’re nothing. In my practice, I’d see a writer who would say, “I thought I was a good writer but I’m shitty. I reread the last thing I wrote, and it sucked.” My next session would be with a different screenwriter, who would come in, all pissed off: “I know that spec screenplay was the best they’ve read all year, and I don’t even get a phone call.” Neither of these responses—I suck, or I’m the greatest—is within the functional line of creation. Neither of those extremes will help you. You can’t ask questions like Am I succeeding? Am I great or am I failing? Am I worthless? None of these things are true as an absolute value. The identity you want to have is that you are the person who puts the next pearl on the string. That’s it. You’re no better, and you’re no worse. This is the only way to avoid a common story in our culture, where someone gets to the point where they feel they’re so successful, they don’t need to try anymore, or the opposite, where they don’t believe that anything they do makes a difference. You must return to this idea that you don’t know anything, that you’re simply putting the next pearl on the string.
“When people are working on a project, or working at their jobs, and they hit a glitch, they can choose to say, Well, this last effort I made was fantastic, and I’ve proven to everyone that I’m the biggest star in the world, or they can say the opposite, something like, I’m a bum and I failed at the key moments. The person who puts the next pearl on the string says, I’m neither this guy up here, nor am I the biggest piece of shit; I’m just a schmuck who puts one pearl on the string and then another. The string of pearls has to do with an identity; it’s a tool to be evoked when you’re at a crossroads and you’re freaking out over the possibility that it won’t end in a way that’s to your liking. You’re building yourself up to the idea that you welcome future events, that you’re confident you can handle them because of this tool. In fact, the bigger the event, the better you can handle it. This person doesn’t particularly care about the results, because no matter what happens, it’s the material world, and it can’t be a final step. There’s no guarantee of anything actually working, but you are going to proceed anyway. In a world of process, there is no final step. It’s an infinite universe, and the best you can do is keep up with the universe through constant work.”
The String of Pearls is very helpful. Like all of you, I’m just putting the next pearl on the string, working my hardest to keep up with the continually unfolding universe.
And sometimes it feels like you have to run hard to keep up with the universe. I think this is another under-addressed part of creativity, that feeling of mania that comes over you (or me, at least) which I can only liken to childbirth. It’s that feeling that the “work” is coming and you need to try to catch it in the classiest and most contained way that you can. (This is why I’m such a structure nut, so I can be somewhat prepared for these moments that feel like a flood.)
Even when you’re prepared, you might only catch a small fraction of “the work” as it exists in your mind. You can see it, and feel its contours and energy, and understand its weight—but then you have to translate it, and bring it over the threshold from your imagination into form, and that’s when it gets awfully hard. (My friend, the painter Alexandra Grant describes it as “The Museum in Your Mind.” You can listen to our podcast conversation about the creative process here: “On Collaborating with Ourselves.”)
I wrote about this a bit last summer in a newsletter called “Getting Over Creative Disappointment,” but having a sense for what it is that you’re trying to do is very different than actually capturing it on the page, or the canvas, or in the pan. As the Jungian Marie-Louis von Franz writes in Creation Myths, “Within oneself, one has a perfect image of something, and therefore one picks up the paintbrush or pencil with great enthusiasm. What one then ends up with on paper is a very sad, imperfect, and awkward copy, most disappointing when one compares it with the inner image that one set out to portray. According to my own experience, I become completely preoccupied with these inner images, and I seem to be able to see them on the paper in front of me. A real descent from above to below is always accompanied by disappointment. One can readily understand this, for, in the world of archetypes, one is inflated, as one is dealing with the gods. But this inflation is necessary because one cannot be creative without a certain enthusiasm. One needs this intensity and momentum, and it comes from God.” (As you probably know, the etymology of enthusiasm is en + theos, which is to be possessed by God.)
So how do you manage through this? I think my author friend is correct: You record your emotional response to your work, day by day, until you understand that it actually has no standing in reality. You can’t trust the inflation, and you can’t trust the deflation either. Instead, you just keep going, one sentence at a time, taking advantage of the fits of enthusiasm to take some big strides in whatever you’re trying to create. We’re all just schmucks, putting the next pearl on the string.
(And if it feels hard to create in this moment, I get that too—but as Stutz would also say, the antidote to evil is not “goodness,” it’s actually creativity—you don’t have to create anything specific, you just need to conspire with the universe to make things and move forward, one step at a time.)
LINK TO REGISTER FOR OFFICE HOURS ON FEBRUARY 7TH at 10AM
When: Feb 7, 2026 10:00 AM Pacific Time (US and Canada)
Register in advance for this meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/sy2QeXcjSbSZZJ5Lwyw2ew
After registering, you will receive a confirmation email containing information about joining the meeting.