
I wrote 18 drafts of my introduction to On Our Best Behavior. I have no clue if that’s typical for other writers, but that was my journey: You’ve got one shot to synthesize your thinking and boil 90,000 words into a compelling synopsis that inspires bookstore browsers to buy your book—and then to keep reading. A well-crafted introduction can’t necessarily make a book, but the absence of one can likely can break it.
Unsurprisingly, I had a lot of ideas that I wanted to roll into 10 pages, and one of those was the presence of the 7 Deadly Sins in other cultural tales, specifically fairy tales…like Snow White. The section below didn’t make the cut, but my editor, Whit, promised me I’d find a way to use it someday, so here we are. The invitation? The legendary New York Times writer, Sarah Lyall, referred to me as a “Tomboy Snow White” in the paper.
Being compared to a Disney princess might be odd, except that Snow White is specifically, if subtly, connected to the Seven Deadly Sins (see below). And, as much as I love the associations between the book and the Barbie movie, when I read that Disney is remaking Snow White with Rachel Zegler of West Side Story fame, and that her casting (she’s Latina) and her commentary on the necessary updates to the story had sparked (racist) outrage and online bullying, it seemed like an even more meta statement on how we expect to see women. Zegler’s inflammatory statements about Snow White include this zinger: “She's not going to be saved by the prince and she's not going to be dreaming about true love.” She also mentioned in this salacious interview that it’s…no longer 1937. (Interestingly, though not surprisingly, her comments also sparked an additional backlash on TikTok that her statements are anti-feminist because women should be allowed to want the Disney fairytale too.) Honestly, it’s all wild.
Below, the parallels between Snow White and the 7 Deadly Sins; Whit, I hope you’re pleased.
When we were very little, probably three and five, my older brother, Ben, and I would pile blankets and pillows in an alcove beneath the stairs and read together. Actually, he could read; I would pretend, using books with pictures to decode the stories. My favorite volume was The Grimm Fairy Tales. I loved Hansel & Gretel, because Ben and I played in the woods together daily and it was easy to project ourselves into those roles, on guard against an old woman looking to cook and eat us. But I was most smitten with Snow White, one of the only heroines with raven hair like me.
In the version we owned, Snow White’s evil stepmother queen learns from her magical mirror that Snow White’s beauty surpasses her own. Enraged and envious, she sends a huntsman to take the seven-year-old Snow White into the woods to murder her—he is to cut out Snow White’s heart and bring it back so the queen can eat it. The huntsman can’t bring himself to kill her, so he kills an animal for its heart instead, and releases Snow White; he assumes she’ll soon be ravaged by wild animals. Scared and alone, she finds a house with seven place settings, samples everyone’s food and drink, tries out the seven beds for size, and falls asleep. In the morning, she meets the seven dwarfs, all miners, who promise her protection so long as she cleans, cooks, and sews. When the evil queen realizes Snow White is still alive, she assembles magical disguises to trick Snow White to her death. Despite warnings from the dwarfs to admit no strangers, Snow White can’t help herself. First, the evil queen corsets her so tightly she passes out (the dwarfs discover her and release her stays); next, the evil queen tempts Snow White to use a poisoned comb (the dwarfs find her again and remove the comb); and finally, she lures her with a poisoned apple, which Snow White eats, putting her into a deep sleep. The dwarfs confine her to a glass coffin where she grows, until a prince discovers her, buys her, and stumbles while carrying her through the woods, which dislodges the apple from her throat. She wakes up and the evil queen is forced to dance in hot coal shoes at their wedding until she drops dead.
While the German Grimm brothers’ names are on hundreds of these stories, they didn’t write them—they collected and compiled them. Originally titled Children’s & Household Tales and published in 1812, variations of these stories existed in the oral traditions of all of Europe, and often beyond. These stories—intended to instruct on the meaning of life, moralism, and the polarity of good and evil (and beautiful and ugly, and smart and dumb, etc.)—are very, very old. They are also the canon of the contemporary Western world, the stories we grew up on: They are Disney, though the animated versions were largely scrubbed of their original, darker themes, like incest, oedipal complexes,[*] cannibalism,[†] and rape.[‡] It’s only in recent years that we’ve recognized these stories—despite their sanitizing—as deeply problematic and patriarchal: Most overtly, we’ve rejected this idea of passive princesses waiting to be rescued. What exactly are we teaching our daughters, we wondered, about desirability and love and what leads to a happy ending? So we pushed for new and different stories, where girls get to be heroes and save themselves and each other (i.e. Frozen). But the hangover remains, and the mold—apart from epics like Moana—is barely broken. The programming we’ve consumed subconsciously for millennia goes so much deeper than who gets to dress up as the hero. The legacy of these stories is so much more sinister and insidious than handsome princes rescuing beautiful princesses from old hags. Incidentally, Snow White, is the first feature-length movie Disney made (1937).
As I re-examined Snow White, which I loved so much as a child, I was struck by several things that were too subtle for my young mind to consciously grasp: The Evil Queen is a witch, for one, possessed by Narcissistic pride and vanity. We recognize Snow White as the story about intergenerational envy, but the Queen’s actions are also guided by anger and greed: She must be the fairest of them all, there’s no room for rivals. And finally, there are sexual undertones in the original, papered over by Disney, as well as hints of gluttony: She wants to feast on Snow White’s heart. Meanwhile, Snow White is innocent, pure, and kind—in Disney’s version, she’s beloved by all, including the entire animal kingdom. She wins over the Seven Dwarfs affection and protection through her diligence as a hard-working collective housewife. In the original story, the Evil Queen/Witch, disguised as an old crone, uses Snow White’s burgeoning vanity to tempt her to death by way of a corset, a comb. Ultimately, she is felled by a poisoned red apple, just like Eve. In the movie, the evil queen is hounded off a cliff by the animals and Snow White is resurrected by the kiss of a prince, getting her vengeance and happy ending. What that story taught me decades ago, without my conscious awareness, is that my safety and security depend on the protection of men, earned through unremitting goodness and hard work at home. But, because I am a woman, the forces of evil will always pray upon my nature—and likely be too strong. Snow White is a parable about the protections of the patriarchy, and the female predilection for the Seven Deadly Sins. It’s about the depravity of women—the older-woman-as-witch and the younger version who will someday dethrone and usurp her.
I was cleaning out my storage unit the other day when I found my college thesis projects. I was a double-major, in English and Fine Arts. My senior project in photography revolved around modern-day fairtyales and their archetypes (25 years later, I give myself an A on the idea, and a C- on the cheesiness of execution). And I wrote my English thesis on Andrew Marvell, John Milton, and the loss of childhood innocence in the Garden of Eden (that’s all I can tell you about it because it’s so stacked with expensive words it’s impenetrable—I don’t understand anything I wrote). In my adult life, I tried to move on, but it’s apparent now that I can’t. Not only have I been seized by these ideas for a long time, but I believe the stories women have been told about who we are continue to hold us by the throat, constricting our lives to this day. We need to find their roots and tug them from our minds, so we can plant something truer in their stead.
[*] In the earliest versions of these folktales, there was no “step”—these stories used oedipal lust and mother/daughter jealousy as central themes. They were sanitized over time to make this less overt by orphaning children and leaving them in the hands of evil stepmothers.
[†] Some versions stipulate the Queen eats Snow White’s liver and lungs. Newer versions omit the cannibalism.
[‡] There is a lot of kissing-without-consent in the Disney movies, arguably better than the fairy tale originals. In Sleeping Beauty, for example, the King finds her in a coma and impregnates her. She gives birth to twins; one of the babies sucks on her finger, which removes the splinter left by the spindle, and she wakes up. The King eventually rediscovers her (and his children) and they get married. There’s also cannibalism in this original.