I recently power-read The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership, per the recommendation of Courtney Smith (she did the explication of the Drama Triangle for us a few weeks ago). Co-written by Diana Chapman, Jim Dethmer, and Kaley Klemp, this book is an articulation of the fundamental premise of the Conscious Leadership Group: You can be below-the-line, the land of victim consciousness, blaming, and drama triangles where you feel like the world is happening to you, or you can work hard to occasionally get above-the-line, where you feel like the world is happening both through and by you. When you’re above-the-line, instead of seeing villains and foes everywhere, you see everyone as an ally: It might not be their intention, but they are there to teach you some sort of lesson as you evolve and grow. As part of this, you lose the desire to prove that you’re right about everything.

In their experience coaching individuals within complex organizations, there’s a predictable pattern that drives people below-the-line:
1. Something doesn’t go the way we think it should.
2. We become stuck in fear (often the anger that we feel is masking our fear).
3. We blame others, ourselves, or the system.
4. Relationships solidify around the roles of victim, villain, and hero.
(You can read more about the Drama Triangle here.)
The authors argue that we’re below-the-line approximately 98% of the time. It’s our natural state, particularly when fear or any threat to our identity is at play (you know, when we mess something up, say the wrong thing, do something disappointing, find our ideas being challenged). But when we can get ourselves above-the-line, watch out! Things get interesting, fun, creative, more aligned, and playful.
While a commitment to play is one of the 15 commitments, most of them are a little more difficult—and aligned with many of the themes I explore in On Our Best Behavior, including a massive section on exploring repressed emotions. Chapman, Dethmer, and Klemp open the book with an exploration on candor and a willingness to embrace conflict, which none of us are particularly skilled at—for women, in particular, conflict is tough, as we’re schooled in the cultural belief that anger will likely result in relational loss. Plus, we’ve long been told that women just aren’t aggressive—girls don’t push or yell. Well, this isn’t true—women are aggressive; we’re just taught as girls to funnel this aggression through covert expression, like alliance building, backstabbing, whisper networks, etc. Boys are allowed to push and yell; men as well. Look no further than the threat of a cage fight between Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg. You can’t make this up, nor can you find a better example of a below-the-line leader than Elon Musk.
So what exactly is conscious candor? Dethmer, Chapman, and Klemp offer this as the required Venn Diagram of conditions:
Truthfulness: “What I say represents my reality accurately.” (Opposite: LYING)
Openness: “I say everything I need to say.” (Opposite: WITHHOLDING)
Awareness: “I see as much as there is to see.” (Opposite: UNINFORMED)
They expound:
“One final point about candor. At any particular time, leaders are operating from either fear or love. This is simple yet profoundly true. Underneath all withholds is fear. We choose to withhold because we’re afraid of losing approval, control, or security.
“Conversely, candor comes from love. The Bible says, ‘Speak the truth in love.’ It couldn’t be said better. Real candor is expressing the unarguable truth from love. When you develop a mastery of candor, you speak the unarguable truth to all relevant parties with thoughtfulness and kindness. Speaking from love is not a license to withhold or sugarcoat our unarguable truth, because we don’t want to ‘hurt someone’s feelings’ (which is the most common reason people give for not wanting to be candid). Rather, speaking from love asks this question: ‘How do I say all my truth in the most loving way possible?’”
The trio also do a pretty thorough exposition of gossip, which is often the result when candor isn’t baked into a culture. I have mixed feelings about maligning gossip—I’ve made an etymology video about the word before and its implications, specifically in the way it’s typically weaponized against women. (It comes from godparent, and became an offense during the European witch hunts, specifically against women who would gather and talk. It became a crime to chat and share information, as we’ve always done.) So, I’d like a fresh, new word, even as I understand the context that the authors offer: Saying things about people that you wouldn’t say to their face is not great, or particularly above-the-line.
They offer this list of reasons why people gravitate toward gossip, or malicious gossip:
Make others wrong.
Gain validation.
Control others.
Get attention.
Divert attention.
Avoid conflict.
Avoid feeling and/or expressing authentic emotions.
Create (pseudo) alliances.
What I like about Dethmer, Chapman, and Klemp’s approach is that The 15 Commitments of Conscious Leadership isn’t about hunting out individuals who gossip, avoid candor, or refuse to embrace play. When they coach in organizations, they explore groups from a meta-level: What is it in the culture of the company that breeds conflict avoidance, diversion, and a need for control? They would say TOXIC FEAR, and that fundamental fear is what needs to be addressed and assuaged. That’s the fear keeping individuals and groups operating below-the-line.
I’ll be sharing more from the book in the coming weeks—there’s so much food for thought, distilled from other leaders in the space (I love a synthesis!), including an excellent articulation of stories versus facts, and appreciation. Stay tuned!