You wouldn’t guess this from the official creeds, but after all is said and done, doing is more important than saying. Jesus was clearly more concerned with what Buddhists call “right action” (“orthopraxy” in Christianity) than with right saying, or even right thinking. You can hear this message very clearly in his parable of the two sons in Matthew 21:28-31: One son says he won’t work in the vineyard, but then does, while the other says he will go, but in fact doesn’t. Jesus told his listeners that he preferred the one who actually goes, although saying the wrong words, over the one who says the right words but does not act. How did we miss that? — Fr. Richard Rohr, The Universal Christ: How a Forgotten Reality Can Change Everything We See, Hope For, and Believe
Those of you who have been reading this newsletter for a minute will know that I’m on a bit of a Father Richard Rohr kick. And Episcopalian priest Cynthia Bourgeault bender (our podcast episode here). And Sufi mystic Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee deep dive (our podcast episode here).

Rohr and Bourgeault are at the Center for Action & Contemplation together—and they’re friends with LVL. They are all drinking from the same mystical faucet, a faucet I find extremely nourishing. They are putting scaffolding around many things that I’ve felt throughout my life—all while establishing context around religion as it’s organized today. As someone who very much did not grow up in any faith, I find any attempt to reinterpret—or arguably, correctly interpret—original sacred texts to be illuminating and clarifying. Particularly because religion is often used as a shield for bad action—and as a projection of values that don’t seem to align with what Jesus actually said.
As I’ve been doing interviews for On Our Best Behavior, questions about my faith (unaffiliated, spiritual, agnostic) often come up. As much as I’ve written about feeling magnetized (back) to Judaism, I like my perch for the moment, as it gives me an opportunity to read widely without feeling like I need to protect any single system of belief. My book is very much about finding that inside, in the way Mary Magdalene’s gospel instructs. I think this is why I was able to write something like On Our Best Behavior in general—I grew up in a progressive, not very patriarchal family, so there were no apple carts to upset. Plus, even with my upbringing, I realized I am not immune—at all—from the programming that constrains us all.
On Our Best Behavior is about religion—its super-structure is the 7 Deadly Sins—and it’s also not about religion at all. The religious lens is important, because it marks the moment when patriarchy, typified in its earliest iterations by artifacts like Hammurabi’s code, first becomes super-charged by morality. A Judeo-Christian reality, where God is interpreted as largely masculine and the goddess is dethroned. A Judeo-Christian reality where women caused the fall down, and now we’re all on a slow, sad climb back up to heaven. (More on ascending and descending via Ken Wilber here.)
Going back to Rohr’s quote above—how Jesus was a fan of “right action” and not just saying the right things, this feels like a very contemporary ill. Social media makes it extra-easy. There’s a lot of performative talk in our culture these days—we often call it “cause marketing”—talk that sometimes lacks the follow-through of will. (I was listening to a particularly depressing episode of Pivot yesterday, where Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway discussed the failure of many DEI initiatives with corporate culture consultant Joelle Emerson, underlining that in the raft of recent lay-offs, women and other marginalized people have been disproportionately affected. And many lackluster DEI programs are now completely gone.)
There are many factors at play here—a potentially flagging economy, inflation, and more, but as we all know, there’s never been a lot of corporate enthusiasm for spending resources on these initiatives unless there’s a potential payday from the glow of marketing. I’d say there’s not a lot of enthusiasm save for companies that have built DEI into their business models from the beginning, that are founded on inclusion as a core value. (There’s a good shot that said companies are helmed by women and others on the edge of patriarchal power—though very little start-up capital goes to either.)
We also see DEI values espoused with vigor when they’re used as defensive armor, as a shield against criticism from the wider culture. This is both a watch-out for women and also an opportunity to lead. It’s a watch-out, I argue in On Our Best Behavior, because women are so susceptible to any cracks in the veneer of our perceived “goodness,” it makes us fragile and timid and defensive. Rather than taking “right action,” even if we sometimes get it wrong, or do it imperfectly, when we get scared, we tend to hide behind performance too. We’re terrified of being called out, labeled bad. We are better than this. Part of what’s required is dropping the veil of “goodness” and simply doing the things, because we understand that they’re the right things to do. As Rohr underlines, right action is the point. Besides, as I explore in the book, hiding behind claims of “goodness”—but I’m a good person!—offers no real protection, just ongoing severance from each other and ourselves. It must stop being the most important thing: When we stop giving “goodness” cultural power as the assignation we care about the most, we can be better than “good”—we can be real. And with that realness, we can become durable agents of change in the world, anchored in ourselves rather than other peoples’ opinions.
Are there times and places where you’ve supplanted “right action” with just saying the right thing? (I catch myself in this all the time and have a new rule where I can’t post anything on social until I’ve taken some sort of action myself.)
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
4/27: On the tapestries that bind with Peggy OrensteinApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/20: On coming (back) to our senses with Gretchen RubinApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/13: On losing a relationship and regaining a self with poet Maggie SmithApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/6: What’s required to ignite creativity and originality? Here’s Ozan VarolApple | Spotify | Transcript
3/30: A conversation about time with Jenny OdellApple | Spotify | Transcript
3/23: The map-maker for our souls and cosmos: Episcopalian priest Cynthia BourgeaultApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is coming 5/23, and available for pre-order now.
Friends: Pub day for On Our Best Behavior is almost here, and if you haven’t pre-ordered a copy, please consider doing it now (it’s also available in the UK, Australia, and New Zealand, with more countries being announced soon). Authors push pre-orders hard because it’s the best way to signal to indie booksellers, librarians, and algorithms like Amazon that people are excited about a book—and this is what gets the discovery flywheel going. Plus, all pre-orders count toward the first week of book sales, which is every author’s best shot at making any sort of list. Making a list keeps the flywheel going. Rinse and repeat.
I would most love for you to order a copy through your local, independent bookseller—and if you’d like a SIGNED copy (same price), you can order through mine: Diesel Books. I really, really love these guys. Someday, I’m going to do a newsletter about all the random things I’ve had them order for me over the years.