I went for a walk with a new friend the other week. She’s a therapist, and she published a book earlier this year that has done quite well—it had just fallen short of making the New York Times bestsellers list, a heartbreaking near-miss that’s a common story for authors with books that are classified for the “Advice, How-To and Miscellaneous” category—there are only 10 spots, and books like Atomic Habits, The Creative Act, and now, The Let Them Theory, can sit on there for years. (On Our Best Behavior made the Hardcover Nonfiction list, which has 15 spots and not as many permanent fixtures.)

Your best shot at “listing” on the New York Times is publication week, because all the advanced orders count toward your first week on sale. (This is why authors beg you for the pre-orders—it also indicates interest to the algorithms and booksellers, who are then more likely to carry the book and put it out on tables and shelves in response.)

As I walked with this friend, I could sense her disappointment.

“So, how are you feeling about your book?”

“Honestly? I love my book, but it’s not the accelerator for my brand and business that I expected it to be.”

Sigh. I totally get it. My friend is one of the lucky ones, too, as her book is “working” and she’s selling copies. Some books hit big and then fall away; others hit and stick; some don’t hit for a minute, or never hit but stick in their own way; and some don’t work at all. It’s a really hard business, even if you experience some success. (If you want to read some sobering statistics, in 2006, Nielsen reported that only 25,000 books—out of the 1.2 million tracked—sold more than 5,000 copies. Fewer than 500 books sold 100,000+ copies. It looks like Mel Robbins’ book has now sold 4 million copies; Atomic Habits, more than 20 million. These are total oddities!)

It’s just hard. I had a really successful launch, and still, it felt like one more brick in a wall you have to build by hand. (I wrote about my publishing day adventures here, including how I went to my favorite NYC bookstore to see my book in the wild…and I hadn’t made the New Releases table. In fact, they only had two copies, buried somewhere in the storeroom in the back. After standing there for 15 minutes while they went to see if they could find them, I eventually tiptoed out the door. Definitely right-sizing for the ego and funny in retrospect—and as I’ve learned, not unusual! Anne Lamott is really funny about this in Bird by Bird, a must-read for would-be writers.)

I offer this here because I think books are very glamorizing to people—they seem like a very big deal and very legitimizing (and they can be!), but it’s a hard road and you should be wide-eyed about it. Not only in the work required, but in what might be on the other side: Your world might not change in response. It’s not a process I’d recommend undertaking unless it feels like you’ll die if you don’t do it.

I think many people are convinced that a book will automatically grant them a platform, and a million invitations to speak—on podcasts, on stages, and so on. This might happen, but before you embark on this journey, get comfortable with the idea that it might not. You need to feel like it’s worth doing for the process itself. (I love writing books as it allows me to synthesize all of my thoughts—everything I’m hearing and reading and observing—and the process brings me legitimate joy. When I am drafting, I am in flow and I am happy; less so during the editing and marketing process.)

I say all this as someone who loves books, obviously. I’m a compulsive reader, I mostly interview authors on PTT, and I’m pushy with people who have a book in them to go write it. Books are my business: I’ve written something like 16 books at this point (I’ve lost count), though only a few under my own name: On Our Best Behavior, Choosing Wholeness Over Goodness (the workbook for OOBB, which comes out in August), and True & False Magic (I co-wrote this with Phil Stutz). Most of the books I’ve written have been as a ghostwriter, which is a totally unique experience (their material, my structure), and something I now undertake only in the most special circumstances—while it’s much easier to do this than my own projects (there’s no ego involved and I have the outsider perspective to see the arc very clearly), it still takes a lot of my energy and time.

During a recent office hours for paid Substackers about the creative process, there were a lot of questions about book writing…and I realized that when it comes to nonfiction book-writing, I do have quite a bit to share, as I’ve written in a lot of nonfiction genres (straight nonfiction, coffee table books, guide books, heavy how-to, memoir, workbooks, advice-driven nonfiction, etc.). Fiction writers, I’m sorry, I’ve never done it.

Herewith, some of my best advice.

1. Read a ton.

Many people, particularly working professionals, tell me that they want to write a book. When I ask them what books they’ve enjoyed, they often can’t name any. When pushed, I’ll sometimes hear things like, “I don’t want to be influenced by other people’s ideas and thoughts.”

This might sound judgmental, but I think it is very hubristic to A. think that you’re somehow immune from cultural influence and B. believe that your own work wouldn’t be greatly improved from reading other people deeply and widely.

I also think it’s offensive to try to pull off a one-sided conversation, or even the illusion of a one-sided conversation: The greatest thing about excellent nonfiction books (IMO) are the end-notes, and I want to see a lot of them. I want to see a vast bibliography. I believe that this is our responsibility as writers to continue the conversation with other thinkers and writers across time, and to continue to revivify the work of people who came before us.

In The Creation of Feminist Consciousness, historian Gerda Lerner (she created the first women’s studies program) writes about the fact that until recent centuries, in order to become literate, women needed to become cloistered—this means that women were writing similar things, and coming to the same conclusions. This is interesting, because they were separated (Jung’s Collective Unconscious in action), but it’s also very sad: It means women couldn’t make leaps in thinking by working together through shared experience and a communal brain. They were left to tread the same ground.

As Lerner writes about the West: “Up to the 17th century, learned women are extremely rare. We can identify perhaps thirty learned nuns in the period up to 1400, and some of the most accomplished of these, such as Hildegard of Bingen and Mechthild of Magdeburg, were unable to write in Latin. In the period 1350-1530, which is regarded by historians as a time when learned women are particularly numerous, a leading scholar on the subject, Margaret King, has identified no more than thirty-five such women in Italy. The medievalist Roland Bainton, in his three-volume work on women of the Reformation in Europe, adds no more than ten names of learned women to those mentioned by King. One can safely say that up to 1700 there are fewer than 300 learned women in Western Europe known to historians.”

We haven’t been in conversation with each other for that long. I don’t take this reality lightly and treat it as a grave responsibility to know from whence I came.

Obviously, if you’re writing a memoir, you’re not going to have end notes—but I still think it’s important to read a lot if you want to be a writer. Read critically too—look for the underlying structure, search for chapter formulas and neat tricks. Study how people effectively land their points and employ both research and story. Read for phrasing, vocabulary, and sentences that are particularly well-constructed. The fastest way to become a better writer is to read people who are better than you. Run their sentences through your brain and mouth; let yourself be inspired by great prose. It will take nothing away from your own original framing and phrasing. (Obviously, don’t plagiarize!!! And if you feel like you’ve been influenced by someone, cite them! It’s not hard!)

When my agent was shopping On Our Best Behavior to publishers, to a one, they all mentioned the fact that I’m a big reader as a selling point: Because I read so much, I intuitively understand how a good book is structured—you pick this up through osmosis by reading ones that are great, along with those that are less so.

2. Keep meticulous notes.

This might not be helpful for everyone, but I have an intense note-taking process for everything I read. As I go, I mark compelling passages and then I go back when I’m done and type them all up, with page numbers, for easy citation. Then I upload these documents to Google Drive so I can search them as I work. (This is also how I do research for my podcast.)

This enables me to read faster, because I know I’m going to go back through every book and catch the most resonant parts. It also helps me feel less intimidating when I sit down in front of a blank page. By converting the words of great writers from a beautifully designed and finished book page into a Microsoft Word document (there are programs like Scrivener, but I’m old-school) you can remind yourself that we all start from the same place: A shitty first draft, to quote Anne Lamott. A basic manuscript. (I think typing up peoples words in akin to reading a lot—you get an osmotic sense of pacing and sentence structure, for good and for bad.)

For my own brainstorms, which frequently happen when I’m walking around my neighborhood, I record voice notes, which I transcribe, or I drop things into a digital sticky note on my phone. I never expect to remember anything unless I write it down. Inspiration is often fleeting—catch it! I carry a notebook and index cards with me wherever I go!

3. Ask yourself a hard and important question: Is this really a book?

There are a lot of books out there that should have been an article. They have one main point or idea, which is then buttressed by 80,000 words. Unless you’re a huge name looking to book mill yourself with a publication every year, look for a larger idea. Keep in mind that going from idea to proposal to book deal to publication date takes years for most of us; you want to be working a dig site that feels worthy of the effort.

To that end, be honest with yourself: Are you answering a big enough question? Is this a book or is it a Substack newsletter or podcast series?* Before I landed on the meta-structure of On Our Best Behavior, I planned to write a book only about envy. My brother is a book editor and he told me to go back to the well: “That’s not a big enough idea to hold down a book—do people want to read 250 pages about envy? I don’t think so.” He was right; 20 pages about envy in On Our Best Behavior was just right.

*This can work in the other direction too; in the editing process, it can be brutal to cut parts that you worked hard on—but it will happen. Take all those parts that don’t necessarily serve the book’s primary structure and repurpose the material into a newsletter. Or tell yourself you’re going to. It makes this part easier.

4. Write a proposal.

A lot of people want to skip out on writing a proposal.* And some people can: If you’re a person with a baked in platform and you’re wanting to write a memoir, you can probably get away with a marketing plan and vision statement. (Your agent will advise you on what they need to sell it through.) A proposal typically contains an introduction, a comprehensive outline, a sample chapter, a marketing plan, bio, etc. It’s a big piece of work and you should do many rounds to make it as strong as possible. (On OOBB, I did 13!)

Embrace proposal writing as critical, even though it feels onerous and annoying and maybe inessential. Yes, the book will shift from the proposal but it’s an important part of the process nonetheless—it will clear out the cobwebs. (If you’re desperate to skip this step, it’s important to interrogate whether you really have the temerity to write a book!)

The proposal is the first forcing function for the book: Is it a big enough idea to hold a book? How are you going to pull people through your arguments? What’s your unique perspective or take? Why you and why this book? Use this time to really think through the structure: What’s the reader journey? How do all the points ladder up? You might not solve everything in the proposal but it is thinking and work that needs to be done; it will benefit your project down the line.

It’s also worth pouring your energy into a proposal because you…want to get a book deal from an editor.* And ideally, you want to get an auction going with multiple editors bidding. Not only do you want a nice advance**, but you want your editor to have skin in the game, too, as this ensures that resources are devoted to getting your book published well. The bigger their investment, the more likely this is to happen. (Math has gotta math!)

*You can also self-publish and for some people this might be the right move; I don’t know much about this process except that you can do it directly through Amazon. If you have a built-in audience, it’s possible that you’ll make more money marketing it directly in this way, though you’d need to model it out.

**For nonfiction, advances are paid out in four installments (signing, delivery, hardcover, paperback), which means they’re amortized over four years—if not more, as most people don’t deliver in a year. Very rarely do authors earn out their advances and begin to receive royalties—it can happen, but often the advance is your total take.

5. Create a really solid container.

I outline like crazy. This process begins with the proposal, and then the next round of outlining includes more deep thinking as well as input from my editor. When people tell me that they intend to start writing a book by just…writing a book, I groan. To each their own, but I can promise that you will end up writing your book two, three, or even four times over if you don’t begin with enough structure. It’s just fact. Don’t spill it out all over the page and then hope you can find the red thread. Even with On Our Best Behavior—which had a baked in meta-structure of the seven deadly sins—I didn’t have enough structure within each chapter. My editor wanted to read as I wrote but I didn’t want to waste her time (or a good edit) and so I finished a draft first…and then I needed to go back to the beginning and re-structure (i.e. write in a bunch of additional parts), making the whole process a lot longer than it needed to be. (I usually save this step with ghostwriting, I think because I’m also serving as a defacto editor/organizer for someone’s material—it’s harder to do this by yourself, for yourself.)

Plan it out as much as you can in advance. Write potential subheads for sections within each chapter before you start writing and use them to buttress your argument. Does the logic follow? (I love a subhead as they give reader’s a break who don’t have it in them to read the whole chapter—I also think they’re imperceptible in a good way.)

I talk about this at length in an upcoming solo episode of the podcast, but I think of this phase as the “masculine” part of writing: It’s the structure and order of the book. Once it’s set, I can turn on the “feminine” and just pour into the framework. I do so much pre-work and pre-processing that when it’s time to start drafting, I can write a chapter in a weekend. It’s a bit like giving birth: It just comes out and there’s no stopping it. (A few weeks ago, I wrote 25,000 words in three days—I can only do this because the scaffolding was set. In some ways, the scaffolding took three years for that three days to happen.)

6. Get a therapist.

Writing a book is emotionally hard—particularly if there’s even a whiff of memoir. I try to warn people I ghostwrite for about this part of the process but nobody really knows what I’m talking about until they’re in it. Meeting yourself on the page is difficult. Interrogating your history, your relationships, and the stories you’ve been telling yourself can be devastating. You will be spending an awful lot of time with yourself, visiting recesses of your memory and the way you’ve come to understand the world. Get yourself a therapist if you don’t have one.

This might sound melodramatic, but I’ve needed to rewrite parts of a lot of books I’ve worked on—specifically the endings. Writing a book will change you, and this can ripple into other parts of your life. Even with On Our Best Behavior, the whole structure of my work life underwent a massive and unexpected change. This isn’t a reason to not do a book, but anticipate that you will need support as it invariably happens.

7. Figure out your creative clock.

Some people get up every morning and write before their day jobs, or their kids are up. Others write all day. Others write at night. Figure out your internal creative clock and then work with it. As mentioned, when I’m ready to go, I go hard. I typically block out whole days within weeks where I am living in my book and writing for six to eight hours a day. (I can do this; some people need to do shorter and more frequent stretches.)

When I am in “flow,” I feel totally high and often, like I’m channeling. It freaks my husband out, but I can sometimes hold a conversation with him while I’m simultaneously typing. I don’t know. I’m a freak. But that’s how it works for me. Figure out what works for you and then set your calendar by it. There is no right or wrong way, we’re all weird creatures. It’s helpful for me to go somewhere outside the house to write now, though I wrote On Our Best Behavior in the corner of my bedroom (COVID). I’ve been struggling to be as productive this time around and so I joined a writing room (Max calls it “the sad room”), where I go and sit amongst other writers and silently write. (There’s no talking, it’s just desks, and outlets, Aeron chairs, and the peer pressure of looking industrious and focused. It works for me.)

I think it’s important to say that when I’m not feeling it and when I’m not in flow, I don’t even try to write. It’s just not the time. I can more than make up for periods of non-industriousness during the times when I’m on fire. I’ve learned this through practice and experience but cut yourself some slack—and experiment. There are writers who swear by a word quota and get that done every day, come hell or high water, but that doesn’t work for me. Sometimes I just need to read books, or go for a walk with a friend, or marathon Love Island. I’ve learned to give myself a break.

8. Bake time in to put your work away for a long time.

As mentioned, I can get high on my own supply. When I finish a chapter and feel like it’s “done,” I put it away for at least a month (minimum). Then I read it with relatively fresh eyes to see if the argument holds, marking up the parts of the page where I sometimes truly have no idea what the fuck I’m talking about. (Expletive required.) I also mark the chapter up where I’m boring myself, or it feels tedious or slow, or on the positive side, really exciting. I also mark it up where I’m over-quoting, as sections like this can feel like too much work for the reader, as it’s hard to switch gears into someone else’s voice as you’re processing what’s on the page. I look for ways to pare these parts down, paraphrase, and move extra quotes to the end-notes for the readers who really want to nerd out with me.

Once I think it’s in a good place, I look for trusted readers who are going to tell me the truth and ask them to red/yellow/green the chapters for me. Green where it’s flowing and they’re following my argument and enjoying themselves; yellow where they feel like it is too slow, or they’re working too hard; and red where I’ve completely lost them. My greatest readers are my brother (“Because I love you, I’m going to tell you the truth…”), my husband (he’s always nice), my mother (she reads even more than I do), my dad, and some of my friends who are unsparing/unfiltered in feedback. (Regina, Jeet, Liz, Rumaan here’s looking at you.) I do a bunch of rounds before I bring in my agent and editor in order to get as fresh of a read from them as possible.

8. Prepare yourself to meet your own resistance.

I’m going to quote from the beginning of a newsletter that I wrote a few years ago, when I was still writing On Our Best Behavior. It’s called “The Power of Resistance,” and it eventually gets into Cynthia Bourgeault and the mystical Law of Three (Affirming, Denying, Reconciling).

❝

Early this year, I sat at dinner with one of my long-time friends, Taylor, a TV writer, catching up. We chatted about our respective sons, and then the conversation turned to my book. I had received notes from my editor earlier that week asking me to restructure each chapter according to a formula and so I had spent the intervening days sitting on the floor, physically cutting my book up and taping sections back together. “Ugh Taylor,” I wailed. “I don’t want my book to be formulaic. What if this ruins my book?”

He looked at me, amused, waiting for me to finish my tantrum. “I haven’t read your book,” he noted. “But I can tell you that she’s right. What’s the note behind the note?”

I thought for a minute. “That she’s struggling to follow my argument.”

“Bingo,” he replied.

“But I am SO TIRED. I thought I was on the 90-yard line,” I responded.

“No, you’re not on the 90-yard line, you’re in the belly of the beast. You’re battling resistance, and when you get through it, your book will be so much better.” After dinner, I drove Taylor home and he pressed his copy of Stephen Pressfield’s tiny book, Do the Work, into my hands. At a slim 100-odd pages, I powered it down that night. Taylor was right: I was in the belly of the beast and it is the suckiest place to be. Chances are, if you’re a creative, you’ve been there with me, feeling like you can’t possibly put any more work into something, and that the overwork will only make the project worse. Well, six months later, I’m still working on my book, and with every spike of resistance that I’ve learned to work through, my book gets better. (And yes, I really am on the 90 or 95-yard line now.)

At various points in my life and career, I’ve also been the resistance—slowing projects down, pushing them in a different direction, or shutting them down for a re-imagining. And I’ve been able to sense how irritating this can be. “You’re too negative.” “Why are you resistant?” etc. But turning my head away, or telling someone to proceed anyway, or lying and saying that something is ready for the world, is not always true or right. And so I’ve continued to wear this mantle because it feels both honest and important. Rubber stamping our way through life is not what we’re being called to do.

As you write your book, you will meet a lot of resistance: Your own, and other peoples'. And you will resist the resistance. But this is where the greatest growth comes and where you will up-level what you’re bringing into the world. When your force meets a counter-force, it pushes the whole enterprise up—if you’re willing to do the work to reconcile these two forces.

I hope this helps. Drop any Q’s into the comments and I’ll do my best to answer them! (And no, none of this attends to bringing your book into the world—if there’s appetite, that’s a whole ‘nother mammoth newsletter.)