Writing and publishing a book is vulnerable. You’re asking the public (and critics) to appraise your talents, for one. And there are certain stories and experiences I write about in On Our Best Behavior that were previously…private, excruciatingly so. But interestingly, neither of those realities kept me up at night: I’m not afraid of criticism, or of telling stories about myself, particularly if they’re relieving for others.

What does fill me with anxiety is what I wrote about in the chapter on PRIDE: The cultural playbook that feels like an inevitable reality for any woman who dares to be seen. What goes up, must come down: The world is constantly cutting visible women down to size, lopping heads off the tall poppies in the poppy field.
I am not particularly visible, nor do I want to be, but as my book continues to sell (thank you!), and my podcast grows, I feel an increasing pressure and desire to stay connected—like superglue—to myself, to who I am.
During interviews, when people have asked me about whether I feel vulnerable and exposed, I stick to this: I am who I am, and I’m honest about who that is. It’s too exhausting—and would be contrary to the whole point of my book—to pretend to be something other than who I am. I’m trying, just like everyone else.
During my first magazine job at Lucky, I wrote a lot of cover profiles. It was a magazine about style and shopping, not hard-hitting journalism, so I was writing about these women, and getting to know them during the handful of hours we’d spend together, by crafting a story about them through their product preferences. You know, what their choice in heel height said about their soul. I remember one musician who was so nervous about alienating her fanbase by appearing too highfalutin in her fashion choices that she verbally cycled through 25 brands before committing to Juicy Couture on the page—and Crest toothpaste. It was a workout to watch her create a persona for the readers of Lucky Magazine, to craft an image that aligned with who they expected her to be.
And in my experience—observing and writing about culture for two decades—that created chasm is where the danger lies. It’s pretty scary to be out in the world exactly as you are, and so there’s a tendency to split, to cultivate two personas, or personalities. There’s who you actually are, and then who you pretend to be. It’s an instinct of self-preservation, and yet the dissonance can be felt—people can sense there’s a gap, that a mask is involved, and they will invariably, in time, hunt for the truth. Or make up a story to fill the vacuum, simply because they sense the dissonance.
This is not my reality and yet, I understand that maybe it’s an inevitability, that being yourself starts to be impossible once people begin to take notice and wonder who you are. That it becomes too excruciatingly vulnerable to expose your inner workings to the world as the gaze turns to you.
In The Soul’s Code: In Search of Character and Calling, James Hillman describes this phenomenon, writing:
“When we read in The World Almanac the name changes of the stars—Madonna Louise Ciccone to Madonna; Diana Fluck to Diana Dors; Cheryl Stoppelmoor to Cheryl Ladd; Roy Scherer, Jr. to Rock Hudson; Borge Rosenbaum to Victor Borge; Sophia Scicoloni to Sophia Loren; Thomas Mapother to Tom Cruise; James Stewart to Stewart Granger; Albert Einstein to Albert Brooks; Anna Maria Italiano to Anne Bancroft; George Alan O’Dowd to Boy George; Ramon Estevez to Martin Sheen; Annie Mae Bullock to Tina Turner—and are told the changes are made for public acceptance and commercial success, we are being fed only the human side of the reason. The other side is that you can’t be both mortal and an immortal star. You need two names because they reflect the two persons, an inherent duplicity operating between the acorn and its bearer.”
This is a powerful idea, that you can’t be immortal and mortal simultaneously, that creating your star invariably means cleaving it from your imperfect, human self and leaving it behind you as an image. I wish people understood, though, that it’s actually much safer to stay attached—to own yourself in the world, even if you’re slightly less brightly hued than the fantasy. It’s better than the gap, and better than the mask—excruciatingly vulnerable, yes, but then there’s no alternate reality to protect.