Wow, wow, wow! In the context of making our wanting clear to ourselves, I wanted to make the New York Times bestsellers list—it wouldn’t have ruined my launch if I hadn’t, my expectations were in check (or non-existent)—but I wanted to hit the list. Based on pretty strong pre-orders, it seemed like a possibility, and so my marketing partner on the book had been watching spots 13-15 for weeks. The hope was to hit the very bottom, but thanks to you all, I hit #6, right between Michelle Obama and Prince Harry. I mean…what?!?! I still can’t believe it, thank you all so much. I wrote more about this on Wednesday, but book sales are almost entirely driven by word-of-mouth. If you have On Our Best Behavior and are enjoying it, please consider dropping a review or rating on Amazon and Goodreads.
The list is funny, in the sense that the NYT weights some sales higher than others (sales at independent book sellers are more impactful than Amazon, for example). They also mark down anything that might be perceived as a bulk order (i.e., buying books as corporate gifts, or for conferences, where attendees didn’t choose to buy the book but are receiving one). Nobody quite knows how the NYT does their calculations, which makes it hard to predict whether you will hit the list and where. They also code non-fiction onto two lists: “Nonfiction” and then “Advice, How-To & Miscellaneous” which is where cookbooks and most self-help lives. The Advice list is shorter (10 spots versus Nonfiction’s 15) and it’s dominated by books like Atomic Habits, which can live there for years. (BTW, I’ve never read that book—should I?) Anyway, thank you.
How Should We Spend Our Time?
My boys share a room in our (very) cozy house—a room that they largely use for sleeping and storage. They are at that edge of age where they still like physical toys—Legos, science kits, Hot Wheels tracks—and yet are mostly drawn to the digital. Point being: It’s not a minimalist’s haven, it’s a Jenga game to get everything to fit on shelves so it’s not all over their floor. I can’t wait to usher it all out of the house someday soon, except of course for the Legos, which are really for my husband.
I spent most of Saturday and Sunday cleaning out their room, while they “helped” by insisting that I keep everything. During the festivities I found an unopened Lego puzzle. And, well, there went my week. I’m such an avid puzzler that I rarely allow myself the pleasure—I find them so addictive that I did little else this week. I tackled no books. I’m writing this newsletter the moment before I will send it.

I don’t know the brain science on puzzles, but I was thinking about how we’d likely tally puzzles in the “virtuous undertaking” column—better than the game “Match Tile 3D” which I love to play on my phone while my youngest falls asleep and I tickle his back. Why do we code some things as worthy of our time, while others are not? Is reading a physical book really so different than reading one on a screen? Why do we code reading as more righteous than watching a movie when both rely on narrative and story? (I think Temple Grandin would argue that it’s because our culture validates verbal thinkers at every turn, while deprecating spatial and visual thinkers—our podcast here.)
Both physical puzzles and Match Tile 3D are consuming for me, much like work. The chapter on Sloth in On Our Best Behavior is about the veneration of productivity, why it’s pushed even more insistently on women (we’ll never do enough, particularly for other people), and how these activities are lauded even when they seem more like addictions. Work for me, productivity for me, is an addiction—a gaping hole that threatens to swallow me even if writing the book made me much more conscious of its cattle prod-like messages. Doing a puzzle all week definitely didn’t make me feel productive—and yet I know if I hadn’t been doing that, I’d be refreshing my Amazon numbers compulsively and fretting about my next book proposal.
Writing and publishing books is a long process—from start to publication, On Our Best Behavior took three and a half years. I started the proposal in January 2020, sold it in August 2020 (my agent had me do eight rounds of revisions), and turned in my first draft in October 2021. I revised with my editor for more than a year. Galleys were printed in December 2022 and the book came out in May 2023.
Nonfiction book advances are amortized over four years—a quarter on selling the proposal, a quarter on manuscript delivery, a quarter on publication of the hardcover, and the final quarter on publication of the paperback. If you earn out your advance, you start earning money on the back-end, which can take years, or might not happen at all. So practically, there’s financial pressure to sell another book as soon as your current book goes into production. (Fiction is different—I don’t know the payment structure but you write the entire book and then sell it.) This is also why many people write one book and then are done—it’s not the easiest way to make a living!—and a vast majority of us must supplement with other work (full-time jobs, teaching, speaking, podcasting, newsletters, consulting, etc.).

I don’t have another book proposal done. In fact, I haven’t allowed myself to start another one, in part to break this grinding spell and allow myself to sit with the discomfort. I don’t have another book proposal because last October, I spent a weekend with friends—I shared a cottage with two of my best friends, Richard Christiansen (if you aren’t a Flamingo Estate fan, what are you waiting for?) and Scott Sternberg (of Band of Outsiders and Entireworld fame, RIP to both incredible brands). Richard and Scott are creative visionaries who have been very present in my life for every step of On Our Best Behavior. OOBB had just gone into production (copy edit, etc.) and so I was fretting about my next move, feeling pressured to start working on something else. I was saying a lot of things like, “If On Our Best Behavior does well enough, then I can write another book. Before OOBB comes out, I need to figure out and sell my next book so I’m into the writing process.”
They exchanged looks and then staged a mini intervention, pointing out that I was continuing to stake my future on the arrival fallacy: “If this thing happens, then I will be safe.” And that my adherence to this type of thinking was driving me (them?) mad. Scott, specifically, forbade me from thinking about another book until I had actually allowed On Our Best Behavior to live and breathe, minus any expectations about what it would lead to next. He argued that instead of busying over the experience by staking myself to the next book, I needed to sit with the journey that was already underway. I couldn’t bulwark myself against the joy or disappointment of OOBB’s reception by moving away from OOBB onto a new object: You know, “Oh, this next book will be the thing.” Scott insisted that I had to let it all unfold, and that the process would be excruciating, which was the point. As creatives, they understood that you can’t abandon what you make out of fear of its reception—you have to stay present to the entire cycle. It was a meaningful weekend, in that it made clear what I already knew on some level: I’m lacking a basic and essential skill, which is to sit with my discomfort without rushing to make it go away through work. I’m so, so good at the latter. But my productivity—and the virtuousness I attach to it—is a distraction. I don’t think I’m alone.
Speaking of distractions, yes, I distracted myself with a puzzle all week. But it was an effective way to keep me from work, from the two paragraphs of book proposal that I started on Saturday. (And yes, I have some ideas, I’ve just been holding myself back from starting to structure them on the page.) So instead of work this week, I puzzled, did a bunch of end-of-school stuff for my kids, went to see Jacqueline Novak’s insanely hilarious and brilliant show, “Get On Your Knees” (New York friends, you can see it next week—go!), and had my LA book party, where Richard installed synchronized swimmers in the pool. It was really quite a week! And I have not one bit of work to show for it. This feels like an accomplishment.