I read historian Gerda Lerner extensively when I was researching On Our Best Behavior: Austrian-born Lerner was the first to establish a women’s studies program in the States. This was at Sarah Lawrence, where she taught in the ‘60s and ‘70s. The impact of this shouldn’t be understated—as well as the fact that it was only 50-60 years ago that we’ve begun to mark women’s voices as absent from our collective history. Lerner published extensively throughout her life: She wrote an incredible book called The Creation of Patriarchy, a bestselling biography of the Grimké sisters, Black Women in White America, and The Creation of Feminist Consciousness. There are more—along with poetry and screenplays. What a mind.

I was an English and Fine Arts major in college, where I wrote my thesis about Andrew Marvell and John Milton—ultimately, about “The Fall” and loss of innocence. (My photography thesis was about female archetypes and fairy tales. I had forgotten both of these facts until I finished my book’s first draft and realized I’ve been thinking about and writing about these concepts for a long time—without realizing it.) I wish I still had my syllabuses from my English seminars and lectures, but aside from an incredible class on George Elliot (a woman who wrote as a man) and a class on Virginia Woolf and Gertrude Stein, I read very few women in class. I’ve read my share of historic and revered female writers over the years—Jane Austen, Mary Shelley, Toni Morrison, Doris Lessing, Edith Wharton, Maya Angelou, Isabel Allende, and more—but women were never at the center of my studies. I took a class on James Joyce and Ulysses every.single.year. I took multiple classes on William Faulkner. And when people asked me for book recs for summer breaks, I urged them to read Richard Ford’s The Sportswriter, John Casey’s Spartina, and anything and everything by Wallace Stegner. It wasn’t until I much later that I clocked I was almost exclusively interested in…the lives of middle-aged men. What the hell?

I didn’t fully clock it, actually, until I read Elizabeth Lesser’s latest book, Cassandra Speaks, which is about the absence of the female voice in history. (Our podcast conversation is here.) She writes about finding boxes of books in her basement—essentially “The Canon” her son had read in school. It included Machiavelli, Plato, Socrates, and many other more contemporary thinkers, with a complete dearth of female voices. She sat there, stunned by the obviousness of this discovery. But still stunned. The etymology of canon is “rule”—it’s what we’ve established as the discourse, and pass on to future generations as an authorized view of history.

As she writes:

❝

As I made my way through the basement box of books—from China, Japan, Greece, Rome, Europe, America—a few things stood out: the focus on domination and aggression; the linkage of leadership and war; and the nonexistence of women’s voices and concerns. I found myself wondering, What would it be like for humanity today if women had contributed to the theories and stories about what it meant to be a powerful person? What if the skills women had developed over the centuries had been as revered as the skills of men? What if their emotional intelligence, their relational natures, their roles as nurturers, healers, mothers, and teachers had been respected, sought after, and woven into the story of power?

There are so many problems with this (largely white) male perspective being the only perspective—it makes other voices strange, deviant, outside of the norm. It’s so overt it’s invisible. And this trickles down into our lives as we continue to see the patrician man as most expert. (I have so many thoughts about this in contemporary culture, and the way women are continually under-platformed as experts and authorities—particularly when the host of the conversation is a man.) Looking solely at gender (I know marginalized folks are hit extra-hard), I don’t think it’s anyone’s ongoing intent to exclude women and primarily feature men—I just don’t think it’s entered most peoples’ awareness that this is what they’re doing. I didn’t realize until I turned 40. As a friend remarked to me the other day, “Men are pretty much only interested in the lives of men; women are interested in everyone.”

Here’s Lesser again:

❝

A good way to measure the ubiquity of the male perspective masquerading as the human perspective is to check out the Nobel Prizes. The Nobel Prizes are awarded in six categories: literature, medicine, chemistry, peace, physics, and economics. Who we are as a species, what we value, where we expend our energy and our resources and our priorities, goals, and dreams can be charted through the development of these categories. As of 2018, Nobel Prizes in total have been awarded to 853 men and 51 women. One hundred ten Nobel Prizes in Literature have been awarded since 1901, and only fourteen of those were awarded to women. The Nobel Prize in Medicine has been awarded to 198 men and 12 women; the Nobel Prize in Chemistry to 175 men and 5 women; the Nobel Peace Prize to 89 men, 17 women, and 24 organizations; the Nobel Prize in Physics to 206 men and 3 women; and the Nobel Prize in Economics to 50 men and 1 woman.”

Some of this is predicated on millennia of educational deprivation, sure—you know, the “pipeline” conversation. Sigh. (The counter to that is that women have actually been outperforming men in school for a century.) Ultimately, it’s a much deeper and more systemic infection. Here’s Gerda Lerner, in The Creation of Feminist Consciousness:

❝

Not only have women been excluded through educational deprivation from the process of making mental constructs, it has also been the case that the mental constructs explaining the world have been androcentric, partial and distorted. Women have been defined out and marginalized in every philosophical system and have therefore had to struggle not only against exclusion but against a content which defines them as subhuman and deviant. I argue that this dual deprivation has formed the female psyche over the centuries in such a way as to make women collude in creating and generationally recreating the system which oppressed them.

“Make women collude in creating and generationally recreating the system which oppressed them.” Ooph. This, in a nutshell, is what On Our Best Behavior is about. Yes, there are ongoing issues with our systems and structures; but it’s the tendency in our psychology to collude in our own oppression that continues to keep us stuck. (And not in a blaming the victim kind of way, in a “this-goes-deep” way.)

Here Lerner is again:

❝

Women, conditioned for millenia to accept the patriarchal definition of their role, have sexually and emotionally serviced men and nurtured them in a way that allowed men of talent a fuller development and a more intensive degree of specialization than women ever have had. The sexual division of labor which has allotted to women the major responsibility for domestic services and the nurturance of children has freed men from the cumbersome details of daily survival activities, while it disproportionately has burdened women with them. Women have had less spare time and above all less uninterrupted time in which to reflect, to think and to write. The psychological support from intimacy and love has been far more readily available to talented men than to talented women. Had there been a man behind each brilliant women, there would have been women of achievement in history equal to the numbers of men of achievement.

There’s another revelation in Lerner’s book that I haven’t been able to shake: Up until 1700, there were “fewer than 300 learned women in Western Europe known to historians.” The women who were known were typically cloistered, and shut away from each other. What this means is that while men have had thousands of years to work out their stories—building on each other’s work and thought progressions to reach new levels of insight—women are just getting started. Thinking about this makes me cry.

❝

Because of the particular conditions under which women’s intellectual development took place, progression from one stage to another in this process did not go smoothly and in a pattern in which one generation built upon the achievements of another. Quite the contrary, it developed in a repetitive, circular pattern, with generation after generation of women repeating what others had done before them. Thus, women’s progress into historical consciousness was doubly delayed—by educational disadvantaging and by a lack of knowledge of the work of their predecessors. As we have seen in the case of women’s Bible criticism, women had to rediscover their history over and over again.

What historians have found from women’s early thought leadership is that these women were developing the same thoughts about themselves and the wider world but not in conversation. They were coming up with the same thoughts and theories, with no one to discuss them with. These threads were emerging from cloisters, never to meet, braid, and become something more.

I have become much more conscious in these recent years of who I’m reading, who I’m listening to, and who I’m looking to for expertise. Not that men don’t have it—but women have it too.

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:

4/20: On getting back into our senses with Gretchen RubinApple | Spotify | Transcript

4/13: On losing a relationship and regaining a self with poet Maggie SmithApple | Spotify | Transcript

4/6: What’s required to ignite creativity and originality? Here’s Ozan VarolApple | Spotify | Transcript

3/30: A conversation about time with Jenny OdellApple | Spotify | Transcript

3/23: The map-maker for our souls and cosmos: Episcopalian priest Cynthia BourgeaultApple | Spotify | Transcript

3/16: The origins of inequality and patriarchy with Angela SainiApple | Spotify | Transcript

THE LATEST POSTS:

Full archive HERE

My book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is coming 5/23, and available for pre-order now.