A few months ago, a friend and I were discussing the travails of another friend. “It sucks,” I offered. “But I did warn her that she was getting close to quicksand and that she should stay away.”

I’ve written about my role as the negative psychic before (“Calling All Cassandras”)—specifically my (not always so fun) ability in business and interpersonal contexts to have a pretty good read on how dynamics will play out (this is theoretically part of being an Enneagram 6). I’ve also written about needing more guidance about the type of feedback people want to receive when they ask for advice, because I always go straight to…my honest opinion, when people would prefer a cheerleader or to be consoled (“To Counsel or to Console”).

Back to this particular conversation, the friend on the other end of the line laughed when I followed up with a question: “I don’t get it—why didn’t she listen to me?”

“Oh, you’re funny,” she countered. “She didn’t listen because we all need to learn things for ourselves. You know that. No shortcuts.”

I thought about this conversation as I attended a No Kings Protest in Santa Monica a few weeks later and read many of the placards—particularly those from the elders in the group, who offered that they’d already lived through authoritarianism, fascism, or Nazism, and that we needed to read the tea leaves. As the George Santayana quote goes, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

Remembering is an interesting word—re + member. It comes from re + memor (Latin, mindful), although many imagine it as re + member from membrum (Latin, limb). I love the latter, as it underlines that part of the memory is somatic—it requires recalling things that have been lived, learned, and embodied. There’s no cheat for that: We might be destined to repeat things that we haven’t experienced ourselves.

It also makes me think about another etymology that I love: expert, which comes from experiri (Latin, try). There’s no circumventing what’s required to really understand, or learn, by putting yourself—and your ideas—in motion in the world. In our AI world where knowledge is now a basic commodity, wisdom becomes ever more important, wisdom born through experience.

It also makes me think of Richard Rohr’s Center for Action and Contemplation: As he explains, Action goes before Contemplation, as you don’t have much to think about unless you’ve experienced the world. Theoretical action—theoretical morality, even—is very different when it meets the complexity of reality. Our egos love to think we have it all on lock, he explains, but idealism fractures when it encounters nuance. We can’t be so certain until we’ve tried—or lived—a lot.

All of this reminds me of one of Phil Stutz’s most foundational and essential tools, The Instinct Cycle—he describes this a way to train your intuition and he’s taught it to all the power brokers and creatives who have graced his office couch over the years. In True & False Magic, which I co-wrote with Phil last year, he explains the tool at length (thus the photo with Harrison Ford above—Phil is the model for his character in the TV show Shrinking).

The Instinct Cycle is a process whereby you make a decision and take immediate action—whether that’s ordering from a menu or determining what to do with your company. In his long experience, the people who “win” are not the people who necessarily know the most—they’re the ones who work the instinct cycle the most, taking the most action. The ones who “win” are the ones who make a decision, accept the consequences, learn from the result, and then make a decision again.

As Stutz explains:

❝

“The instinct cycle is a tool to train someone to trust their instincts, because when you’re in uncertainty, that’s all you have. This is how you function when you don’t have the information—and quite frankly, you never have the information. An ability to tolerate consequences and recover is the only certainty you can have. This is why The String of Pearls is important: Identity can’t be attached to whether you’re going to win or lose. Simply, it’s the process of activating your instinct cycle and knowing you’re going to have to take the consequences—not only knowing this, but feeling good about this.

❝

“The instinct cycle is where you develop your intuition. It is an exercise that requires a committed and proactive willingness to be wrong. It’s not the person who is right the most times who is the most confident, or who trusts the universe more completely—it’s the person who works the cycle the most times. People always ask me, “Well, if there’s no logic to it to begin with, what’s the advantage of repeating it over and over?” And the answer is in its cyclicity: You’re giving your unconscious room to draw its conclusions. It’s like playing an instrument. You get better at it because it’s a repetitive action; it’s not coming from an intellectual process.

❝

“The key to the instinct cycle is that you accept the final step, which is the consequences. You will develop instinctual confidence, which means you’re confident not because of any singular thing, but because of how you conduct yourself. It’s very hard in our culture, almost impossible, to keep up our instincts, because we deny that everything is changing every second. Even if you’re right once or twice, it makes no difference. You have to be in the process of continuing to take action in an environment where a lot of times, the consequence isn’t going to be good. But if you can tolerate the consequences, even consequences you fear, you become unstoppable.”

As Stutz notes above, a key part of the Instinct Cycle is tolerating consequences—“even consequences you fear.” When I think about all the ways in which we try to red flag each other away from danger, perhaps we’re depriving people of their own growth curve. Though I guess I take faith in the fact that we don’t really heed each others’ warnings away. Live and learn, or live to learn. That’s something I can live with.

See you next week friends!