The title of this post is a line from James Hollis’s Finding Meaning in the Second Half of Life. Hollis is referring to the fact that none of us can directly see or access our shadow—that’s what makes it our shadow—though it may be plenty obvious to other people and is likely driving much of our life. As he continues, “But that which is unconscious has great power in our lives, may currently be making choices for us, and most certainly has been implicitly constructing the patterns of our personal history. No one awakens in the morning, looks in the mirror, and says, ‘I think I will repeat my mistakes today,’ or ‘I expect that today I will do something really stupid, repetitive, regressive, and against my best interests.’ But, frequently, this replication of history is precisely what we do, because we are unaware of the silent presence of those programmed energies, the core ideas we have acquired, internalized, and surrendered to.”

(If you missed James Hollis on my podcast, the episode—the most listened-to last year—is here: “On Finding Our Soul’s Vocation.”)

This past Monday, I released a solo episode of Pulling the Thread (“Are You Holding Yourself Back?”) where I dove into the admonishment from Phil Stutz in last week’s episode (“Activating Your Life Force”) to become “10% more evil.” Our conversation evolved into a bit of a therapy session at the end and Stutz was pointing out that my Part X (his description of shadow) works to keep me small by whispering in my ear that I’m exempt from marketing and self-promotion. I’ve labeled self-promotion, campaigning, and marketing on behalf of myself as bad and base and exhausting (it is) by telling myself that I’m too good for it, that my work will find its own audience in time, that “if it’s supposed to happen, it will happen,” that I can hang out in the corner of my bedroom by myself and feel like I’ve done enough—all with growing irritation (and envy?) directed toward the manosphere, as so many of those dudes have no qualm about empire building.

As Stutz told me this, I had to laugh because it is so obvious and yet, because it’s my shadow material, I’d kept it hidden from myself. What makes this extra-funny is that I AM A MARKETER by trade—this was part of my corporate life for decades, and I still do this for companies. I do content strategies as part of this, yes, but my primary gift is identifying a company’s “Zone of Genius”: Why they exist, why it’s important, and how to communicate this to audiences. And yet, and yet, I cannot triangulate enough from myself to do it on my own behalf. I’ve been refusing to accept that I’m not immune from needing to pull the same levers. Temper tantrum-ing about it really. Condemning my very trade.

I’ll be doing work on this for awhile as it’s part of the bigger layer of onion I’ve been peeling in therapy for the better part of a year (or my whole life?)—it connects to money, and scarcity, and this feeling I have that it’s wrong to seek compensation for work I value myself. That if I find it enjoyable, I shouldn’t be paid. That anything intending to be “of service” should be free. Even as I type this I recognize it’s silly—and self-aggrandizing, in its own way, particularly that last one.

To this end, to make content that’s “of service,” I currently have eight “paid” jobs—yep, eight! I write my own books, I ghostwrite books for other people, I host a weekly podcast, I write this weekly newsletter for which some people pay me, I have an ongoing consulting gig, I freelance write for publications, and I serve on two boards. This doesn’t count parenting or my non-profit/volunteer work. (Honestly, I love all of these jobs, which is a vast improvement from my 20’s and even 30’s—part of my problem is that everything sounds fun and interesting and it often is.) I have a hunch that the “more success” I encounter in the world, the more I’ll convince myself to labor—the two are so inextricably entwined in my mind.

While it’s easy to convince myself I’d have it no other way (ask my husband and he’ll tell you that I’d prefer to have 12 jobs), it is funny to be up to something so insane and to not be able to see it for yourself.

Later in Finding Meaning in the Second Half of Life, Hollis writes, “In order to enhance this passage toward a more authentic existence, it is useful to become more knowledgeable about how the psyche works. We are invited to take a different view of our symptoms. Our first, natural desire is to suppress them, but we must learn to read them as clues to the wounded wishes of the soul, or as the autonomous protest of the soul over our mismanagement. We learn to exercise a form of discipline that requires the daily scrutiny of life: ‘What did I do, and why, and where did it come from within me?’ We engage our soul’s agenda, which requires a humbled attitude, and a wary watchfulness. It requires that we understand that our lives, even when fraught with outer difficulties, are always unfolding from within. (Jung disturbingly observed that what we have ignored or denied inwardly will then more likely come to us as outer fate.) ‘So, where did this outcome, this event, come from within me?’ is a most critical, and potentially liberating, question. To ask it consistently requires a daily discipline, increased personal responsibility, and no little amount of courage.”

At the end of last year, the podcast network I’d been part of since launch changed my deal for Pulling the Thread and I couldn’t afford to stay. I pulled it out and am self-funding and building the show myself. Even though this is scary—PTT will likely be in the red for a bit, until it finds its feet with advertisers*—it also feels like a push from my soul to get serious about what I’m up to and to build something real and substantial. Part of this will require me to stop relying on “others” to provide external structure and to create this myself. (To quote my friend Emma Grede, I have an “employee mentality” and will try to find anyone to submit to as a boss even though I’ve fully worked for myself for five years.)

As part of this project of building something real and substantial, I will be thinking deeply about Pulling the Thread—both the show and this newsletter—and the promise of what it could be. I routinely hear calls for community from those of you who don’t live near people who are similarly spiritually inclined. Some of you have requested a structured course or online community. Some want IRL workshops, or workshops that are digitally accessible. All of these things are possibilities.

In my previous life as a marketer, my inclination was always to create more. More content, more story rubrics, more events, more experiences—and currently, my soul is saying do less. But do less in a more impactful way. I want to create something that feels essential and nourishing but not overwhelming—something elegant that doesn’t feed overwhelm. I’d love your thoughts about what would serve—even if your thought is that I should keep things exactly the same.)

I’m going to try this poll feature on Substack, but feel free to drop thoughts in the comments below.

Before I head out, leaving you with another essential question from James Hollis: “Of each critical juncture of choice, one may usefully ask: ‘Does this path enlarge or diminish me?’ Usually, we know the answer to that question. We know it intuitively, instinctively, in the gut. Choosing the path that enlarges is always going to mean choosing the path of individuation. The gods want us to grow up, to step up to that high calling that each soul carries as its destiny.”

Take care friends, see you next week.

*If you have a company or brand and want to sponsor Pulling the Thread, hit me up at [email protected]; if you want to support the show as a listener, consider becoming a paid subscriber to this newsletter.

Latest Pulling the Thread Episodes

Latest Pulling the Thread Episodes