Back in 2018, in the early days of this administration’s first go, I remember suggesting to a podcast guest (different podcast, different time) that it might be helpful to look at Trump as an unconscious martyr. I offered that maybe he was playing a very particular archetypal role for the collective, showing us the parts of our culture that were present but we didn’t want to acknowledge or really see. I remember likening him to a demonic aesthetician (sorry aestheticians): “He’s stripping off the foundation and giving us a really gnarly facial,” I offered. “All the stuff was there, covered up…he’s just bringing it to the surface and making us look at it so we can heal.”

This guest glanced at me, a little horrified: It was a gross metaphor, sure, but he also hated the intimation that anything about Trump could be repackaged as a positive (at the time we were speaking, they were locking up kids in cages at the border). He also (understandably) rejected the idea that he might be an (unconscious) martyr—while the intimation now is that a martyr is a self-sacrificing victim, its etymology is interesting: It’s Greek (martur), witness. This guest argued that while many more people were waking up, and many more people had found their gift and their power in the challenge of the moment, the ends for him could never justify the means: “I don’t want to glorify trauma because people are figuring out how to survive it. There’s this whole tradition of a trauma happens and people are resilient, they find their power in strength in the midst of trauma. The goal is to live in a world without trauma. The goal should be: How do we create spaces where you can find your gift, and not in the absence of your life being threatened or your safety being threatened?”

Totally fair and I conceded the point. (I did want to offer to him that I don’t know if a world without any trauma is possible, because I don’t know if growth is possible without some amount of suffering.)

As the years went by, though, I couldn’t completely shake this belief: I struggled to give our president credit for much outside of pain, and yet, as an optimist who believes in some larger spiritual construct or pattern, clearly he was playing some sort of role that must be helpful. I had to stake my faith in the idea that his presence on the scene has some larger meaning. (In some ways, it’s easier for me to give him credit as an archetypal puppet than as a soundly elected official.)

As we moved past his first term and attempted to shake it off, I happened across this paragraph about the archetype of the Trickster in ’s Hagitude:

❝

“And so Trickster can also be thought of as an archetype of the apocalypse—in the original sense of that ancient Greek word, which means revelation: ‘an unveiling or unfolding of things not previously known and which could not be known apart from the unveiling.’ When civilizations start to become moribund; when social, economic, and political systems stagnate, and empires become degenerate and unresponsive to the needs of the people, in walks Trickster to shake it all up—embodying that disruptive intelligence which all cultures need if they are to remain lively, flexible, and open to change.

“What follows after Trickster’s intervention, of course, depends on many things—among them, the specific qualities of the Trickster who happens along in the story we are living through. And although we don’t always get the Trickster we imagine we might want, we mostly get the Trickster we deserve—because Trickster is often, in Jungian terms, the one who also reveals the cultural Shadow. In the same way that the personal Shadow is the dark, unacknowledged complement of an individual’s persona, a culture will cast its own collective Shadow, which includes all the things we imagine that other cultures are, but categorically believe that ours is not—racist, sexist, xenophobic, or undemocratic, for example. Whenever a society believes strongly in its own moral righteousness, superiority, or entitlement, the collective Shadow is likely to be present in spades—and it’s then that we most need Trickster. Trickster holds up a mirror to us and helps us to see what we have become.”

Huh, I remember thinking (her book came out in 2022). That sure sounds like our last president. And then I had to wonder: Was the mirroring complete? Can we be done?

It turns out maybe not.

Despite being capped by COVID, this administration’s first term seems positively tepid in contrast to the cruelty and absurdity of the past nine months. ICE raids, military takeovers, a shut-down government including the loss of SNAP benefits for more than 40 million Americans (mostly children (40%), elderly (20%), and the disabled (10%))—all against a backdrop of an astronomically increasing wealth gap, Great Gatsby parties at Mar a Lago, the destruction of the historic East Wing for a $350 million dollar ballroom, and a peculiar obsession with a White House toilet. Speaking of toilets, our president generated and posted an AI video where he dropped fecal matter on No Kings Day protestors.

So I had to read the following passages twice from mythologist Michael Meade’s Why the World Doesn’t End, which came out in 2012:

“Tricksters play essential roles in folk myths throughout the world. They throw dirt as well as toss rocks; they play with feces and throw it at people, even at god. They keep the dirt and the earth and the earthiness in the stories of life. They appear especially when the old order of the world needs to change; they are change agents and provocateurs and wise in wise-guys ways. They bring strange and unexpected pieces of wisdom that help to kick-start creation when it has collapsed or simply lapsed in its rhythm.”

He continues, “In many native traditions, contrarians and tricksters would enter at crucial times in the most holy ceremonies. Their appearance breaks the spell of perfection and the rhythm of expectations. They might scare people a little or expose some shadow of pretense or self-importance. They might simply bend over and bare their bottoms in order to keep the backside of life more visible.”

Huh.

Here’s the thing about the depravity of this administration—and this particular president’s ability to pull our attention to his antics 24/7. We are living in the age of transparency and he is showing us—repetitively, compulsively, outrageously—what’s been present but unacknowledged. He is exploiting our system’s weaknesses and illustrating how ripe it is for mass corruption—unabashedly and overtly. Honestly, I’m finding relief that it’s not happening under the cover of darkness but is all being destroyed right in front of our faces: He won’t let us look away as he bares his bottom at us all. We can’t pretend like it’s not happening, or that iterative change will fix this, or push the boulder down the hill for the next generation to deal with.

Here’s the reality: Our system has been broken for a long time. We have corporate welfare in this country. We subsidize companies like Walmart so that its CEO can take home $25 million this year, while as of 2020, 14,500 Walmart employees rely on SNAP and Medicaid (per U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO)). Meanwhile, Amazon founder Jeff Bezos is worth $254 billion (the CEO, Andy Jassey, took home $40 million in 2024), while a May 2024 report by the Center for Urban Economic Development (CUED) at the University of Illinois Chicago found that 23% of Amazon employees relied on SNAP and 50% stated consistent food insecurity.

In 1965, the ratio of chief executive to workers’ pay was 20:1. In 2020, it was 312:1. As Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks writes in Morality, “In 2018 the chief executive of Disney, Bob Iger, received a total payment for the year of $65.6 million, provoking outrage from Abigail Disney, granddaughter of Roy Disney and the grandniece of Walt Disney. She called it ‘naked indecency.’ It represented 1,424 times the median pay of a Disney worker. It is time, she said, ‘to call out the men and women who lead us…about how low we are prepared to let hardworking people sink while top management takes home ever-more outrageous sums of money.’”

Beyond wealth inequity, we have concurrent physical health, mental health, gun safety, and environmental crises. Not to mention the chaos abroad.

The reality is that Trump didn’t create these problems—but he is exacerbating and exploiting them. And then by drawing our attention in a relentless way, he’s making it impossible to look away.

I understand the instinct to blame him—to put him in the Drama Triangle and insist that as the Villain, or the contaminating influence, if we can make him go away, we’ll find relief. But that won’t solve our problems. He’s exploding our system because we need a new one.

If we can hold him in our heads as the Trickster, as Loki, as holding up a mirror to our blind spots, we can begin to eat the cultural shadow that’s begging to be acknowledged and metabolized, and get to work on the other side. As Trickster, he is an agent of chaos, and his very specific job is to push us back into the cauldron of creativity to build something new.

After the Robber Baron Gilded Age, when we saw similar wealth inequity, we introduced a slate of progressive legislation to remodel our government. As professor Jamil Zaki writes in Hope for Cynics, “After a chaotic and painful labor, the twentieth century gave birth to a vibrant Progressive movement. Activists, workers, and civic leaders assembled into a vast array of new organizations. They built power through strikes, lobbying, and public engagement, and racked up staggering accomplishments. Here are just some of the policies passed between 1888 and 1920: women’s suffrage, the income tax, the creation of the Food and Drug Administration, Federal Trade Commission, and National Forest and Parks System, child labor laws, the eight-hour workday, campaign finance regulation, and public kindergarten.”

Similarly, after both World Wars, we saw the New Deal and the G.I. Bill and other massively formative pieces of legislation—we used to be able to respond to the needs of the people in significant and sweeping ways. We need to rebuild those atrophying muscles for the decades to come.

So, if we can see Trump as the instigator of necessary chaos for a new era of government, what can we imagine? I have faith that in the coming years we will see sweeping reforms and a gut renovation of our systems: anti-corruption laws, a severing of the pipeline between government and industry, term limits on Supreme Court justices, a regulated tech industry, campaign finance reform, common sense gun laws, universal childcare, full rights over our own bodies, environmental regulations and reparations, an appropriate tax code which ensures that the uber wealthy pay (more than) their fair share (to quote Billie Eilish, why are you a billionaire?), and that corporate welfare ceases to companies where there’s even a single employee reliant on SNAP. And more!

So as he pushes us to the edge, as more of us wake up to what we’re for (and not just against), I’m going to hold the faith that there’s something beautiful on the other side. Getting there will require acknowledging everything we don’t want to see. But we have the capacity to fight for what we love—and sustain it.