
In almost every book that Jungian psychotherapist James Hollis writes, he includes the poem “Woodchucks” by Maxine Kumin.
Woodchucks
Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedGassing the woodchucks didn’t turn out right.The knockout bomb from the Feed and Grain Exchangewas featured as merciful, quick at the boneand the case we had against them was airtight,both exits shoehorned shut with puddingstone,but they had a sub-sub-basement out of range.
Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedNext morning they turned up again, no worsefor the cyanide than we for our cigarettesand state-store Scotch, all of us up to scratch.They brought down the marigolds as a matter of courseand then took over the vegetable patchnipping the broccoli shoots, beheading the carrots.
Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedThe food from our mouths, I said, righteously thrillingto the feel of the .22, the bullets’ neat noses.I, a lapsed pacifist fallen from gracepuffed with Darwinian pieties for killing,now drew a bead on the little woodchuck’s face.He died down in the everbearing roses.
Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedTen minutes later I dropped the mother. Sheflipflopped in the air and fell, her needle teethstill hooked in a leaf of early Swiss chard.Another baby next. O one-two-threethe murderer inside me rose up hard,the hawkeye killer came on stage forthwith.
Text within this block will maintain its original spacing when publishedThere's one chuck left. Old wily fellow, he keepsme cocked and ready day after day after day.All night I hunt his humped-up form. I dreamI sight along the barrel in my sleep.If only they’d all consented to die unseengassed underground the quiet Nazi way.
— Maxine Kumin
I get why Hollis is such a fan, and why it’d be good for all of us to tape this poem to our bathroom mirrors. It’s a poem about our psychic basements, our shadow selves, and the very real parts of us that remain cloistered from the light of day. We are terrified of descending those stairs and flipping on the lights. It’s a poem about when our baser natures hijack the way we show up in the world—the way we spill our darkness onto others, even (often?) in socially acceptable ways, without taking conscious responsibility for our actions.
We are getting a masterclass in shadow right now: Our culture is swamped in it, and we are playing it out every day, on the collective stage and also in our own lives. Our souls seem to be asking: Can you own this part of yourself and integrate it, rather than project it onto the “Other”? Can you take responsibility for what you’re denying, and therefore feeding in the world?
On the cultural stage, you see Trump (and his friends) engage in daily acts of Shadow Play: Sending federal troops into blue states is a political stunt, yes, but it’s also a projection of Trump’s own fear of the “Other.” (It’s certainly not rooted in facts on crime.) The rollback on women’s rights is also powered by Shadow: A deep fear of the feminine, a fear that only becomes more pronounced with more repression. (It’s a bit like a loaded slingshot that’s being pulled back, extra-taut.) I didn’t say "fear of women”—though there’s probably some of that too, but it’s actually fear of the feminine, divorced from gender. The feminine archetype represents creativity (and death), nurturance, love, and care—all that is not rational and impossible to coerce and control. What we’re seeing in the U.S. and across other parts of the world is an autocratic rise of out-of-balance masculine energy (again, not connected specifically to gender) that’s the impulse to take complete control—it’s both generated and super-charged by this fear of the feminine.
I interviewed Elinor Dickson last week, the co-author with the late, venerated Marion Woodman of Dancing in the Flames, a book that’s been formative to my own understanding of this cultural moment. Back in the late ‘90s, they wrote: “Ironically, the very fear that led patriarchy to repress matriarchy has kept patriarchy neurotically bound in a struggle for power to what it did and does repress. What is repressed out of fear reemerges in the form of its repression. It is not therefore the absence of the feminine that should be lamented (both feminine and masculine are always already present in some form); it is the distorted forms of their presence that exaggerate the tragic imbalance between them. That imbalance undermines an entire civilization, contributing to its collapse.”
One of the reasons I love Dickson and Woodman’s work so much is that it evades easy and reductive answers: What’s happening today is far more complex and nuanced than our binary thinking would insist. As much as our culture keeps trying to push us to one side or the other, it’s not about the right versus the left (or even right versus wrong), it’s not us versus them, it’s not men versus women. Relief will come only through balance. More and more of us need to become conscious of these tricks to polarize and divide, transcending and including instead. From balance, we find growth. (This is the “Tension of Opposites” in Jung’s world: See “The Power of Resistance.”)
This also means that we don’t get easy outs, nor do we get to escape taking a piece of responsibility for the culture we find ourselves in. Woodman and Dickson again: “While we are clarifying words, we need also to note that patriarchy and masculinity are not synonymous. Female patriarchs can be just as domineering as males. Like their male counterparts, they live in a patriarchal ethos that operates through control over others, over themselves, over nature. We need to recognize also that many men have a more finely honed femininity than many women. We all are the children of patriarchy and, therefore, we all have to take responsibility for a killer power shadow that would massacre the feminine and the masculine in whatever form they manifest. This book is not a defense of the feminine at the expense of the masculine. The one without the other leads to suicide or tyranny.”
I offer this only to say that while there’s a lot of relief and feelings of safe harbor in saying I’m not like them, we’re all a lot more alike than we care to see. And we’re also all highly susceptible to unconscious mob actions, to participate in shadow play without realizing what we’re up to: This is the scapegoat mechanism, this is the energy of witch hunts (current day and ancestral), of the crucifixion, of child sacrifice, of any way that we can find to discharge our anxiety, despair, and rage on a common target. They are the contaminating influence. If this person goes away, everything will be better. These are incredibly intoxicating ideas and they’re also evidence that our shadow has come out to play. These shadowy parts must be reconciled, not eradicated.
As Hollis writes in Why Good People Do Bad Things, “How much evil, intended or not, has come from ordinary citizens being carried along on the tide of such energies? What we have denied in ourselves will nonetheless be visited upon the world, sooner or later. To be possessed by the Shadow is to bring large energy into the world. No wonder it is so often so seductive. Sometimes we are left to pick up the pieces; other times, others have to pick up the pieces for us. And none of us are more dangerous then the righteous who uncritically believe they are right, for they are the least capable of knowing the harm they bring with them into this world.”
May we each become just a little more conscious of the implications of our own actions.
My conversation with Elinor Dickson is coming soon on Pulling the Thread; tomorrow, I’ll be joined by Jungian therapist and frequent PTT guest Satya Doyle Byock (fellow Substacker (Self & Society), author of Quarterlife, childhood friend) to talk about ego and a well-developed sense of self.
Take care out there friends!