I was listening to some Carissa Schumacher tapes recently when a moment jumped out at me: She said that our essence can be governed by the gifts we have to console, or the gifts we have to counsel. Yep, two primary camps.

In the camp of the consolers, she grouped most of our healers: These people are preternaturally gifted at receiving, listening, soothing, holding space, and alchemy, i.e. processing the emotions that are emergent simply through their presence. (I put Dre Bendewald, the guest of last week’s episode of Pulling the Thread, very much in this category—along with people like Thomas Hübl.)
Counselors, on the other hand, are primed for assisting, guiding, and pointing things out—revealing what might be unseen or unsaid.
To some extent, everyone is equipped to provide both consolation and counseling, but her point was that one of these two things is primary in each of us—and that a consoler should not attempt to counsel too much, while a counselor should not be the first call when you need consoling. To that end and most insistently, she cautioned that if you’re a counselor, you are not allowed to console as a cop-out. It is incumbent on counselors—when asked—to tell the truth, even when delivering the truth is hard and it’s easier to side-step and steer the conversation into reassurance or platitudes.
I loved this stretch of Carissa transmission because it dovetails with my own experience: I’ve written previously about how many of us (me!) are not great at the empathic response—i.e. listening closely, without jumping in to advise, educate, correct, etc. I am not a great consoler, though I practice it intently, particularly with my kids who are never, ever, looking for my advice or feedback.
Carissa’s challenge was for each of us to own our essence and shepherd our gifts accordingly, but in my experience, there’s a responsibility for the receiver of all this counseling and consoling as well. When we reach out to friends, we should be honest with ourselves—and then with each other—about whether we are looking for consoling or counseling. And once we know what we need, we should go to the correct well and make our request clearly and accordingly. After all, it’s frustrating to call a friend or a parent because you need to vent and express, only to be told what you should do and why; and it’s disappointing when you ask someone you trust for advice and they sidestep the truth in an effort to save your feelings or avoid an uncomfortable conversation. Much of this is avoidable.
There’s responsibility on both sides, which might include statements and questions like: “I need your honest advice,” “I’m upset—would you be willing to hold some space for me while I vent without giving me feedback?” On the flipside, the question could simply be: “What exactly do you want from me? Consoling or counseling? Happy to just listen or give advice, you tell me what you need.”
A friend suggested that there should be a few more options here because sometimes we might not be hunting for consoling or counseling but want either cheerleading (you’ve got this!) or confirmation (your plan is the right plan). I think this is true—I’ve certainly been on the hunt for both of these before—but I’m not sure it’s a fair set-up for a friend. I think you’re inhibiting honesty by engineering the response you want: “I feel nervous about something, so reassure me it will be great.” I mean…sure, but none of us are in a position to guarantee certainty. (Aren’t I fun?) I would say, too, that when I directly ask for confirmation, I don’t feel any more secure by a confirming answer simply because I…asked for said confirmation. It’s much more validating when you open the door for feedback and what you hear aligns with your own intuition.
In all cases, the critical move is to be honest and clear with yourself about what you’re after, before you go after it. It’s not fair to ask for advice when you really just want a friend to rubber stamp the direction you already intend to take. (If you know what you want to do, you should do it, rather than trying to share responsibility!)
I was in New York City earlier this week and chatting with a good friend—he was telling me about adventures with a pathological liar, and then made an aside that trust violations are the toughest things to overcome with co-workers and friends. “You know, there are the little white lies we all tell, which are one thing, but then there are the big ones—and it’s also hard for me when I feel like people I should be able to trust aren’t giving me honest feedback.”
I asked him if he thinks he makes it safe for people to give him feedback and he pondered that for a minute—he’s intimidating! After all, being honest requires bravery and vulnerability—if you meet those who are giving you advice with anger or defensiveness, they might not attempt it again. If counseling is what you crave and yet, you can’t find it, not exhibiting a capacity to receive it might be why.
Giving and receiving feedback is hard work—I haven’t mastered it on either side. But it’s a skill we all desperate need, particularly in a world that’s experiencing a dearth of essential, healthy conflict (we’re awash in unskilled high conflict instead). I treasure my bravest friends because I know they can be mirrors when asked, and are unafraid to reflect reality right back to me—but doing this takes guts. Sacred guts. After all the etymology of advice is Latin (videre) “to see”: Sometimes our friends can see us better than we can see ourselves.
Meanwhile, to all my consolers: I salute and thank you for this all-too-rare skill. Here’s Simone Weil again: “The capacity to give one’s attention to a sufferer is a very rare and difficult thing; it is almost a miracle; it is a miracle. Nearly all those who think they have the capacity do not possess it.”
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
7/6: When women tell the truth about their lives with Dre BendewaldApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/29: Reconciling with the childhood you didn’t receive with Minka KellyApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/22: Standing at the edge with Roshi Joan HalifaxApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/15: Getting in touch with our desire with Emily MorseApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/8: Examining the myth of the linear career with Bruce FeilerApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/1: Gender as transcendent with Geena RoceroApple | Spotify | Transcript
5/25: Remodeling the world with Austin Channing BrownApple | Spotify | Transcript