I don’t recall where I heard this, likely a podcast, but I was listening to a conversation about relationships and someone remarked that they are all, by their very nature, transactional. With our closest loved ones, there’s an exchange of attention, affection, security. The currency in play is love—not money or favors or opportunities—but a current nonetheless, just an energetic one. A currency that can’t be tallied or tracked, or coerced. This is the realm of the romantic, familial, deep friendship. And then there are the completely transactional relationships—predicated on the exchange of money, opportunities, favors, quantifiable things. There’s nothing wrong with transactional relationships, either—we just get confused and hurt when we mistake them for something deeper. (More on this below.)

We like to believe that relationships founded on love don’t require negotiation. But when there are expectations that are unstated and unsaid, the dynamic in the relationship shifts over time. These covert assumptions are called “Shadow Vows,” according to Jungian therapists Elizabeth Eowyn Nelson and Anthony Delmedico, and theoretically, our partnerships are full of them—we often enter marriage with entrenched ideas about what our partner will do for us, what they’ll provide—whether it’s a paycheck, care, back rubs, an unchanging face and body, endless romance and date nights. We have many buried conceptions about how our partners will magically anticipate and meet our unexpressed needs. These are called “shadow vows” because they’re unvoiced—they might even escape our conscious awareness. From a Jungian perspective, marriage is one of the ultimate vehicles for soul evolution, where we learn about ourselves by virtue of being reflected by the other, all while in a deeply vulnerable state.

As Nelson and Delmedico write in “When left hands touch: Shadow vows and Jung’s Quaternity”:
Couples may feel the reverberations of the “basement exchange” erupt in their daily lives. They may come to realize that every stated vow is accompanied by a shadow vow: all that remained unspoken, and even unconscious, when they said “I do.” Shadow vows are the unacknowledged assumptions, agreements, and obligations each partner brings to the relationship, sourced from childhood experiences of the parents and grandparents as well as religious and cultural scripts that create a mesh of expectations, hopes, and fantasies of how two people can and should love and live with one another.
These therapists offer that conflict can offer a glimpse of shadow vows—a chance to get closer to what you might want but haven’t been able to acknowledge. From there, we learn and grow and get bigger.
Here's Nelson and Delmedico again:
In marrying, the clichéd phrase “you complete me” is correct, typologically speaking. In this case, the shadow vow taken by the couple is for them to be each other’s place holder for their inferior function. That is, the thinker marries the feeler so as not to have develop their own feeling function. They unconsciously assign it to the feeler. Of course, the feeler readily accepts because they are already a great feeler and has enough feeling function for both of them! And vice-versa. … But over the years, if they do not develop their own auxiliary functions and acknowledge each other’s inferior functions, shadow vow frustrations build and surface in enactments.
We do for others what they cannot do for themselves, so they may do for us what we cannot do for ourselves. Though energetic, it’s transactional. And unspoken.
I’ve been thinking a lot about transactional relationships lately. Working in media for 20-odd years, I’ve created a lot of them, particularly because I’ve “covered” a lot of people—shop owners, bloggers, authors, experts, restaurateurs, etc. When they needed press for themselves or their projects, I was able to provide this, always with pleasure. I have never covered anyone who I didn’t believe in. (Or anything for that matter, either—when I was at Lucky magazine, the editor-in-chief Kim France’s rule was that if you couldn’t say something nice, you don’t include. This was revolutionary at a time of high snark—maybe even the beginning of snark—in women’s media. We weren’t critics, we were enthusiasts. I’ve carried this forward today.)
I also received early lessons in transactional relationships, working at a brand that wasn’t cool until it was very cool. (Lucky was the most successful launch in Condé Nast’s history, but when it first emerged it was mocked.) We were inundated with invitations, products, gentle cajoling for said coverage. And then I went to Time Out New York for a stretch and all those publicists who were once dying to know me lost my email. This wasn’t painful because I didn’t care—but it was instructive, the transactionality made very clear. I’ve done that throughout my career, zigzagging back and forth between high-wattage brands and those that fly more under-the-radar. And now I work for myself. When I meet new people, I can pretty quickly ascertain what they want. (And many people really don’t want anything—and these days, I have very little to offer outside of conversation and book recommendations. It’s actually very liberating.)
All that said, I’ve theoretically built a significant transactional web over these decades. And as I’ve been working to bring my book into the world, I’ve been hearing that a lot: “You’ve helped so many people; surely, it’s payback time.” But maybe not. In fact, this type of thinking was actually creating a lot of anxiety and pain for me, specifically in anticipation of disappointment and resentment. As I’ve thought about it, I’ve realized that I don’t think it works that way—and shouldn’t. Not when the expectations are shadow vows, never stated, spoken, or made overt. It’s not fair to create transactional ties to people without their agreement and consent. Yet, this happens for a lot of us, all the time, in many different spheres of life—you don’t need to have a project coming that needs attention. We feel this way when we hope friends will honor our birthdays, or remember important anniversaries, or when we hope that the co-worker we helped last year will show up for us with a favor when we need assistance—so much hoping that’s never directly voiced. And when cues are missed, this hoping is followed by frustration and anger.
The other day, I was talking to a male author who I’ve interviewed before, and was interviewing again. He asked me how my process was going (his book comes out about a month before mine) and if I needed any help. I asked him how he goes about soliciting coverage from peers in his network.
“What do you mean?” He asked, genuinely confused.
“Do you just send a book and hope that they’ll read it and write or post about it?” I asked.
“No, I make a very clear ask. No biggie if they can’t do it, or didn’t like the book, or don’t feel like it’s a fit. But I ask: ‘Hi, I think this book might resonate with your work. If you feel called, would you be willing to share this with your audience?’ It’s that simple. Most people are really supportive, but no hard feelings to those who are not.”
I mean, WOAH. Occasionally women I know reach out and ask for coverage. But I’m most frequently pitched by people I actually don’t know—I’m guessing because there’s no relationship, so there’s less to lose. I receive tons and tons of galleys and books—and I can count on one hand the number of friends or women who I know who have overtly asked me to cover the book. They also never tell me how they’d like this done, or when. Never, never. It’s always just a nice card and a book—attached to nothing concrete. I wonder how many women I’ve accidentally disappointed because I didn’t pick up on the cues. Men, on the other hand, are much more direct and overt: I’m going to go ahead and say that in the transactional sphere, there’s a significant gender difference where men have no problem asking whereas women feel it’s somehow uncouth, uncomfortable, or wrong.
Fellow women, we need to take the risk and make our hopes overt. We need to say what we want and need. If the need goes unmet, no big deal—but it’s better than wondering.
To that end, I’ve released everyone from my past from expectations, and moved hope into active requests. I recognize that I’d much rather get a no, or even no response to an overt ask, then wonder why someone doesn’t feel bound by that favor I did for them in 2008. They shouldn’t feel bound. That’s not the universe I want to live in, one where payback is required, where it’s always tit for tat. I do things for people because I want to—it’s a pleasure and delight, and not laden with expectations. The etymology of favor is favere (Latin): Show kindness to.
Before I go, I will tell you that one of the great joys of this process has been the people who have shown up for me for whom I have done…absolutely nothing! I am so grateful to many. And I will say that it’s also been a joy to brainstorm with other female authors, to figure out how we can help each other, connections and ideas we can provide. Honestly, it’s been heart-warming and fun—and excellent practice in accepting, offering, and asking for support, all while making it overt.