Have any of you read Ken Wilber? I never had until I heard his name mentioned too many times to ignore—most recently in the work of Richard Rohr. Wilber is a philosopher and the creator of integral theory/psychology—he has written 35+ books, many of which are very, very long, though his ideas are so compelling I just ordered several, including The Religion of Tomorrow, which clocks in at a whopping 817 pages. Here’s why: Wilber’s genius is in his ability to collate and synthesize…everything. Literally. I just read A Brief History of Everything, which is so compelling, accessible, and clear, I powered through it in three sittings, underlining something on almost every page. I’m going to do a series about some of his revelations—in this first post, I will articulate some of the basic ideas and then we’ll go from there. (I’m also going to try to get him on the podcast.)
A Brief History of Everything is written as a conversation, and it concludes with one as well: A Q&A with Matrix co-director Lana Wachowski. There, Wilber explains how he shut himself away for three years and wrote down every system, from every tradition across the globe—biological, medical, anthropological, political, cultural, religious, spiritual, philosophical—on yellow legal pad paper. He spread them around every room in his house, stared at them, processed them, and then attempted to organize them into a single, unified theory. He couldn’t make them fit until he stumbled onto something he now considers quite obvious: They all live in a quadrant, divided by I, We, It, Its.

1. Everything (including us) is a holon.
There are some essential rules to Wilber’s system, namely that everything is a holon, a term coined by Arthur Koestler, which means everything is both whole, in of itself, and part of something else. We are parts and wholes. I am a complete person, and I’m also part of a family, part of the human species, etc. As he writes, “On the one hand, it has to maintain its own wholeness, its own identity, its own autonomy, its own agency. If it fails to maintain and preserve its own agency, or its own identity, then it simply ceases to exist. So one of the characteristics of a holon, in any domain, is its agency, its capacity to maintain its own wholeness in the face of environmental pressures which would otherwise obliterate it. This is true for atoms, cells, organisms, ideas. But a holon is not only a whole that has to preserve it agency, it is also a part of some other system, some other wholeness. And so, in addition to having to maintain its own autonomy as a whole, it simultaneously has to fit in as a part of something else. Its own existence depends on its capacity to fit into its environment, and this is true from atoms to molecules to animals to humans.” (p. 19)
2. All holons are part of holarchies.
These holons are part of a “holarchy”—a hierarchy that indicates a depth of consciousness. Everything is part of a holarchy. As he explains, “A natural hierarchy is simply an order of increasing wholeness, such as: particles to atoms to cells to organisms, or letters to words to sentences to paragraphs. The whole of one level becomes a part of the whole of the next.” (p. 24) So let’s use one as an example: Letters, words, sentences, paragraphs, books, series of books, etc. Here’s a fundamental truth about holarchies: You can destroy a more advanced layer of a holarchy (books) without impacting the levels that are simpler, less complex, less conscious. Words and sentences still exist even if books don’t. But whatever is more conscious or complex above the level that’s destroyed cannot exist (so absent books, you can’t have series of books, etc.). Destroy letters—the most basic level of this holarchy—and words, sentences, et al are done. Existentially, if humans die out, the biosphere still exists; if we blow up the biosphere, we’re done.

The quadrant makes up four different holarchies: Evolutionary paths in four different realms (and no, within each of us and within the collective, they don’t always evolve in sync). As he writes, “All of those scientific descriptions can generally be summarized as: the basic drive of evolution is to increase depth. This is the self-transcending drive of the Kosmos—to go beyond what went before, and yet include what went before, and thus increase its own depth. Consciousness and depth are synonymous. All holons have some degree of depth, however minor, because there is no bottom. And with evolution, depth becomes greater and greater—consciousness becomes greater and greater. However much depth atoms have, molecules have more. And cells have more depth than molecules. And plants have more than cells. And primates more than plants.” (p. 37)
3. All holarchies fit within four quadrants, focused on “the inside and the outside of a holon, in both its individual and collective forms.”
The top two quadrants, or holarchies, are the personal/individual, where Wilber differentiates between “I” and “Its”: He uses the example of the mind (inside) and the brain (outside). Here’s Wilber:
Let’s look to an expert on the brain itself—say, a brain physiologist. The brain physiologist can know every single thing about my brain—he can hook me up to an EEG machine, he can use PET scans, he can use radioactive tracers, he can map the physiology, determine the levels of neurotransmitters—he can know what every atom of my brain is doing, and he still won’t know a single thought in my mind.
This is really extraordinary. And if he wants to know what is going on in my mind, there is one and only one way that he can find out: he must talk to me. There is absolutely no other way that he, or anybody else, can know what my actual thoughts are without asking me, and talking to me, and communicating with me. And if I don’t want to tell you, then you will never know the actual specifics of my individual thoughts. Of course, you can torture me and force me to tell—but that’s the point: you force me to talk. (p. 78)
The difference between the bottom two quadrants—the inside and outside—is the difference between how we perceive ourselves in relation to other people (including our spiritual predilections and worldviews), versus the way that we are politically and culturally structured.
I (Upper left): consciousness, subjectivity, self, and self-expression (including art and aesthetics); truthfulness, sincerity
We (Lower Left): ethics and morals, worldviews, common context, culture; intersubjective meaning, mutual understanding, appropriateness, justness.
IT (right hand): science and technology, objective nature, empirical forms (including brain and social systems); propositional truth (singular and functional fit). (p. 104)
4. We are collapsing these holarchies, and overly prioritizing the right side, or “IT” side—diminishing the left side at our own peril.
Wilber’s fascinating view is that we have collapsed all of these quadrants. I’ll dig into this more in coming weeks, but he asserts that we’re collectively in the “rational” phase of development—some people have moved beyond this stage, but the epicenter of our culture is here. And there are also some, Wilber argues, including many fundamentalist religions, that are stuck in the magical and mythical realms. Our obsession with rationality and empiricism can turn into scientism, where we are solely prioritizing the “IT/ITS” quadrants: If it can’t be measured or studied, then it ain’t real. Wilber argues that all four quadrants must evolve; that all must be appropriately balanced.
Here’s Wilber:
Every holon has these four aspects, these four quadrants. Empiricism and behaviorism are a superior approach to the exteriors of holons. They are basically correct as far as they go. I fully endorse them as far as they go.
The problem, of course, is that they don’t go very far. And thus you often have to condemn them in the same breath, because they usually deny not only the importance but the very existence of the other quadrants. You are depressed, not because you lack values or meanings or virtues in your life, but because you lack serotonin, even though stocking your brain to the hilt with serotonin won’t do a thing to develop your values.
In other words, my depression can be interiorly caused by an absent father, the exterior correlate of which might be a low level of serotonin in my brain, and Prozac can to some degree correct that serotonin imbalance. Which is fine, and sometimes extremely helpful. But Prozac will not in any way help me to understand my interior pain, to interpret it in a way that it takes on meaning for me and helps me to become transparent to myself. And if you are not interested in that, if you are not interested in understanding your own depth, then Prozac will suit your purposes.
But if you desire to see into your own depths and interpret them more adequately, then you will have to talk to somebody who has seen those depths before and helped others interpret them more adequately. In this intersubjective dialogue with a therapeutic helper, you will hold hands and walk the path of more adequate interpretations, you will enter a circle of intersubjective depth, and the more clearly you can interpret and articulate this depth, the less baffling you will become to yourself, the clearer you will become to yourself, the more transparent you will be. (p. 85)
5. In our drive for evolution, we inherently transcend and include all holons of lower consciousness.
The mega-point in Wilber’s system is that in our drive for evolution, when we transcend our current state (moving to the next level), we inherently include everything beneath. Transcend and include. When we think about the current state of affairs, we are polarizing to a point where it feels like we will break in order to transcend and include.
The idea is that at every stage of evolution eventually runs into its own inherent limitations, and these may act as triggers for the self-transcending drive. The inherent limitations create a type of turmoil, even chaos, and the system either breaks down (self-dissolution) or escapes this chaos by evolving to a higher degree of order (self-transcendence)—so-called order out of chaos. This new and higher order escapes the limitations of its predecessor, but then introduces its own limitations and problems that can’t be solved on its own level.
In other words, there is a price to be paid for every evolutionary step forward. Old problems are solved or defused, only to introduce new and sometimes more complex difficulties. (p. 45)
Sounds like our current world, doesn’t it? More on this later, but all of the binaries that we find ourselves contemplating—Democrat/Republican, Masculine/Feminine, Gay/Straight, Male/Female—are begging for transcendence. The etymology of trans (Latin): "across, beyond, through, on the other side of, to go beyond." We are seeing this play out in the sphere of gender, but wilber calls for us to contemplate a transrational, transegoic, and transpersonal future as well. This is heady stuff (and this is getting long), so I’ll leave this conversation for now, but will pick it up in the coming weeks.
Thanks, as always, for reading.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
2/16: A beautiful conversation about friendship with the wonderful Will SchwalbeApple | Spotify | Transcript
2/9: I chatted with one of my favorite college professors, Priscilla Gilman, about being a child of divorce and the essential role of criticismApple | Spotify | Transcript
2/2: My first ever solo episode (I talked about belief vs. faith, wholeness, coming into spirituality from a secular childhood)Apple | Spotify | Transcript
1/26: Third time is the charm: Carissa Schumacher is back for another round about spiritual power, the difference between creativity and productivity, and moreApple | Spotify | Transcript