Perhaps everything terrible is in its deepest being something that needs our love. —Rainer Maria Rilke

If you’re new to this space, I’ve been writing a series of newsletters about dark energy, inspired by an accident this past summer where I fell off a horse and broke my neck. While I was fine (miraculously), I had a pretty incredible energy healing in its aftermath that introduced me to other dimensions. (You can read that full story here.) I found a lot of resonance and explication of these forces in the writings of Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee, an incredible Sufi mystic and teacher (you can hear our podcast conversation here, though we didn’t talk about dark energy). I then wrote a newsletter about understanding spiritual power and another about when communities are in shadow.
In today’s note, I wanted to explore what that darkness even is—is it “evil,” or something else entirely? Now first, a caveat: I don’t know. I know what we all know—that it certainly feels like evil forces are at play in the world, historically and otherwise. So what, exactly, are they? And is darkness even a “they”? What I’m going to argue is that everything can be transmuted and transformed, that what we’re seeing is extreme shadow, untouched and unmixed by light. (Keep in mind that “Lucifer”—equated with Satan in the Bible—means lightbearer/lightbringing in Latin.) Shadow and light, two sides of the same coin—dependent on each other for existence.
In Breathing Under Water, his book about the 12 steps, Father Richard Rohr writes: “The game is over once we see clearly, because evil succeeds only by disguising itself as good, necessary, or helpful. No one consciously does evil. The very fact that anyone can do stupid, cruel, or destructive things shows they are, at the moment, unconscious and unaware. Think about that: Evil proceeds from a lack of consciousness. Jesus also says, just earlier, ‘The lamp of the body is the eye. If your eye is sound, your whole body will be filled with light. But if your eye is diseased, your whole body will be darkness. And if the lamp within you is, in fact, darkness, what darkness that will be’ (Matthew 6:22-23). Step 4 is about creating a good and trustworthy lamp inside of us that reflects and reveals what is really there, knowing that ‘anything exposed to the light will itself become light’ (Ephesians 5:14). Somehow, goodness is transferred by radiance, reflection, and resonance with another goodness, more than by any act of self-achievement. We do not pull ourselves up; we are pulled.” I love this sentiment, particularly as it posits that we are both lamps and mirrors—capable of transforming and reflecting more light…or absorbing and projecting distortion. This feels very accurate to me, also underlining that we are containers for all of these energies, that we ourselves hold all of these polarities. I balk a little bit when I hear people only talking about light, lightness, and being lightholders—it feels like a disavowal of reality, a refusal to acknowledge voids and the harder things we experience, like death. The Taoist symbol of the yin and the yang tells us everything we need to know: There is light present in darkness, and the reverse is also true. Darkness—hard things, hard people, hard events—can be the greatest impetus for growth.
In The Signs of God, Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee, writes: “Today much of the process of purification takes the form of psychological work: confronting and integrating the shadow and other conflicting aspects of our psyche. Finding our faults is not just a process of separating the light from the dark, but also of integrating our darkness. For each of us it means taking upon ourselves the responsibility of being human. As we are taken into the realm of our own complexities, the price of self-knowledge is always more responsibility. We have to become responsible for our own darkness, for our own pain and lack of self-worth.” (p. 20) Many balk at this task, but those who engage with all of life find wholeness: And well, that’s what I think we’re all about.
This idea of responsibility is also critical—both on the personal level (we tend to project what is unhealed in us onto other people), and also when it comes to serving the whole. I interviewed Thomas Hübl, author of Healing Collective Trauma, on the podcast a few months ago, and was blown away both by his work and our conversation (it’s here if you want to give a listen). Thomas is a spiritual teacher who travels the globe to work with groups on trauma transformation—specifically the darkness and density held in physical places, across time. He works with groups to build webs of resonance where the material can come up and be processed. It might not—in fact, it most likely does not—have anything to do with anyone in the room personally, but they can still feel and access what’s there and then use their bodies to both experience and move it. As he explained to me: “On the collective level, if you just take Holocaust or slavery in the U.S. and racism, these are massive wounds. These are millions of people in concentration camps. This is so painful. And what I hear in that room is a tiny little bit of the whole, and it's so intense that there is a lot of suppressed, disassociated, split off, fragmented information, what I would say is the collective unconscious, and it's stored there. And it's being kept down by collective defense mechanisms. Because if all of that information were to arise now, I mean, I think many people would be hospitalized in mental hospitals because it's so intense. Because it'll burn us. But skillfully, as groups coming together, and having an internal process, everybody for themselves, building relational containers, co-regulative containers and building spaces that develop a certain level of coherence or awareness of themselves, of itself—that's a very powerful tool.”
Hübl sees this as incredibly important on multiple levels: Both that we need to process and not supress these atrocities so we can heal, but also because we actually need this stuck and stagnant information—both so we can internalize and learn from it (so as not to repeat it), but also because it is energy…it fuels our growth and evolution. Here he is again on Pulling the Thread:
Every trauma that gets integrated into the central nervous system stream expands the perspective. If a thousand people do that, it expands our perspective too. If millions of people do that, we just grow all the time. I call this bottom-up innovation. It's the learning that we've never had. You know, we've never had that learning because it was frozen in the ice. So when we de-ice the ice, learning starts to show up through integration. So that's innovative too. And I believe actually that the ethical learning that we have to have when we deal with the bigger wounds of the past are actually the ethical development that we need in order to deal with AI, or with nanotechnology, or with genetic engineering.
Because if the ethical development lags behind the technological development, that's dangerous, because it opens the door for another re-traumatizing cycle of abuse or misuse. And so healing is not only like a personal wellbeing factor, it's actually taking responsibility as citizens. I actually think that collective trauma work should be that a society takes care of its legacy, it should be written in the constitution. Like for the states, the immigration, the civil war, slavery and racism, the Native American genocide, and all the other wars that happened on the way, like these are major impacts that need a collective skill to integrate. And if we don't do that, generations will have individual trauma because that's what it causes later on. We'll have all kinds of abuse, all kinds of domestic violence, all kinds of health issues, physical and mental health issues.
So either we hand it over to the next generation, or we say, okay, we can do at least our part and it's a citizen's responsibility. And then I believe, yes, there is a tipping point because the more we liquify trauma, that information that's being set free becomes creativity. And so not only do we release some of the past and harvest its learning and become wiser, we also liberate a lot of creativity to build a different world then the old structures that we have, that we see are not functional anymore. Because it makes us more fluid. And I see that we are in the face, as you started the conversation, like a lot of stuff is coming up because we see two things. We see that data is accelerating through technology and the data is accelerating in consciousness in our nervous systems.
There’s something really important to Hübl’s work and it’s the fact that it’s collective—groups working together for the collective good. While I believe that we can and must caretake our own shadow, we are not supposed to take on darkness alone, unless we’ve been trained (more on this below).
In Falling Upward, Father Richard Rohr directly addresses this idea of facing or fighting evil, pointing out that one of the guiding tenets at the Center for Action and Contemplation (which he leads with Cynthia Bourgeault), is this: “The best criticism of the bad is the practice of the better,” which he learned from St. Francis, writing of him that he “did not concentrate on attacking evil or others, but just spent his life falling, and falling many times into the good, the true and the beautiful.”
Falling Upward is about the wisdom gleaned for the second half of life, when we learn how to do “better” after the formatory experience of the first half. Rohr explains that with time, “You do not fight these things anymore; they have just shown themselves too many times to be useless, ego based, counterproductive, and often entirely wrong. You learn to positively ignore and withdraw your energy from evil or stupid things rather than fight them directly. You fight things only when you are directly called and equipped to do so. We all become a well-disguised mirror image of anything that we fight too long or too directly. That which we oppose determines the energy and frames the questions after a while. You lose all your inner freedom. By the second half of life, you have learned ever so slowly, and with much resistance, that most frontal attacks on evil just produce another kind of evil in yourself, along with a very inflated self-image to boot, and incites a lot of push-back from those you have attacked. This seems to be one of the last lessons to be learned.” (p. 118) I’m going to write more about this book in the coming weeks and months, it’s very, very beautiful. I particularly love this idea that the second half of life, if we’re lucky, delivers us into a “generative” personhood, where “one…is eager and able to generate life from his or her own abundance and for the benefit of following generations. Because such people have built a good container, they are able to ‘contain’ more and more truth, more and more neighbors, more and broader vision, more and more of a mysterious and outpouring God. Their God is no longer small, punitive, or tribal. They once worshiped their raft; now they love the shore where it has taken them. They once defended signposts; now they have arrived where the signs pointed. They now enjoy the moon itself instead of fighting over whose finger pointed to it most accurately, quickly, or definitively.” Once again we go back to this idea of people as containers.
But, back to evil—or more simply, darkness. According to Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee there is a primordial darkness, the existence of which just is. As he writes in Light of Oneness, “Evil is one effect of darkness on human consciousness, but evil is not the fundamental purpose of this energy. Darkness itself just is. While the darkness of our personal and collective psyche can be transformed, we cannot integrate or transmute the powers of real darkness. They originate in a different dimension and follow different laws.” Before we get deeper into this, LVL first describes the essential nature of this darkness, without which we could not live. He writes: “Some level of distortion will always exist in this reflection of light, because in this world nothing is perfect. In fact a small degree of distortion is necessary to bring light and love into manifestation. Without distortion the energy would not be accessible; it would be too fine, too pure to be assimilated. However, if there is too much distortion, if the heart is not pure enough, then the disciple will be unable to reflect it, and the light can be damaging. Instead of being reflected out into the world, this powerful light can become caught in the ego structure and psyche of the disciple, where it can unbalance her. It is important that the light be reflected outward, and not get caught in the ego.” (p. 26-27) Again, we’re reminded that we are lanterns, mirrors, containers—ultimately processors of energy who then spill it into the world, reflecting light or darkness wherever we go.
LVL then goes on to explain how we need energies, even darker ones, to unlock our full creative potential—anyone who has gone through anything difficult (i.e. reached Rohr’s second half of life), will understand what he means. Here he is:
Through this inner work we clean the room of our psyche, creating an inner space that can receive the light of the Self. We gain more access to our instinctual nature and a greater sense of our wholeness. In alchemical symbolism, we are turning lead into gold, releasing the energy hidden in the depths. This work of transforming the darkness of our psyche is an important stage on the journey. It leads to an awareness of our collective shadow, to that which has been denied by our whole culture. As we work in the depths, we are able to redeem what has been abused and rejected, and not only take responsibility for our personal well-being but make a real contribution to the whole. These steps are necessary to the evolution of consciousness.
But the real powers of darkness do not belong to our personal or even our collective psyche. We rarely directly encounter these powers in our journey of self-development. And yet they are always present, influencing us, absorbing our own light.
The powers of darkness are real and they demand our attention. As we step out of the limited horizon of our individual self into the dimensions of light, we will also encounter realities of darkness. We can see the imprint of these forces in the pages of history, in the horrors enacted by humanity. There have been times when forces of light and darkness have appeared to battle upon the world stage, as in the war against Hitler and the Third Reich. Then Europe was covered by a dark cloud in which the light was hardly visible. The advent of collective terrorism carries a similar stamp, a primal disregard for life and an archetypal fervor.
The powers of darkness work through human weakness. Just as light needs the vehicle of our sincerity and steadfastness, darkness uses our prejudices, often racial or religious, to activate violence that is within us. We can see the effects of darkness through the cycles of despair, ignorance, and hatred it incites in individuals and communities.
Doing battle with the instinctual forces of destruction as they are activated and influenced by darkness exposes us to an even greater danger: the potential for darkness to absorb our light, thereby limiting our access to what is higher. Without our inner light we are more easily caught in the darkness of ignorance and the unconscious, where destructive forces can dominate us. Without any inner light to guide us, we are easily swamped by the undifferentiated and amoral forces of the unconscious that have no real humanity.
If one looks carefully at acts of extreme cruelty or violence, one can see that the light of humanity has actually been lost. This is what we have come to describe as “evil.” The absorption of light leads to acts of evil, as the core of light that balances the primal darkness of our personal and collective unconsciousness is taken from us. In this case, light has not just been drowned in violence, cruelty, or religious fanaticism. Rather it has been absorbed—it is no longer present. This is the danger of real darkness, and this is what distinguishes it from the usual circumstances of ignorance or aggression in which our light and understanding are often hidden but never lost. In our world of reflected light there is always the choice between good and bad, light and dark. But just as in the world of pure light there is no duality, no reflection, only the light of His love, the real darkness also takes us beyond our relative realm of duality, of choices. The darkness absorbs our individual light and we lose our free will.
…
As humanity begins to awaken into an expanded consciousness of oneness and to take responsibility for the whole of life, we will begin to have access to the ways of darkness. We will learn to differentiate between the effects of ignorance and the effect of absorption of light. And we will learn to work with real darkness as a force in the universe that requires our attention and our respect, in ways that come from awareness rather than fear, that do not engage us in conflict or battle. (p. 95-98)
I know this all sounds quite terrifying—particularly the absorption of our light (rather than the covering over, which can be healed)—but LVL urges us not to be afraid. Particularly because there are those amongst us who understand what exists beyond duality—and the absolute nature of this unmixed, untransformed shadow. He concludes: “Mystical consciousness has long known of the existence of this darkness. As mystics ‘keep watch on the world and for the world,’ they know the influence it has on the world. Their work of witnessing is a detached awareness, combined with compassion for the effects of darkness. But although the darkness causes so much suffering, once one has seen its real nature one has a deep respect and awe, recognizing in it the imprint of the Absolute. Pure darkness requires respect; otherwise we will remain its victim. We have realized this in our interaction with the unconscious, whose demons require respect if we are not to be dominated by them—it is dangerous to dismiss the monsters of the deep, the dragons of the inner world. Accepting the divinity of darkness, we do not need to turn away from its power, because we stay within the protection of the One who is all. The power of consciously aligning with the divine protects us with His energy.” (p. 99) I very much respect this idea, which underlines the point I made at the top about the tendency of many of us to extol the light while ignoring the shadow. We must dance with both, while keeping ourselves safe. Or perhaps, we leave that work to the mystics.
LVL: “Only the mystic who is not frightened of nonexistence can approach the darkness without fear of destruction. One who has been absorbed in love can encounter forces that would damage anything created. Free from the opposition of good and evil, the mystic has passed through the ring of fire that keeps humanity within the sphere of cause and effect. Protected by both the darkness and the light of love, the mystic recognizes that everything belongs to the One. We may have fear or awe before this aspect of the Absolute, but we are surrendered to That which is beyond light and darkness. And there is work to be done with the powers of darkness. There is an energy that is needed to help humanity, an energy that belongs to the dark side of God.” (p. 101)
It’s hard to imagine what this energy is, but going back to the words of Hübl, I have to wonder if it’s one of our jobs here on earth to properly use what we are given—to not disavow the darkness but to understand how to transform it into “creativity,” to quote Hübl, to an extended understanding and evolution of consciousness. Perhaps this is ascribing morality to this darkness, or a purpose that it doesn’t claim, but I have to believe it serve a function, that it is matter or material that must be used up rather than suppressed.
Who really knows. (As always, curious for your thoughts.)
Thanks, as always, for reading.