Oh, Mother’s Day. Another day during which women get to feel conflicted. I mean, I get it. I don’t really relish Mother’s Day—it’s typically a day like any other, which is honestly okay with me. After all, it’s a fabricated holiday, coined by a woman named Anna Jarvis in the early 20th century to honor her mother, Ann Reeves Jarvis, who organized “Mothers’ Friendship Day” in 1868 to foster reconciliation between Union and Confederate soldiers after the Civil War. Anna Jarvis herself never married and never had children, and she actually petitioned to have the holiday removed from the official calendar after it became commercialized. (A woman who was raised by her dad after her mother died during childbirth moved to create Father’s Day almost immediately after Mother’s Day was institutionalized, though it did take many decades for it to become recognized.)

What’s interesting to me about the holiday is how many of us feel bad about it, and how these feelings of badness have escalated over the years—or perhaps they’re more pronounced because of social media. We feel bad, because if we’re mothers, we likely find the day slightly embittering (sad deli flowers as some sort of compensatory measure for a year of largely invisible labor just feels bad…basic, ongoing gratitude feels better). We feel bad, because if we’re mothers, we’re reminded how many women want to be and aren’t able to become moms (yet). We feel bad because those of us who have living mothers are reminded that some peoples’ moms are on the other side, and are greatly missed. We feel bad because if we have a great mother, we’re reminded that some people had ones who were difficult, distant, mean. And now, with waning bodily autonomy and movements to forcibly remove the freedom to choose happening across the country, we’re reminded that while we might have chosen to have children, many women are now being forced to become mothers, despite not wanting to (or having to risk their lives in the process).
I have never seen a man post on Father’s Day that he feels awkward celebrating his dad because he wants to honor all the men who had absent or tough fathers. Or that he feels self-conscious being celebrated publicly because he does not want to trigger all the men struggling with infertility. This just doesn’t happen. I’m not sure if it should or should not, but its absence feels remarkable.

I don’t think men wrestle in the same way as women do with feelings of “badness” and consequently “goodness.” I don’t think they’re particularly concerned with being called out as insensitive for not taking everyone’s feelings, however complex, into consideration. (I don’t actually think they’re even much thinking about these things.) Being a woman is awfully hard. We struggle to cut ourselves and each other slack. If there’s something to police ourselves about, we rush to do it, before someone does it on our behalf.
I wrote about my mother a fair amount in On Our Best Behavior—and she’s become an object of fascination for my publishing team. (They want me to interview her for Pulling the Thread, stay tuned.) I wrote about her for a piece coming soon, too, which I’ll share with you later this week. In a nutshell: My mom is fascinating, brilliant, and complicated—a box of See’s Chocolates doesn’t really do the relationship justice, or what she’s done for me. Neither does one day a year. And I chafe at the idea that it should.
Switching gears for a second, I spent part of this week with a friend named Courtney Smith, who coaches the Enneagram. (She’s a Yale Law school grad, has a Masters in Public Health, majored in mathematical engineering, and is a former McKinsey consultant—gah! She really makes me work to keep up with her intellect, but she also makes me laugh really hard. And can I say how much I love it that she took a hard left turn into esoterica?) We stayed up really late one night talking about the most helpful frameworks in her practice and she took me through the dynamics of the Drama Triangle, which I’d heard of via Roshi Joan Halifax’s Standing at the Edge, but have never studied.
Halifax designates the three triangle tips as “persecutor, victim, rescuer” though Courtney uses a slightly less subtle triad: “villain, victim, hero.”
It’s an incredibly useful frame for evaluating relationship dynamics, including those with parents. You’ll see that in dysfunctional families, often there’s a hero child and one who is a scapegoat, with one parent playing victim and pitting the two kids against each other. Courtney’s point is that very easily—without our conscious awareness, and without a lot of present dysfunction—we can become entrenched in this pattern, particularly when someone in our midst is highly attached to victimhood. Invariably, there’s a need for this victim to triangulate—someone needs to be the “hero” to help coordinate an attack on the “villain.” Or at the very least, to protect the victim from the villain. My guess is that if you think through your most dramatic relationships and/or irreconcilable conflicts, you’ll find this dynamic in play. It might be present even in relationship patterns that aren’t all that dramatic at all. It’s really hard not to engage: We automatically rush in to help.
It’s a good pattern to be conscious of, because it’s very human. When we feel attacked or victimized, it’s natural to take those feelings of badness and project them onto the person who is making us feel bad. Sometimes this is deserved. Sometimes it’s not. Sometimes blaming others is a complete cop-out, as choosing victimhood means you can sidestep taking responsibility for your own emotions. I write about this at length in On Our Best Behavior, in the chapter on Anger.
I’m still working through the Drama Triangle and all of its implications, but my conversation with Courtney was eye-opening. And maybe she’ll join us here for a Q&A if you all would find it handy.
Roshi Joan Halifax’s take on it is also helpful. This is from Standing at the Edge:
The Drama Triangle maps the roles people become caught in as persecutor, victim, and rescuer. Typically, the drama begins when a persecutor antagonizes a victim—or when a victim perceives or even seeks out an attack by a persecutor. Feeling threatened and disrespected, the victim solicits help from a rescuer, or a rescuer volunteers to fix the situation. Rescuers usually believe they are acting from a place of altruism, but often it’s a pathological form of altruism that is an ego enhancement for the rescuer and keeps the victim dependent.
She goes on to explore the Five Gatekeepers of Speech: 1. Is it true? 2. Is it kind? 3. Is it beneficial? 4. Is it necessary? 5. Is it the right time?
And then adds:
Thich Nhat Hanh interprets the Buddhist precept of Right Speech with these words: “Do not say untruthful things for the sake of personal interest or to impress people. Do not utter words that can cause division or hatred. Do not spread news that you do not know to be certain. Do not criticize or condemn things that you are not sure of. Always speak truthfully and constructively. Have the courage to speak out about situations of injustice even when doing so may threaten your own safety.” Right Speech is courage speech. Speech that is compassionate and fearless is grounded in authentic respect. It is also one of the ways that we can step out of the Drama Triangle.
Right Speech is hard for women, particularly in a world that looks to penalize us for pushing against the status quo. It is hard to stand out. It is difficult to do things differently. But we have to start interrupting all the cultural conditioning that makes us feel “bad.” We have to stop clinging to exterior ideas of “goodness” as a protective shield. And we have to start telling the truth, even when it makes us uncomfortable—particularly when it makes us uncomfortable.
As you’ll discover if you read On Our Best Behavior, my mom is not afraid of the truth. It’s one of her most dazzling qualities. On this Mother’s Day, I honor her and thank her for telling the truth about her life—because it’s allowed me to tell the truth about mine.
There’s more from to come on this topic, but this Mother’s Day, I hope all women do something for themselves. And give themselves a break.