I didn’t think much about religion growing up. Or, more precisely, I thought about it as a no-fly zone for my mom, the third rail—she grew up Catholic and felt stung, to put it lightly, by the church. We attended Jewish services sporadically (in a Methodist church), but that felt like a low-key commitment, a way to stay connected to my dad’s family, even as they’re largely scattered. My dad is an only child—he has some family in Israel and some in South Africa, where he grew up. His father ended up there from Germany; his mother from Poland. Like many other Jews, he’s part of a diaspora—and in turn, my brother and I are untethered as well.

I went to see Rabbi Steve Leder a few months ago to talk to him about Judaism and whether I should join a Jewish community, even though I’ve always felt rejected by the faith (because my mom is Catholic and Judaism is matrilineal, I never felt like I qualified—he told me I did). We talked about many other things that day, and I asked him why he thinks I’m drawn to Judaism when my container for faith is a bit wider than the Torah (I’m into a lot of “ascended masters,” and their corresponding wisdom traditions and teachings).

“Well, he offered, Judaism is a religion, yes, but it’s also a tribe.” Ah. That clicked for me, as there’s always been something deeper for me at play here than conceptions of God, the universe, nature, et al. The bigger question for me in this search for a very comprehensive, expansive context is: Where do I belong? What is my culture? And why do I feel so unmoored? In wanting to understand the metaphysical patterns of existence, I’ve primarily wanted to understand my place within the big, poo-pah container. (Is poo-pah even a word?) I’ve often felt that by having no substantial, official affiliations, I belong nowhere.

I don’t think I’m alone in this search for belonging. One of my spiritual teachers, Carissa Schumacher, argues that belonging is actually “a longing to be,” and by “be,” I think she’s talking about that vertical access, that connection to something much larger than ourselves. (The horizontal axis is our daily lives, or ideally, how we spill the vertical into the horizontal—you can see a video I made about this here.) This longing is a desire to feel completely ourselves, to strip off social programming about who we’re supposed to be. This longing is a desire to experience ourselves as entirely whole.

But that wholeness needs to be grounded by something, somewhere.

I interviewed Jules Blaine Davis, a.k.a. the Kitchen Healer a few months ago, and she said something that I’ve been thinking about since: “I'm forever in recovery around what it looks like to nourish my deepest life inside a culture that is so hungry that doesn't know how to model this, reflect this, or show me how to do this. So I’ve got to learn how to do this on my own.” Inside a culture that is so hungry. I feel this intently: What is my culture? And is this a personal yearning, or do we all lack a collective culture, outside of those of us who have enduring traditions passed down by families of origin? I recognize that for many, religion likely plugs this hole.

In the piece I wrote for O Magazine earlier this month—“The Journey from Wellness to Wholeness”—I explained that the world of Western wellness, where many of us attempt to find ourselves, is largely appropriated. I wrote: “We are meaning-making people, though, and we needed these principles to add up to something more than rudimentary health principles. Absent our own rituals and traditions, we borrowed from cultures around the globe: yoga, meditation, and Ayurveda from India; acupuncture, cupping, and gua sha from China and other Asian and African countries; Reiki and forest bathing from Japan; and most recently, plant medicine and shamanic journeying from Indigenous people across the world, many of whom have been displaced.” After all, what do Euro/Western traditions add to this mix? Aside from gadgets, psychotherapy, and labs? (In recent years, it feels like wellness—which felt feminine as its inception, a response from women who felt ignored, steamrolled, and gaslit by the medical establishment—has become increasingly mechanized and masculinized with its trackers and bio-hackers.)

I was talking about the implications of this absence of healing rituals and traditions with Pilar Guzmán, the new editorial director of Oprah, the other week—trying to stumble my way toward why there’s been such a paucity. And then I had an a-ha moment that might seem obvious to most: We have little in healing arts to offer because most of our healers were burned at the stake during the European witchcraze (1500-1700). While we’ll never know the exact number of (primarily) women who were murdered, records estimate that it’s between 80,000 and 100,000. For context, 25 people were executed as part of the Salem Witch Trials here in the U.S. I have a lot more to say about this moment of time in my book and the way I believe it continues to reverberate in our lives, but suffice it to say: Matrilineal lines were broken, and much knowledge was lost. Healing became part of patriarchy, masculinized, paternalized—and criminalized. As Barbara Walker writes in The Crone, “By the fourteenth century, the church had declared war on female healers, stating that if any woman cured sickness without having studied medicine at a university, she was a witch, and must die. The catch was that women were not admitted to universities, which were largely controlled by the church and patronized only by men.” And professor Anne Barstow elaborates in Witchcraze, “Through healing, by both spells and potions, delivering babies, performing abortions, predicting the future, advising the lovelorn, cursing, removing curses, making peace between neighbors—the work of the village healer and her urban counterpart covered what we call magic as well as medicine. This work overlapped dangerously with the priest’s job as well.” When European women were forcibly removed from healing, we lost more than essential intelligence—we became severed from our inner knowing as well. Instead of looking to ourselves, we were trained to look outside—to “experts,” to “authorities,” to a God who was a man.

I believe spirituality is to religion what wholeness is to wellness—religion and wellness offer an externalized ideal, some sort of “target” to achieve, a system of beliefs—while the former stand for the practice of faith, the path that actually must be walked: Spirituality and wholeness represent living the vertical in the horizontal, of being, while religion and wellness stand for the doing. And while we’ve historically rushed to the doing for permission to be, it might be leading us farther astray—to a place that feels ever more dislocated and confused.

The call instead is to reconnect to that internal knowing. To start where we are. To turn inwards and then reattach to where we came from. And I don’t just mean spiritually. I mean physically, materially, as well. That longing for ritual and tradition is real—the disconnection, or severance, that many of us feel from our roots is not insignificant. We are looking for the sacred ground of the cultures that forged us—for me, that’s likely the pull of Judaism—not so much that we can adopt a culture’s beliefs, but so that we can understand where we came from. I’m tired of feeling like tumbleweed. I want to be rooted into the earth, to belong to something concrete, something that literally matters (the etymology of matter is stunningly, mother). Like Jules, I want to be anchored and then nourished, that hunger soothed.

Thanks, as always, for reading.

Thank you for reading Pulling the Thread with Elise Loehnen. This post is public so feel free to share it.

I’ve been hard at work porting all of my Instagram content over to Substack—you can find all my Words with Elise etymology videos here (like matter, abracadbra, and care), therapy modality explanations here (I.F.S., EMDR, and more), and book notes as well (here’s Dahlia Lithwick’s Lady Justice, Gabor Maté’s The Myth of Normal, and Marshall Rosenberg’s Nonviolent Communication—the rest are coming as they’re time-intensive). Full story archive HERE.

THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:

1/19: A rollicking conversation about the importance of breath with mega-bestselling author, James Nestor

1/12: An exploration of paradise with one of my favorite decoders of the world, Pico Iyer

1/5: The incredible Sufi teacher and mystic, Llewellyn Vaughan-Lee

THE LATEST POSTS:

An oldie I rediscovered that relates to this week’s newsletter: Tend to the Part of the Garden You Can Reach

Full archive HERE

My book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is coming 5/23, and available for pre-order now.