If you’ve been reading my newsletter for a minute, you might have a sense of my long history with horses. I grew up riding in the woods with my brother and then did long-distance endurance rides (a bit like marathon-ing) with my dad. I had an amazing black Arabian named Ebony, who obviously qualified as my best friend. Ebony re-fractured his leg while I was on him—we were trotting along when he rolled his foot on a big round rock about a mile from the finish line of a fifty-mile ride in Western Washington. I never rode him again. Though he was ultimately okay, this was so traumatizing that I didn’t really get on another horse for 30 years, until a few years ago, when I returned to it with ardor.

As part of my return, I had to do some healing around Ebony and the responsibility I felt for his injury, which officially qualified as an accident, a fluke, bad luck. But to my twelve-year-old self—nay, my forty-year-old self—this was my fault. I’ve never been good at understanding the line between responsibility and over-responsibility. I wrote about it at some length here, but the fascinating thing about horses is the question of who has the power: As I wrote last year, “They give you the illusion of control—you have the reins after all—but when you’re going flat-out, or swimming a river together, or climbing a mountain, there’s really no mystery about who is in charge. And yet, faith must run in both directions, as well as trust. And broken trust—that I was responsible for Ebony and Ebony got hurt—is what I needed to address.”
To put something of a bow on it, I was riding very fast on a horse last year who was trying to go even faster when I lost my stirrup, came off, knocked myself unconscious, and broke my neck. Miraculously, I was sore but fine, and spent a month in a brace before I was cleared to get back on a horse, which I did. (I wrote about the experience here and here.) It’s funny to me that thirty years later, someone got hurt (me), and again, there was no one to blame—certainly not the horse. I could find no responsible party. I found some grace for myself and Ebony in the experience: After all, riding is risky business.
Even during the thirty years when I did not ride, the animal that I most identified with was the horse. I have horse totems and figurines everywhere and a lot of horse jewelry. When the The Horse Whisperer came out, I had a “Duh, can’t everyone talk to horses?” response. But six or so years ago, right before my brother-in-law Peter died, a woman told me that my animal is actually a black panther. I’ve written about this a fair amount too, but the presence of this cat shows up in my life again and again with enough synchronicity to assure me that it’s real. I also love cats—and the idea that I have a panther, a predator, guiding me through life from a clifftop perch gives me some comfort. After all, my beloved horses are prey. As someone with an anxiety disorder, perhaps I shouldn’t identify so strongly with a fear-based, energetic creature that is essentially a large walking feeling who is ready to run.
A few years ago, Carissa gave a teaching about our vehicles, and how we need to resist the urge to conflate our vehicles (careers, jobs, projects, relationships, children) with our dharma: She argued that when we lose our vehicle, outgrow it, need a larger one, send it off to college, get dumped, we then feel like we’ve lost our entire identity. Meanwhile, we’re simply being pushed to evolve, get bigger—we’re snails on the hunt for new snail shells. (More about this here.)
Last week, Carissa returned to this teaching, arguing that our commitments are what tether us to our vehicles. They are the knots that bind/bond us to our work, our children, our containers for our lives. She used a lot of horse metaphors—after all, we were gathered on a ranch with horses—but she made the point that sometimes we’re no longer the driver, sometimes we’re no longer the horsepower, and our vehicles, our carts, come to drag us, using the tether of commitments to keep us attached.
Often, we stay attached because of feelings of obligation (different than loyalty) or because we’ve made a commitment not for the commitment itself—but for its potential outcome. “I’ll put in my time, so that ____ happens.” “If I do this, then they’ll think to give me that.” “If I stick it out in this relationship, maybe we’ll get married and have kids.”
I’ve felt this at moments during my life, certainly, but what was most striking to me while I listened to Carissa explore vehicles and commitments was this idea of the plough horse, the cart horse, the work horse—the horse being dragged by the cart it once hauled. I remember being a young magazine editor at Condé Nast and hearing about a socialite/editor at one of the big fashion magazines saying to an editorial peer something to the effect of: “There are two types of women in this building—show horses like me, and work horses like you.” Ouch. (She might have called herself a race horse, this was 20 years ago and a story I heard in the cafeteria, but you get the idea.)
How many of us are work horses, pulling the cart of a corporation’s dream? I would argue all, if not most, at various times of our lives—it’s essential endurance training to learn how to pull toward a collective goal, to learn the pacing and the road. And sometimes it’s really nice to leave the responsibility of driving and piloting to someone else, to know your basic duty and do it. Ultimately, the question becomes: When is that service through joy, and when does it become servitude through suffering? When is the bit and the bridle just too much to take on again? At a certain point in our lives, I think we all hit that point where we have to resist the bit—or our spirits will break.
A few weeks ago, my chronic hyperventilation resurfaced with a vengeance. It’s mostly been gone for the past few years—I’ve had a bad day or two here and there, but nothing acute. I credited this primarily to therapy, palette expansion through an ALF appliance, and limited travel, which means less sleep-deprivation in general, but this recent attack came out of the blue. I could credit it to no specific event outside of the mounting sensation that it’s time to take my next step—and yet, as I wrote last week, I know I can’t move forward until I step into the void.
I was thinking about all of this last week during the journey—about my hyperventilation, my fatigue, my tendency when I get scared to find something to attach to (as it were, I was contemplating taking on a very worthy ghostwriting collaboration to buy myself some time). But as Carissa spoke, as I thought about my worn-out work horse self, I knew my breathlessness was a warning sign that I was careening toward self-violation: I don’t think I can be a plough horse again.
At the end of the journey, Carissa told us that we each have Shakti, or soul force, and we also have Chi, or inner strength. This Shakti comes from the divine (the vertical), and from our ancestral lineage (you can’t take it with you, and you seed it to others when you go), whereas our inner strength is the vehicle for bringing this Shakti into the world (the horizontal). Ideally, these are balanced forces—those with Shakti but no Chi struggle to materialize what they “bring down,” whereas those with Chi but no Shakti can be wildly charismatic and powerful in the world, and dangerous for it, because they’re not connected to the divine.
As we settled into our final meditation, I saw my black panther—and then I saw my black horse. I felt palpable relief and grief, taking the horse’s appearance to mean that I was finally being entrusted with him again. And then I had a revelation: My Shakti was my panther; my Chi was my horse. My horse had returned to me, but under the veil of protection of my Shakti: He would ride for no one else, and only under her watchful eye. May I entrust myself to their dual wisdom and discernment, if only so I can breathe again.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
9/28: Cultivating our Presence with Thomas HüblApple | Spotify | Transcript
9/21: Thinking our way to health with Ellen LangerApple | Spotify | Transcript
9/14: Contending with panic with Matt GutmanApple | Spotify | Transcript
9/7: Understanding psychological safety with Amy EdmonsonApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/31: On What We Can Become with Kate BowlerApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/24: Why Do We Expect Life to Be Any Other Way with Nora McInernyApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/17: The Science of Heartbreak with Florence WilliamsApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/10: What We’ve Chosen to Forget with Baratunde ThurstonApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/3: Accepting the Invitation with Frank OstaseskiApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My New York Times bestselling book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.