My dad is a pulmonologist, and when I was a kid, he came to my grade school to scare the sh*t out of us about the perils of smoking. (He threw in chewing tobacco for good measure, as chew was—and probably is—very popular amongst Montana teens.) He took us through a terrifying slideshow of tarred lungs and mouth cancer, asked us never to start with nicotine because we likely wouldn’t be able to stop, and then bid us adieu.

Even though my dad only ever forbade me from two activities—smoking and motorcycles—I still tried them both. (Sorry dad!) Fortunately, I didn’t take to either, but the fact that I was a very compliant and rule-abiding and hyper-conscious kid suggests that we’re all inclined to try things for ourselves, even things we’ve been told will likely kill us and break our parents hearts. Not only are humans inherently curious, but we like our autonomy—and we learn through experience. Plus there’s social norms and peer pressure and all of that.

Now, my dad wasn’t wrong to scare us, particularly about smoking. This is really the only cultural approach we take when it comes to warning people away from things. We try to control people’s behavior by stoking their fear: Fear of consequences, punishment, disapproval, social rejection, death, etc. It just hasn’t proven to be all that effective.

When I was in my 20s in New York City, one of my closest friends smoked a lot—maybe more than a pack a day. I mentioned to her that maybe she should quit, and she responded that she didn’t think she should bother, as she’d already signed her death certificate. I asked my dad about it and he responded that no, no, the lungs recover quite quickly—particularly in younger people who don’t have emphysema (irrecoverable). Even for heavy smokers, when they stop, their risk of cancer reduces to non-smoker levels after 10 years. This shocked me, and it shocked my friend enough to inspire her to quit. She’d always assumed, as I had, that if you start and get hooked, you’re screwed—stopping might prevent more damage, but you’re bound to what you’ve already got.

After this revelation, I had to wonder why lung recovery isn’t sold up-front, as in, “Hey kids, you’ll likely try smoking. Try not to, it’s gross and highly addictive, but we get that you probably will anyway. If you do get hooked, though, know that all is not lost and your lungs will recover. Stopping sooner rather than later is always better. Smoking less is helpful, too.” I didn’t know this at the time, but this is a version of, or adjacent to, harm reduction.

While harm reduction (needle exchange programs, methadone/suboxone/antabuse, etc.) is now a proven strategy for saving lives and helping those with substance abuse disorder recover, these types of efforts have met a tremendous amount of resistance and stigma in the culture. This is because the thinking goes that anything gentle, loving, and not absolutely restrictive is inherently enabling, that a hard line, do this and die, or do this and go to prison is the only way to prevent or stop use. Again, fear makes us reach for control—to submit to the idea that other people have autonomy is too much to bear when we would really just prefer for them to do it our way, on our timing. Ignore our preferences and suffer the consequences.

Throughout my career, I’ve done a lot of content and hosted a lot of podcasts about addiction. Like almost everyone else, this is a topic that’s very close to my heart, and I’ve spent a lot of time trying to understand its mechanisms and theories. Yet, when I started to work on the special four-part series on addiction I just hosted on Pulling the Thread, I was stunned by all that I didn’t know, specifically about recovery. I had fully bought in to the dominant cultural narrative: People struggling with substance abuse must hit rock bottom (absolutely not necessary, better to avoid), intervention is a proven strategy (it can be very harmful and counter-productive), supporting a loved one in addiction means you have the disease of codependency and are an enabler (research strongly suggests that involving family and friends significantly increases odds of improvement), treatment is always required (as it turns out, most people recover without treatment), and if you don’t attend AA meetings, you’re doomed to fail (also not true).* And here’s the most shocking insight: Addiction isn’t a life sentence. Most people struggling with substance abuse do recover—in fact, they simply “grow out of it.” (I interviewed Maia Szalavitz in the series, who writes prolifically in Unbroken Brain about substance abuse as a learning disorder.)

(*That said, if you’re in AA and it works for you, that’s wonderful, truly—I know there are some incredible groups out there and it definitely seems worth a shot to find one you like if you’re trying to get well.)

After doing this series, I really have to wonder how many people think they can’t get clean, or stop drinking, because they’re sold on a single idea of recovery that they cannot access, afford, or don’t resonate with, or convinced they’ll fail because the odds are stacked against them. Or, more likely, don’t know if they really have a problem, or don’t want to think about whether they have a problem because they don’t want to stop drinking or using forever. What I learned, through talking to Holly Whitaker about recovery, Dr. Carl Erik Fisher about addiction binaries, Maia Szalavitz about harm reduction, and Dr. Carrie Wilkens about what actually motivates change, is that there are myriad pathways to sobriety, including functional moderation for some. And that these paths shift over time (a lot of people start with moderation as a goal, and then decide to embrace abstinence in time).

If you’re not all that interested in addiction, but curious about change, then tune into the final episode of the series, a conversation with Dr. Carrie Wilkens, who is the founder of Center for Motivation and Change. While CMC primarily applies their evidence-based approach (CRAFT) to supporting those with substance abuse and their families, it applies beautifully to all aspects of life. As she writes in Beyond Addiction:

Here’s to more of that in 2024: May we give each other grace, space, kindness, compassion, latitude, and a plethora of options. May we turn off the control and fear spigot and turn on our love and faith—understanding that what might not make sense to us, must make sense to them, and that change is an inside job.

Know a friend who might like or need this series? Please pass it on.

Here are the episodes, available wherever you get your podcasts.