Everyone is marked; each of us is singular. For the soul the idea of mediocrity is meaningless. —James Hillman, The Soul’s Code

I believe there’s a strong desire in each of us to be seen—and perhaps to be celebrated for our talents—even if we can barely admit this desire to ourselves. I write about this a fair amount in Pride in On Our Best Behavior, specifically the weird double-bind of wanting to be perceived as “good” and high-achieving, while not seeming to want attention…you know, the danger of being called out as an attention whore. (Funny how that phrase is gendered. Here’s an etymology video I made about whore, which comes from Horae, Aphrodite's celestial nymphs.) Wanting attention is bad; deserving attention is maybe okay? I’m still not sure.
I often wonder if this instinct and the conflict it generates—“I need to express myself fully” and “don’t look at me while I do it”—is gendered, or if some men feel it too: I think women want to be good, to meet expectations without making anyone feel bad, or “less than,” whereas men are comfortable with excellence and its implications. (The etymology of excellent, excel is excellare (Latin), “to surpass.” It’s laced with the idea of being “better than,” superior, rather than just “your best.”)
I was what you would probably call a gifted child—eager to prove myself in all realms—though with the constant admonishment to “not get a big head.” To me, there was always a demarcation between doing well, doing my best (the expectation) and then the spotlight and the stage. The former felt essential, like I had no recourse, to disobey would be disappointing, and in some ways a disavowal of self; the latter, on the other hand, felt full of risks.
Building off last week’s newsletter on tapping into creative potential, I believe, or actually know, we’re all uniquely gifted—and it’s incumbent on each of us to bring our talents to bear. But the way that these talents and gifts are apprised by society, the way we’re distinguished from the masses, well, that’s culture. It’s our culture that adjudicates what’s worthy of being esteemed, what has value. And our culture typically values and prioritizes masculine ideals of power and dominance. (Women are celebrated for “beauty” and qualities of “goodness,” which are typically attached to ideas of selflessness, along with servanthood to those who are “in the world.”)
As mentioned, I’ve been thinking a lot about James Hillman’s The Soul’s Code, which is a Jungian exploration of how each of us carries a daimon—a seed of self, a guardian angle, a genius point, an acorn—a daimon that must be expressed.
Here he is:
The talent is only a piece of the image; many are born with musical, mathematical, and mechanical talent, but only when the talent serves the fuller image and is carried by its character do we recognize exceptionality. Many are called, few are chosen; many have talent, few have the character that can realize the talent. Character is the mystery, and it is individual.
What determines eminence is less a call to greatness than the call of character, that inability to be other than what you are in acorn, following it faithfully or being desperately driven by its dream. Many heroes and heroines of this century, like Bradley, appeared in mediocre circumstances with hardly a hint of their rising star. Nixon, Reagan, Carter, Truman, Eisenhower—many whom we vote for, listen to, watch on TV—might have lived lives like our own, unblessed by the sun, their feet stuck to the shady side of the street. And yet they were singled out.
The acorn theory states that each of us is singled out. The very fact of eachness presumes a unique acorn that characterizes each person. Sun or shade, each has a character. In rare instances, the acorn shouts loud and clear at an early age. Musicians often hear the call first: At six Pablo Casals already knew piano and organ music; Marian Anderson gave her first paid performance (she earned fifty cents) at eight; Mozart, of course, and Mendelssohn too; “even before Mahler could stand, he would hum tunes he had heard”; Verdi’s father, to stop his son’s pleading, acquired a spinet for Giuseppe, age seven; Tchaikovsky was pleading already at age four.
These are the examples that show, and show business shows this best. But most times, the angel does not shout, and instead governs the slow and quiet revelation of character.
The front half of The Soul’s Code offers profiles of exceptionality—the rare talents who blossomed despite circumstances (or because of them). But most of the book is a call to “normal” civilians, to peel back childhood trauma and cultural programming to access the deeper parts of who we are. To look past the artifacts and experiences of our lives to understand who we’re called to become.
Hillman writes a fascinating chapter on “Bad Seeds”—profiles of Hitler and serial killers—before turning to the idea of mediocrity. The chapter is fantastic, offering the idea that mediocrity is a socially created concept and an inherent fallacy: No two of us are alike, nor are we supposed to be. And yet, we’re extolled to stand out.
Here’s Hillman again:
These writings look at styles of relating, at social customs, at the tiny daily accomplishments of courage that shift the values of a culture, at the moral trials, at the ideals expressed, to show the subtleties of individuality apart from what went on around the emperor’s throne. For character we look as much to the soldier’s letter on the eve of battle and the families at home away from the action as to the plans laid out in the general’s tent.
These revisions of biographical and historical writing aim to display individual souls amidst the mess of events. Their underlying theory is the same one I would like to claim here: Character forms a life regardless of how obscurely that life is lived and how little light falls on it from the stars.
Calling becomes a calling to life, rather than imagined in conflict with life. Calling to honesty rather than to success, to caring and mating, to service and struggle for the sake of living. This view offers a revision of vocation not only in the lives of women or as viewed by women; it offers another idea of calling altogether, in which life is the work.
As long as we regard people in the terms of earning power or specific expertise, we do not see their character. Our lens has been ground to one average prescription that is best suited for spotting freaks.
Our sociology, psychology, and economics—that is, our civilization itself—seems unable to estimate the worth of people who do not stand out. Such people are relegated to the mediocrity of average intelligence in middle America. That’s why “success” takes on such exaggerated importance: It offers the only way out of the limbo of the middle. The media pull you out only when you are weeping after tragedy, raging onstage, or posing for an opinion; then they drop you back into the melting pot of undifferentiated mediocrity.
To say it quick and plain: There is no mediocrity of soul. The two terms do not converge. They come from different territories: “Soul” is singular and specific; “mediocrity” sizes you up according to social statistics—norms, curves, data, comparisons.
Kapow. These paragraphs feel so profound to me. Hillman addresses two sides of the coin: Sharing and developing our gifts, and then craving recognition, which is “the only way out of the limbo of the middle.” This perfectly encapsulates why the pull of the latter inspires so much ambivalence: The avenues for recognition are informed by cultural ideas and ideals of “earning power” and “specific expertise.” They are founded on a quest for power, dominance, and excellence, not so much on quality of character. And if we follow Hillman’s acorn theory, the development of our character, the alignment with our calling, might be why we’re actually here. We valorize CEO’s and cultural “freaks,” to quote him, while overlooking all the people who much more directly impact our days—you know, the kindness of strangers.
Hillman’s points also underline why, for me, social media is so fascinating and so democratizing. Remember Star Search? I remember the unassailable idea as a child that talent would always be discovered, that cream rises to the top, that if you had it, the world would know it. We now recognize, of course, how immature and silly that thinking is, how colored by privilege. The game, naturally, is rigged, and previously, even more so: Star Search informed the consciousness of my generation, at least, and so it’s fascinating to watch that fantasy be unspooled by TikTok and Instagram. Now everyone, theoretically, can show their star and be judged by an algorithmically accessible audience, not just a panel of experts—though as Hillman warns, in the push toward exceptionality, it’s easy to lose sight of the point: “Character forms a life regardless of how obscurely that life is lived and how little light falls on it from the stars.” Sometimes the light distracts us from the work, sometimes the light disguises what’s actually important and essential.
I get that it’s easy for me to say this—Sarah Lyall wrote a profile on me for The New York Times that published yesterday, so that’s a lot of light falling on me at this moment in time—but maybe that gives me a unique vantage point to offer that recognition doesn’t change anything materially, even if it is entrancing. I’m certainly not done with my work, or my becoming.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
8/17: The Science of Heartbreak with Florence WilliamsApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/10: What We’ve Chosen to Forget with Baratunde ThurstonApple | Spotify | Transcript
8/3: Accepting the Invitation with Frank OstaseskiApple | Spotify | Transcript
7/27: Contending with Fear with Jakki LeonardiniApple | Spotify | Transcript
7/20: Our Collective Psychological Development with John Churchill, Psy.DApple | Spotify | Transcript
7/13: Understanding the WiFi of the Body with Lauren RoxburghApple | Spotify | Transcript
7/6: When women tell the truth about their lives with Dre BendewaldApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/29: Reconciling with the childhood you didn’t receive with Minka KellyApple | Spotify | Transcript
6/22: Standing at the edge with Roshi Joan HalifaxApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is out now.