I published an Op-Ed in The New York Times today, a thrill on any day. But this piece is particularly close to my heart, because it’s about my mother, and me, and in some ways, my grandmother too. The piece is about my mother’s ambivalence about mothering, and her willingness to give this a name. It’s about what it means to pass this ambivalence down unprocessed, from generation to generation.

The comments are fascinating and instructive and many are worthy of their own newsletters—there are many readers who found resonance, there are beautiful personal narratives, and there are some people who intended to be instructive and sometimes scolding (“you sound like you need therapy,” “your mother might be a sociopath,” “how can you be angry when you have so much privilege?”).
This one made me laugh:

And I really loved this insight from Todd, who is from “Earth” and not, I don’t know…from “Mars.” No Todd, I’m actually not “confused”—I’m quite clear.

Putting Todd aside, I’ve heard from a lot of men in my life this morning in really beautiful ways, saying that the piece cracked open new insight into their mothers and wives. Because this is where I think feminist men have sometimes been confused: The systemic practicalities of being a mom weigh on us, but the psychology of it buries us.
Let me say that again: The systemic practicalities of being a mom weigh on us, but the psychology of it buries us.
This is what On Our Best Behavior is about—the gap between our unequal culture and how we enforce the inequity in our lives. It’s about those voices in our heads extolling us to be good, be better, behave—voices that corral and curtail our lives. For those who don’t hear these voices (i.e., primarily powerful white men), it can be hard to understand.
Yes, we must rail with all of our might against our pitiful and deeply inhumane systemic structures—the lack of paid family leave and dearth of high-quality, affordable daycare for one. And yes, we must demand that our partners, if we have them, pick up the slack in childcare and chores, in the vein of Fair Play (which, admittedly, is its own form of invisible labor). But that’s not enough: I know, for me at least, and I’m guessing for many of you, the most piercing pain isn’t that I do more cooking and cleaning. It’s that I do a lot and still feel like it’s not enough. Because this is in me. Deeply.
Here are two recent examples: I’m writing this from a plane, on my way to New York City for an event tomorrow. I land at 8pm, work tomorrow in the city, and then head to the airport after the event, to take a 10pm flight home, landing at 2am. Then, two days later, I fly back to New York City for my book launch.
Why am I doing this instead of crashing on my brother’s couch for the duration? Because we have a parent-teacher conference for one of my kids on Friday morning before school, and I want to be there in person and not on Zoom. And then I want to pack my kids for a camping trip they’re going on while Rob and I are in New York. Is this slightly insane and bad for the environment? Yes. Is anybody telling me I need to do this? No. But I would feel too bad to just stay in New York, and so I’d prefer to vanquish this bad feeling with my presence.
There was also that part of me that desperately wanted to bring my kids to New York for the launch next week so that they could participate in some way. My husband refused: Not because he wasn’t happy to take them to the Natural History Museum and Rockefeller Center while I do press, but he knew that having them there and being unable to be with them would make me feel too bad.
“You’d be texting me all day to check in, to see what we need, and to tell me that you feel bad you’re not with us.”
He’s right.
My greatest hope for my piece today, and my book, is to crack open this conversation because I don’t think I’m alone. And I hope men read my book too, because I think it might shed light on something that women feel deeply and men don’t understand: The conditioning that functions like a cattle-prod in each of us, pushing us to do more and be more, because we feel we’ll never be enough. We can start to dig ourselves out by open and frank conversations and supporting each other to do the same. And then, may we fight together against the inequities that practically hold so many women down.
THE LATEST FROM THE PODCAST:
5/11: Navigating marriage and attachment with Stan TatkinApple | Spotify | Transcript
5/4: The best strangers in the world with NPR’s Ari ShapiroApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/27: On the tapestries that bind with Peggy OrensteinApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/20: On coming (back) to our senses with Gretchen RubinApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/13: On losing a relationship and regaining a self with poet Maggie SmithApple | Spotify | Transcript
4/6: What’s required to ignite creativity and originality? Here’s Ozan VarolApple | Spotify | Transcript
3/30: A conversation about time with Jenny OdellApple | Spotify | Transcript
3/23: The map-maker for our souls and cosmos: Episcopalian priest Cynthia BourgeaultApple | Spotify | Transcript
THE LATEST POSTS:
Full archive HERE
My book—On Our Best Behavior: The Seven Deadly Sins and the Price Women Pay to be Good—is coming 5/23, and available for pre-order now.
Friends: Pub day for On Our Best Behavior is almost here, and if you haven’t pre-ordered a copy, please consider doing it now (it’s also available in the UK, Australia, and New Zealand, with more countries being announced soon). Authors push pre-orders hard because it’s the best way to signal to indie booksellers, librarians, and algorithms like Amazon that people are excited about a book—and this is what gets the discovery flywheel going. Plus, all pre-orders count toward the first week of book sales, which is every author’s best shot at making any sort of list. Making a list keeps the flywheel going. Rinse and repeat.
I would most love for you to order a copy through your local, independent bookseller—and if you’d like a SIGNED copy (same price), you can order through mine: Diesel Books. I really, really love these guys. Someday, I’m going to do a newsletter about all the random things I’ve had them order for me over the years.